What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (27 Viewers)

I sent this guy in my league a trade offer. He doesn't reject it but makes a counter. I reject it tho.

Next the guy sends me back the offer I sent to him originally.

Is this a common thing for ppl? To me, in the long run this seems like a losing negotiation strategy. Just trying milk every bit of value out of every member of the league every single time. Its just going to come right back.
Sometimes I'll do that because I really don't want to make the initial trade even if it looks good on paper. A kind of "make this impossible for me to say no to"
 
I sent this guy in my league a trade offer. He doesn't reject it but makes a counter. I reject it tho.

Next the guy sends me back the offer I sent to him originally.

Is this a common thing for ppl? To me, in the long run this seems like a losing negotiation strategy. Just trying milk every bit of value out of every member of the league every single time. Its just going to come right back.
Could be a feeling out process if you haven't played with this guy long term. Unfortunately a majority of FF players want and expect to win every trade decisively. That's fine except don't expect much action in a league where players are competent.

I did 3 FFPC dynasty startups and in one of them, I get really bad offers from one team on a weekly basis. So bad I don't even bother countering, just reject. Got another one on Tuesday, so I countered with an equally stupid offer that benefits me. Will continue that trend until he gets the point.
 
I sent this guy in my league a trade offer. He doesn't reject it but makes a counter. I reject it tho.

Next the guy sends me back the offer I sent to him originally.

Is this a common thing for ppl? To me, in the long run this seems like a losing negotiation strategy. Just trying milk every bit of value out of every member of the league every single time. Its just going to come right back.
Sometimes I'll do that because I really don't want to make the initial trade even if it looks good on paper. A kind of "make this impossible for me to say no to"
I have a guy I’m in several leagues with and he’s done this a few times.

Reject offer, next day change his mind and re-offer the same trade I proposed. No change.

One of those times I made the worst trade of my life, wish he’d have never changed his mind.
 
FFPC one QB:

Gave: Mahomes and Deebo

Got: Tet McMillian

Starting rebuild process after a nice 13 year playoff run. Picked up Mahomes for $1 back in FA back in 2017 and drafted Deebo at 1.12 in 2019. Got my moneys worth, will miss Mahomes but have Drake Maye. Believe Tet will be a star.
 
I sent this guy in my league a trade offer. He doesn't reject it but makes a counter. I reject it tho.

Next the guy sends me back the offer I sent to him originally.

Is this a common thing for ppl? To me, in the long run this seems like a losing negotiation strategy. Just trying milk every bit of value out of every member of the league every single time. Its just going to come right back.

Several guys in FFPC leagues do this. I've sent an offer I feel is pretty fair to both sides, it gets rejected and countered, and I'll respond, "Thanks, but my original offer was fair," and reject with no counter. A little later, the other guy will send back my original offer.

Sometimes they DON'T reject my original offer, but they send me a counter. If you don't feel strongly enough to reject my original offer, and there's a chance you'll accept it, why would I accept your counter that's worse for me?
 
so far today...
12t SF PPR - gave a 2026 late 3rd for Flacco

14t SF TEP+0.5 - gave later 1st + some younger scrubs (savion Williams, Horn, Mitchell Evans) for Deebo + Hock & got him to throw me a 4th

14t sf TEP+0.5 (diff league) - gave 2027 1st + j wright for Devonta + Mariota
 
so far today...
12t SF PPR - gave a 2026 late 3rd for Flacco

14t SF TEP+0.5 - gave later 1st + some younger scrubs (savion Williams, Horn, Mitchell Evans) for Deebo + Hock & got him to throw me a 4th

14t sf TEP+0.5 (diff league) - gave 2027 1st + j wright for Devonta + Mariota
Nice work here.

Really hate giving up '27 1st's .. but Slim reaper is legit. Hopefully, and i assume, you made that trade to go and "get it"
 
12 Team SF 0.5ppr TE premium start 10

A small one but I’ve had this offer sitting in my inbox for a while

I get Jennings for Tillman

I should do this right ? I feel like Jennings might come on strong now he’s getting healthy so the depth might be very helpful, he’s more likely to be a good plug in than Tillman will be ROS. I really believe in Tillman though, maybe Browns get a better QB next year.

