Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
***Official*** Holy Grail Redux WW Game Thread (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter Bob Sacamano
- Start date
Bob Sacamano
Footballguy
You guys playin' cards?
Evilgrin 72
Distributor of Pain
OFTW.. will check in from time time. I don't think I'm doing much besides cleaning up the whole pool area. What a pain in the ###.
Merlin
Alchemist
Bob Sacamano
Footballguy
Night Report
ARTHUR: We'd better not risk another frontal assault, that rabbit's dynamite.
ROBIN: Would it help to confuse it if we run away more?
ARTHUR: Oh, shut up and go and change your armor.
GALAHAD: Let us taunt it! It may become so cross that it will make a mistake.
ARTHUR: Like what?
GALAHAD: Well,....
merlin gets impatient (I have a job, you know) and loses his head.
Dead is merls - Plain Jane Briton
Day 9 begins. 7 live. 4 kill.
ARTHUR: We'd better not risk another frontal assault, that rabbit's dynamite.
ROBIN: Would it help to confuse it if we run away more?
ARTHUR: Oh, shut up and go and change your armor.
GALAHAD: Let us taunt it! It may become so cross that it will make a mistake.
ARTHUR: Like what?
GALAHAD: Well,....
merlin gets impatient (I have a job, you know) and loses his head.
Dead is merls - Plain Jane Briton
Day 9 begins. 7 live. 4 kill.
Merlin
Alchemist
bostonfred
Footballguy
Gg merls.
McGarnicle
Footballguy
GG Merlin.
Bob Sacamano
Footballguy
Official D9 My Big Unit Dog Only Costs $6, But It's Pricier By The Inch Vote Count
7 alive; 4 lynch
YTV - Lambskin, mexiJoe, EG, bostonfred, witz, McGarnicle, Hodor
7 alive; 4 lynch
YTV - Lambskin, mexiJoe, EG, bostonfred, witz, McGarnicle, Hodor
Hodor
Footballguy
Where I see things from GG to BG, I suggest everyone do the same
McGarnicle - naded icon, confirmed gg imo
bfred - pretty sure fred is good, only question mark is that foos ended up with the grail after I passed it to fred. But Fred has seemed GG the entire game.
Dan Lambskin - I'd be surprised if Dan were bad, he is new, so bg meter might be off a little bit
Mex Joe - him blindly following Norm list was a little concerning
Witz - question marks
EG - was on my early BG list for some forced reactions and BG rubbing it in type posts. My leading candidate at the moment.
McGarnicle - naded icon, confirmed gg imo
bfred - pretty sure fred is good, only question mark is that foos ended up with the grail after I passed it to fred. But Fred has seemed GG the entire game.
Dan Lambskin - I'd be surprised if Dan were bad, he is new, so bg meter might be off a little bit
Mex Joe - him blindly following Norm list was a little concerning
Witz - question marks
EG - was on my early BG list for some forced reactions and BG rubbing it in type posts. My leading candidate at the moment.
McGarnicle
Footballguy
Christ.
McGarnicle
Footballguy
Hey Bob if you were trying to give me another grenade, I didn't get it. Try again plz imo 
McGarnicle
Footballguy
Did I already mention what a great time I've had? Thanks again you guys.
Dan Lambskin
Footballguy
I don't really trust any of you 
BF and Hodor both very pro town but I know sometimes that's how the BG get their hooks in
Will give the benefit of the doubt as GG for now
McG - new, seems as lost as I am but I know he's smart enough to play off the noob role with some coaching. Lean GG though
MexJoe - I can barely recall a single contribution
Witz: claimed GGRP. No counter so either nobody's spoken up yet (time to do it IMO), or he's BG and the real GGRP is unnamed dead
EG: been helpful but gut feeling we're getting played
I'm willing to either lynch Witz and find out the truth (or too early? Let me know as a noob) or get a claim from EG
BF and Hodor both very pro town but I know sometimes that's how the BG get their hooks in
Will give the benefit of the doubt as GG for now
McG - new, seems as lost as I am but I know he's smart enough to play off the noob role with some coaching. Lean GG though
MexJoe - I can barely recall a single contribution
Witz: claimed GGRP. No counter so either nobody's spoken up yet (time to do it IMO), or he's BG and the real GGRP is unnamed dead
EG: been helpful but gut feeling we're getting played
I'm willing to either lynch Witz and find out the truth (or too early? Let me know as a noob) or get a claim from EG
McGarnicle
Footballguy
McGarnicle
Footballguy
Witz already claimed. And I don't necessarily dismiss him as bad anymore. Ugh.I don't really trust any of you
BF and Hodor both very pro town but I know sometimes that's how the BG get their hooks in
Will give the benefit of the doubt as GG for now
McG - new, seems as lost as I am but I know he's smart enough to play off the noob role with some coaching. Lean GG though
MexJoe - I can barely recall a single contribution
Witz: claimed GGRP. No counter so either nobody's spoken up yet (time to do it IMO), or he's BG and the real GGRP is unnamed dead
EG: been helpful but gut feeling we're getting played
I'm willing to either lynch Witz and find out the truth (or too early? Let me know as a noob) or get a claim from EG
McGarnicle
Footballguy
This game is unbelievably awesome but I'm feeling a lot of pressure at the moment. Didn't expect to last this long. I feel like the answers are right there in the last 20-30 pages or so and I'm taking my time to try and get it right.
