On these points I'd add, name how many times the Texans have been right the past 4 years. Dunta Robinson, Dominick Davis....who else? How many pro bowl offensive or defensive players have they drafted? How about this....Like 99.99% of us, I haven't watched tape on these guys any more than the handful of plays we see on draft specials, and those chosen to illustrate some point. But when it comes down to evaluating those kind of specific aspects of a recruit, I'm going to put more stock in the evaluations of guys who do it for a living, but more importantly actually have had a chance to thoroughly study the player. Yes they could be wrong and some times are, but wouldn't you agree that between you, I, and the scouts, they probably have the more informed opinion about his agility?
.....
As I said, I agree that cornerback is a major need. Safety as well though I wouldn't worry about it before corner and LB unless a guy fell that was a great value. But there is no way this team was going to address every need they had in 1 draft. The fact that their picks did address needs with quality players with upside makes it hard for me to fault them if they felt the LBs available there were better than the CBs.
I'll also note that every single media source I've seen that grades drafts has the Texans ranging from a B to an A, so seeing the value in their picks is far from a fringe opinion.
<{POST_SNAPBACK}>
How many Texans do you honestly feel would start for a .500 team right now? 4, 5 tops?
Are the scouts more informed? Yes. That doesn't mean they make the correct decisions. Watching film and attending the combines doesn't show you who is going to be the best professional football player. I have lost my faith in the Texans staff ability to draft, plain and simple.
And from all the media sources that you have read giving them a grade of B or A, how many D's and F's have you seen? How many other B's and A's have their been? If there are 32 teams and there are 4 A's, should there not be 4 F's? Every thing I have read, shows the Texans getting high B's too, but I NEVER see a grade lower than a C, so that tells me that that media sources are a bunch of chicken #### pansies afraid to disparage a draft. Lastly, if you have the #1 pick in the first round, the #1 pick in the second round, and the #1 & #2 picks in the third round, how the hell are you not going to score some players that are rated highly? Fact remains they blew this draft, in my humble opinion. I've given a very detailed analysis of the players they selected and why they are not right. I have also demonstrated how they TOTALLY avoided their most glaring need. How many of the other media sources went into any detail with the Texans, besides a blurb about one player? Don't buy into the spin doctoring going on with the media and the Texans. This is a pathetic franchise right now.