I’m 6-3

QB : Allen/Hurts/Brissett

RB : K Williams/Irving/Dowdle/Dobbins/others incl Mixon

WR : Amon-Ra/Devonta/Deebo/Jamo/Godwin/Tillman/Coker/others

TE : Kelce/Frieirmuth/Grey


It seems like the correct win now move
 
I made a trade a few days ago that did not play out well this weekend. Wouldn't have mattered this week regardless and I do like what this does for my team long term, but the G Wilson 0 hurt in more than just this one spot. (I did not start Bill in this one BTW)

FFPC SuperFlex

I gave Kittle, 2026 1st (late)
I got G Wilson, Bill
 
I made a trade a few days ago that did not play out well this weekend. Wouldn't have mattered this week regardless and I do like what this does for my team long term, but the G Wilson 0 hurt in more than just this one spot. (I did not start Bill in this one BTW)

FFPC SuperFlex

I gave Kittle, 2026 1st (late)
I got G Wilson, Bill
and then today in same league:

FFPC SuperFlex

I gave Jefferson, Shaheed
I got Burrow, Q Johnston
 
12 team Superflex and TE Prem

Contending team where RB was my weakest position (Gibbs, Harvey, not much else…). Well stocked at WR/TE.

Gave: Tre Harris, Michael Mayer, 2026 4th (late)

Got: Chase Brown
 
14 Team ... 0.5 PPR

Two trades went down...

Gadsden and Late 2026 2nd
for
Late 2026 1st

Hurts
for
Brissett, 2026 Projectes Late 1st, and 2027 Projected Late 1st
 
12 Team PPR Superflex League

Team A: Jameson Williams
Team B: 2026 1st (late), Isaiah Bond

Team getting 1st is rebuilding/current 1.01, team getting Williams strong 1st overall
 
I made a trade a few days ago that did not play out well this weekend. Wouldn't have mattered this week regardless and I do like what this does for my team long term, but the G Wilson 0 hurt in more than just this one spot. (I did not start Bill in this one BTW)

FFPC SuperFlex

I gave Kittle, 2026 1st (late)
I got G Wilson, Bill
and then today in same league:

FFPC SuperFlex

I gave Jefferson, Shaheed
I got Burrow, Q Johnston
SF I’m taking Joe but fair.
 
12 Team PPR Superflex League

Team A: Jameson Williams
Team B: 2026 1st (late), Isaiah Bond

Team getting 1st is rebuilding/current 1.01, team getting Williams strong 1st overall
Did something happen to juice William's value? He's worth a second at most
depends on your league I guess but where I have JW I’m not considering anything less than a 1st. I expect top 24 stats RoS.
I own him and I don't see it happening. I'm going to ride this train til the floor falls out, but I expect him to go 1/4 maybe as soon as today.
 
12 Team PPR Superflex League

Team A: Jameson Williams
Team B: 2026 1st (late), Isaiah Bond

Team getting 1st is rebuilding/current 1.01, team getting Williams strong 1st overall
Did something happen to juice William's value? He's worth a second at most
Touchdowns in three of four. Efforts being made to get him the ball. I’d move a late first for him 🤷‍♂️
 
12 Team PPR Superflex League

Team A: Jameson Williams
Team B: 2026 1st (late), Isaiah Bond

Team getting 1st is rebuilding/current 1.01, team getting Williams strong 1st overall
Did something happen to juice William's value? He's worth a second at most
Touchdowns in three of four. Efforts being made to get him the ball. I’d move a late first for him 🤷‍♂️
I was the team acquiring Jameson here.

I feel an early 2nd is probably a more accurate price tag, say pick 14 overall with +/- 4 being fair.

I struggle to see his value, with his upside, dropping below a mid-late 2nd anytime soon, but if the effort to feature him continues, the price will go up. Especially with Laporta on IR.

We can start 4-5 WR in this league so the WR2-3 with upside was worth a dice roll, but I probably like him more than most.
 
12 team PPR, start 1Q, 2R, 3W, 1T, 2F (R/W/T), 1K, 1DST

Gave:
Franklin, Troy DEN WR
Fannin, Harold CLE TE
Mitchell, Keaton BAL RB
Year 2026 Round 1 Draft Pick - currently the #2 seed by 1 victory point, so this would currently be 1.11

Got:
Harvey, RJ DEN RB

Our thinking:
  • Harvey should help our team down the stretch, especially with Dobbins out.
  • Our other RBs are Barkley, McCaffrey, Taylor, and Chubb. Needed to get some youth into the RB group.
  • We still have Kittle, Gadsden, Barner, and Likely, so could afford to part with Fannin.
Harvey was drafted at 1.5 this year. We drafted Fannin at 4.10 and picked up Mitchell and Franklin off the waiver wire. So, while this is all sunk cost and thus not really a valid way of looking at it, we traded 2026 1.11, 2025 4.10, and two waiver wire players for 2025 1.5.
 
12 Team PPR Superflex League

Team A: Jameson Williams
Team B: 2026 1st (late), Isaiah Bond

Team getting 1st is rebuilding/current 1.01, team getting Williams strong 1st overall
Did something happen to juice William's value? He's worth a second at most
Touchdowns in three of four. Efforts being made to get him the ball. I’d move a late first for him 🤷‍♂️
#5 WR ppg weeks 9-11. Not that we should extrapolate three weeks.
 