McGarnicle
Footballguy
Question -- we win when all bg's are dead, yes? Not indies aligned with the bad side -- actual bg's.
Hodor
Footballguy
no sure things, it is good to take time. I plan to dig into EG gameplay later tonight.
McGarnicle
Footballguy
Mods in this game pick roles at their discretion? Or random number generator, dice roll etc.?
bostonfred
Footballguy
More lists please
bostonfred
Footballguy
random dice
McGarnicle
Footballguy
EG is a massive question mark for me. I've been playing along with the conventional wisdom that he's good, but I know he's good at this game. And I'm guessing this phase of the game rarely goes down how everyone was assuming all along. We're all expert FF players, gamblers, poker players etc in this forum after all.
McGarnicle
Footballguy
vote bf
Dan Lambskin
Footballguy
bostonfred
Footballguy
I think it's good that you're going outside the box here. You can definitely make a case for anyone in the village being bad. So lay out your case for why I'm the right person to run up today. I'll answer any questions you might have about my play. We should do that for everyone at this point, myself included.
McGarnicle
Footballguy
Basically for me it's bf and I'm not coming off that. I posted a long thing about why I naded icon, and I'll do one for this too, stay tuned. In the meantime, to summarize my stance on the issue at hand, my vote is bf, if I'm wrong I have a one-time noob luxury of saying sorry I was a noob, and I'll learn from it, yada yada, but it's vote bf and if you have a problem with that I cordially invite you to suck my warm and salty nutsack.
I'll go a step further and say that I'm comfortable going all the way to lynch and I could give two ####s what anyone says on the way there. If I'm wrong, bash me over the head with all the signs I missed.
I'll go a step further and say that I'm comfortable going all the way to lynch and I could give two ####s what anyone says on the way there. If I'm wrong, bash me over the head with all the signs I missed.
bostonfred
Footballguy
Remember i posted the bg hunting process before
1) identify role players
2) identify trusted ggs
3) run up the people you don't think are good
4) figure out what to do with the guys who are left
I feel like most people had me in that group of probably good guys. If that includes you, something to think about: are you done with step three yet?
1) identify role players
2) identify trusted ggs
3) run up the people you don't think are good
4) figure out what to do with the guys who are left
I feel like most people had me in that group of probably good guys. If that includes you, something to think about: are you done with step three yet?
Dan Lambskin
Footballguy
I forget...didn't EG blow up a GG day 1 and then appear on quite a few of the early GG lynches?
Hodor
Footballguy
Went through all of EG's gameplay, not a lot of GG points imo. I had totally forgotten about the nading of unclaimed dhart. I was not around for that.
D1
- voted GG spoofy
- Blew up GG dhart with no warning, anti village imo
- said BG icon was worrisome cause he votes him when he is bad and icon proxied bry who was voting him
- defended his grenade throw by saying a BG would wait for GGRP claim (but a bg would not know if a GG passed it to him)
- voted GG Bry based on a Worm read
- voted BG Rascal with BG Hags for a triple run up when two GGs were Leading vote getters
D2
- votes GG Bucky
- Tells BG icon to nade either GG spoofy, GG bucky or GG Bryhamm
D3
- votes GG hulk, low flyer easy target imo
- argues more with bry for him calling his nading of dhart anti village
- switches to help lynch GG Manback cause hulk had no traction
D4
- started out with kind of a forced post calling the night kills f'ing ridiculous
- announces he will now lead the village cause the village sucks
- backed Dan's theory that votes on Acer transfer to LVG, makes a suspect list based on that
- calls out Zed for his (stolen) grenade toss
- jumps on the BG Rascal train after his game event view
- wanted people to vote BG rascal and Acer to solve the vote manip theory
- defends himself by saying he staying on rascal and wants people to vote him but testing theory.
