KarmaPolice
Footballguy
We already have that high quality of a space movie: Starship Troopers.("The Godfather in Space" ... hmmm ... )
fftowriteascreenplay:
We already have that high quality of a space movie: Starship Troopers.("The Godfather in Space" ... hmmm ... )
fftowriteascreenplay:
The Emperor that was thrown down the hole was just a clone of the real one.No all of that is in the extra material.
How about how did Palpatine survive? Or we just good with space magic and call it a day? That's where we're at with Star Wars? It's basically Dr Who where there are no rules and anything is ok as long as it looks cool?
Godfather level movie? They puttered out after the second movie, too. Godfather wishes it could have told as good a story over 11 movies like SW.Awesome- but of course not everyone agrees with that, and it's not because they are expecting The Godfather level movie.
Pretty much everything that goes down a shaft in Star Wars comes back later. Darth Maul (in Solo). Luke's light saber (in TFA), and Palpatine (in ROS). Heck, even Obi Wan survived a fall in what was essentially a shaft.No all of that is in the extra material.
How about how did Palpatine survive? Or we just good with space magic and call it a day? That's where we're at with Star Wars? It's basically Dr Who where there are no rules and anything is ok as long as it looks cool?
Did we ever find out how what's-her-name came up with it?Pretty much everything that goes down a shaft in Star Wars comes back later. Darth Maul (in Solo). Luke's light saber (in TFA), and Palpatine (in ROS). Heck, even Obi Wan survived a fall in what was essentially a shaft.
"A good question for another time."Did we ever find out how what's-her-name came up with it?
Han, Chewie, Luke, and Leia all went down the garbage shaft (ANH). Luke went down a Cloud City shaft after falling a bajillion feet (ESB).Pretty much everything that goes down a shaft in Star Wars comes back later. Darth Maul (in Solo). Luke's light saber (in TFA), and Palpatine (in ROS). Heck, even Obi Wan survived a fall in what was essentially a shaft.
Clearly Jyn Erso's mistake was climbing up the shaft in Rogue One. She probably would have survived if she had just jumped with the data file.Han, Chewie, Luke, and Leia all went down the garbage shaft (ANH). Luke went down a Cloud City shaft after falling a bajillion feet (ESB).
Holy cow! All of Star Wars can be boiled down to surviving falling down shafts! Why did we never see this before!?!?
This isn't that far fetched an answer. The Sith have a history of messing around with clones. It makes sense Palpatine would have one ready just in case.The Emperor that was thrown down the hole was just a clone of the real one.
They did the clone thing in the EU and it was fine. The difference was that it wasn't an ancient dried up husk VRing into other bodies from some far off planet. It was the real Palpatine that died and then had a backup plan. He was a younger clone with his memories implanted in a fresh body. The other way is just weird.Scoresman said:This isn't that far fetched an answer. The Sith have a history of messing around with clones. It makes sense Palpatine would have one ready just in case.
The real answer is that Palpatine survived because Rian Johnson killed off Abram's villain.
Has anyone ever died from falling down a shaft in the SWU?They did the clone thing in the EU and it was fine. The difference was that it wasn't an ancient dried up husk VRing into other bodies from some far off planet. It was the real Palpatine that died and then had a backup plan. He was a younger clone with his memories implanted in a fresh body. The other way is just weird.
And yes the 2nd part of your post is the logistical reason.
Well they never brought Mace back... Yet. And Han stayed dead even though they gave him dream dad powers. Also Phasma is dead I guess but she doesn't really count because no one cares. It's really only Maul and now Palpatine.Has anyone ever died from falling down a shaft in the SWU?
Luke fell down and shaft and didn't sustain a single injury. I mean, he lost a hand, but that was prior to falling.Well they never brought Mace back... Yet. And Han stayed dead even though they gave him dream dad powers. Also Phasma is dead I guess but she doesn't really count because no one cares. It's really only Maul and now Palpatine.