Two trades in my “main” league

A gave Matt Stafford
B gave 2027 2nd

A gave CMC, AJ brown, Buddha Baker
C gave Breece hall, Garrett Wilson

A is a consistent contender having a bit of a down year but still playoff bound.

B (me) is playoff bound after a few years of building, just lost Penix, was going to start cousins ROS

C is a bubble team, if the season ended today would not be in the playoffs but has a good chance to make a push. His conference is the weaker one so if he gets in there’s a really good shot of making it to the Super Bowl.
 
FFPC Triflex (superflex, start 3 WR, TE premium)

Both teams are contenders.

A team I run with a friend:

Gave: Bhayshul Tuten, 2026 1st (not ours, but early)
Got: George Pickens, 2026 2nd (same early team)

FFPC Triflex, different league:

Gave: Jayden Reed
Got: Stefon Diggs
 
Standard 1QB/TEP FFPC:

Rebuilding team:

Gave: Kittle
Got: Gadsden and a high 2026 second.

In FFPC Triflex, after LaPorta went on IR, a friend and I tried to trade him for Gadsden, and all we could get on top of Gadsden was a R3 from the current 1 seed.
The good news of this trade to me was I've been shopping Kittle around for last few weeks, just a bunch of rejections with no counter or comment. The team I just made the deal with the current #2 seed for his first. The pick I got back is currently from a team that is a guaranteed top 4 pick. So right now those picks are 3 apart, gap might grow a little but not huge. Frankly I'd have taken Gadsden straight up and probably needed just a little more on top of the second to take it straight up. So getting both makes me really happy.

The part I don't like is I drafted Gadsden, held him into the season, cut him after week one. But what's done is done.
 
Standard 1QB/TEP FFPC:

Rebuilding team:

Gave: Kittle
Got: Gadsden and a high 2026 second.

In FFPC Triflex, after LaPorta went on IR, a friend and I tried to trade him for Gadsden, and all we could get on top of Gadsden was a R3 from the current 1 seed.
The good news of this trade to me was I've been shopping Kittle around for last few weeks, just a bunch of rejections with no counter or comment. The team I just made the deal with the current #2 seed for his first. The pick I got back is currently from a team that is a guaranteed top 4 pick. So right now those picks are 3 apart, gap might grow a little but not huge. Frankly I'd have taken Gadsden straight up and probably needed just a little more on top of the second to take it straight up. So getting both makes me really happy.

The part I don't like is I drafted Gadsden, held him into the season, cut him after week one. But what's done is done.

I run a Triflex team with my son, and we cut Gadsden at the September deadline. He's been in mourning for the past month.
 
Apparently Saquon is doa

He just got traded with Ivan pace for woody marks.
I just traded him for a late 1st and that's all I could get. I kinda regret it but I'm rebuilding and pretty much had to. I think he will do well ROS.
I recently traded Barkley for Chase Brown and a 2026 1st
that would be great. Nice going! No one would do that in my league. We play w/contracts and he was on his last year.
 
Last edited:
Need some wisdom. Injuries killed me this year, I have a solid core. 12 team SF, deep benches. Current offer on the table:

I give 2026 1st, 2026 2nd, 2027 2nd. Should all be mid round.

I get McConkey, Allgeier, 2026 or 2027 3rd (my choice).
 
Need some wisdom. Injuries killed me this year, I have a solid core. 12 team SF, deep benches. Current offer on the table:

I give 2026 1st, 2026 2nd, 2027 2nd. Should all be mid round.

I get McConkey, Allgeier, 2026 or 2027 3rd (my choice).

Seems pretty fair but without more context of who your other WR are and the age of your roster as a whole I’d probably lean towards keeping the picks and remaining flexible going into the offseason.
 
Need some wisdom. Injuries killed me this year, I have a solid core. 12 team SF, deep benches. Current offer on the table:

I give 2026 1st, 2026 2nd, 2027 2nd. Should all be mid round.

I get McConkey, Allgeier, 2026 or 2027 3rd (my choice).

Seems pretty fair but without more context of who your other WR are and the age of your roster as a whole I’d probably lean towards keeping the picks and remaining flexible going into the offseason.
Starters;
Lamar, Purdy
Barkley, Marks
London, Wilson, Metcalf
Juwan Johnson

Bench is numerous plays for next year and/or backups (Mac Jones, Ollie Gordon, Manny Wilson, X Legette)

RB depth and issue and Metcalf has stunk with Pitt.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

  • jps
Back
Top