- unvotes rascal and votes ACer...
D5
- wants to start a voting bloc with BG icon and GG Cav...
- says village is getting #### kicked out of us, merlin calls him out
- votes BG Foos, says his claim is fake
- votes BG Loan Sharks, but unvotes for a claim
- revotes foos, revotes loan calls for foos the next day.
D6 votes foos
- asks about the holy grail passing
- talks about if he were bg he would want to strangle all of the BG low flyers
- Tells GG Zed to OBGS
- No comments on Hags claim
- votes GG Merlin? Doesnt even go back to Foos the guy he was clammoring for?
D7
- makes a post with all the players and has GG Merlin, Witz, GG Sand, and GG Zed in his four suspects
- Makes weird post listing all roles and Hags as claiming Bedevere...
- Then hammers Hags
d8 votes Witz
D1
- voted GG spoofy
- Blew up GG dhart with no warning, anti village imo
- said BG icon was worrisome cause he votes him when he is bad and icon proxied bry who was voting him
- defended his grenade throw by saying a BG would wait for GGRP claim (but a bg would not know if a GG passed it to him)
- voted GG Bry based on a Worm read
- voted BG Rascal with BG Hags for a triple run up when two GGs were Leading vote getters
D2
- votes GG Bucky
- Tells BG icon to nade either GG spoofy, GG bucky or GG Bryhamm
D3
- votes GG hulk, low flyer easy target imo
- argues more with bry for him calling his nading of dhart anti village
- switches to help lynch GG Manback cause hulk had no traction
D4
- started out with kind of a forced post calling the night kills f'ing ridiculous
- announces he will now lead the village cause the village sucks
- backed Dan's theory that votes on Acer transfer to LVG, makes a suspect list based on that
- calls out Zed for his (stolen) grenade toss
- jumps on the BG Rascal train after his game event view
- wanted people to vote BG rascal and Acer to solve the vote manip theory
- defends himself by saying he staying on rascal and wants people to vote him but testing theory.
- unvotes rascal and votes ACer...
D5
- wants to start a voting bloc with BG icon and GG Cav...
- says village is getting #### kicked out of us, merlin calls him out
- votes BG Foos, says his claim is fake
- votes BG Loan Sharks, but unvotes for a claim
- revotes foos, revotes loan calls for foos the next day.
D6 votes foos
- asks about the holy grail passing
- talks about if he were bg he would want to strangle all of the BG low flyers
- Tells GG Zed to OBGS
- No comments on Hags claim
- votes GG Merlin? Doesnt even go back to Foos the guy he was clammoring for?
D7
- makes a post with all the players and has GG Merlin, Witz, GG Sand, and GG Zed in his four suspects
- Makes weird post listing all roles and Hags as claiming Bedevere...
- Then hammers Hags
d8 votes Witz
Hodor
Footballguy
Hodor
Footballguy
I'd like to hear this long thing you got on bf, cause I am not seeing it at the moment, like at all
bostonfred
Footballguy
That didn't sound like you laying out a case. It sounds like you're trying to justify a hero play. We all do it. But this isn't the time in the game for stubborn decisions.
there are seven players left. If there are two bgs left, and one lynch per day and one inch per night, then we only get one miss. Tomorrow there would be 5 players, three good and two bad, and the bgs would never vote for each other, so all three ggs would need to vote for the same bg or the bg team wins. We call that a Kendall because if a guy named Kendall who used to play.
I think it's more likely there's only one bg left. So we get two misses before we are in a three person Kendall.
We had a couple really bad days to start the game, but then we had some good days that bought us the wiggle room to missone or twice. But that's all we get for leeway, so we need to tighten things way up. If you think I'm bad, explain why and convince people to vote for me. Saying you have a hunch andplan to be stubborn isn't enough, and it's the kind of thing bad guys do, especially newbies at the end of the game.
there are seven players left. If there are two bgs left, and one lynch per day and one inch per night, then we only get one miss. Tomorrow there would be 5 players, three good and two bad, and the bgs would never vote for each other, so all three ggs would need to vote for the same bg or the bg team wins. We call that a Kendall because if a guy named Kendall who used to play.
I think it's more likely there's only one bg left. So we get two misses before we are in a three person Kendall.
We had a couple really bad days to start the game, but then we had some good days that bought us the wiggle room to missone or twice. But that's all we get for leeway, so we need to tighten things way up. If you think I'm bad, explain why and convince people to vote for me. Saying you have a hunch andplan to be stubborn isn't enough, and it's the kind of thing bad guys do, especially newbies at the end of the game.
bostonfred
Footballguy
this is the kind of post that sways votes. Good stuff Brent
Dan Lambskin
Footballguy
Evilgrin 72
Distributor of Pain
Evilgrin 72
Distributor of Pain
Ultimately, if we're this game, it's going to be the non-reveals on Acer and Bender that do us in.
Evilgrin 72
Distributor of Pain
bostonfred
Footballguy
I wouldn't kind getting a claim Eg and maybe if you could point to some pro village stuff you've done
Hodor
Footballguy
bostonfred
Footballguy
why?
bostonfred
Footballguy
Lol Brent
bostonfred
Footballguy
Talk to me about mex
Hodor
Footballguy
Here is Witz. Not a whole to go off of imo. The non activeness yet voting BGs never too good of a sign, but he may have been laying low as Lancelot. Calling out Fred could always be a BG play if he knew Hags was gonna do that.
D1
- not a whole lot of early substance, happy to be playing again posts, etc.
- says GG Bucky looks fishy after Worm's "view"
- calls out fred, Otis, Bucky, EG and SacBob for following view
D2
- asks for reasons for spoofy runup, tells icon to throw it at spoofy
- thinks Low fly killing might be randomized kills from YTV
D3
- calls out GG Conn, EG and GG Sand for being on all three lynches
- more DOS on EG and Sand
- no votes
D4
- votes BG Rascal
D5
- asks why BG Foos or BG Loan on people's lists...
- kinda calls out Dan for him insuating that Loan is a BG before reveal
- does not vote
D5
- makes a list of outstanding claims
- kinda calls out McGarnicle for being engaged unsolicited pj claim
- no votes
D6
- votes BG Foos
D7
- votes BG Hags
D8
- calls out EG for copy pasting list from BG board
- laughing at EG for apologizing
- claims Lancelot - Angel
- votes Zed
- points out fred's vote of Zed and not wanting to hear a claim.
- Then calls it out again after Hag hammers...
D1
- not a whole lot of early substance, happy to be playing again posts, etc.
- says GG Bucky looks fishy after Worm's "view"
- calls out fred, Otis, Bucky, EG and SacBob for following view
D2
- asks for reasons for spoofy runup, tells icon to throw it at spoofy
- thinks Low fly killing might be randomized kills from YTV
D3
- calls out GG Conn, EG and GG Sand for being on all three lynches
- more DOS on EG and Sand
- no votes
D4
- votes BG Rascal
D5
- asks why BG Foos or BG Loan on people's lists...
- kinda calls out Dan for him insuating that Loan is a BG before reveal
- does not vote
D5
- makes a list of outstanding claims
- kinda calls out McGarnicle for being engaged unsolicited pj claim
- no votes
D6
- votes BG Foos
D7
- votes BG Hags
D8
- calls out EG for copy pasting list from BG board
- laughing at EG for apologizing
- claims Lancelot - Angel
- votes Zed
- points out fred's vote of Zed and not wanting to hear a claim.
- Then calls it out again after Hag hammers...
Hodor
Footballguy
Mex was real eager to follow Norm's list after he died, that is the last thing I remember. I am gonna have to analyze him a bit
Evilgrin 72
Distributor of Pain
PJB. I haven't done anything that wasn't pro village since blowing dhart up. Pretty sure I've hammered 2 BGs, was vocal about Foos' claim being garbage and posted a GG/BG list at pretty much the same time as Norm's that was nearly as accurate. I admit to being somewhat lost ATM. I'm basically treating this like a new game from here.
Also, might be time for everyone to claim.
![[icon]](/data/avatars/s/5/5167.jpg?1660313464){kind=avatar}