Yep but we watched him the whole way.Luke fell down and shaft and didn't sustain a single injury. I mean, he lost a hand, but that was prior to falling.
Are you implying we have superpowers that keep people from getting hurt with our gaze? Sweet.Yep but we watched him the whole way.
There was no mystery there. We saw Luke fall. He guided himself into a side tube. Still nearly fell to his death and would have if his force sensitive sister didn't feel him nearby.Are you implying we have superpowers that keep people from getting hurt with our gaze? Sweet.
I get what you're saying, GB, but no one could survive that fall that Luke had. Also, his sister floated out into space without any protection and was able to "force space walk" back into the spaceship. These people are using telekinesis to move things and do things. I'm just not sure why all of that is totally feasible, but the Emperor making it out of the Death Star somehow is such a crazy idea.There was no mystery there. We saw Luke fall. He guided himself into a side tube. Still nearly fell to his death and would have if his force sensitive sister didn't feel him nearby.
Yea well everything in that movie is bull####. So I don't use that as a reference.I get what you're saying, GB, but no one could survive that fall that Luke had. Also, his sister floated out into space without any protection and was able to "force space walk" back into the spaceship. These people are using telekinesis to move things and do things. I'm just not sure why all of that is totally feasible, but the Emperor making it out of the Death Star somehow is such a crazy idea.
Yea well everything in that movie is bull####. So I don't use that as a reference.
On palps survival. I can buy him dying and then having a backup body ready. The fact that he has a decrepit sack of meat that's been hooked up to a generator for centuries and he somehow just sends out meat puppets that he logs into to run things is dumb. Also him trying to saying he could see Vader's betrayal coming and it was all part of the plan is even dumber.
As much as that made me laugh, I was referencing more than one movie.
just brutally dumbOn palps survival. I can buy him dying and then having a backup body ready. The fact that he has a decrepit sack of meat that's been hooked up to a generator for centuries and he somehow just sends out meat puppets that he logs into to run things is dumb. Also him trying to saying he could see Vader's betrayal coming and it was all part of the plan is even dumber.
Like Kylo said in his reaction video. He was the Dark Lord of Failing and then pretending it was all part of the plan.
Turns out Palpatine's spirit lived on, I guess like a force ghost, but then was able to inhabit a clone.The Emperor that was thrown down the hole was just a clone of the real one.
When you say "turns out" do you mean this is confirmed somewhere, or are you just changing your own assessment.Turns out Palpatine's spirit lived on, I guess like a force ghost, but then was able to inhabit a clone.
Case solved.
So I guess a book came out (or is coming out in the next couple of days) that is like the movie, but in book form. Something like that. Not sure. I'm not a super SW nerd, plus I'm not a fast reader. So I'm not going to be the best person to answer this.When you say "turns out" do you mean this is confirmed somewhere, or are you just changing your own assessment.
FTR, this new theory is what I assumed as I watched the movie.
I think she's GORGEOUS. that smile...I'd say she has what Julia Roberts has, one of the prettiest smiles and mouths in Hollywood. HUGE fan. If she just had a few more curves on her she'd be the perfect woman in my worldGreat final trailer. Good lord, Daisy is so pretty.
So stupid. Better off leaving it unknown.
At this pace, with so many clones, I can only imagine it leading to a war of some sort.It's past embarrassing now. Every day they come out with a new clone.
Maybe this time they will turn it into a decent movie.At this pace, with so many clones, I can only imagine it leading to a war of some sort.
But they aren't even smiling and showing their teeth!! what a tease, that smile and mouth is her best asset! But thanks for posting thatWalking Boot said:Speaking of clones, you should see her sisters
boy, you mention her mouth a lot.But they aren't even smiling and showing their teeth!! what a tease, that smile and mouth is her best asset! But thanks for posting that
whatevaClearly Jyn Erso's mistake was climbing up the shaft in Rogue One. She probably would have survived if she had just jumped with the data file.
no, its not just you. She's smoking hot. https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2Ftse1.mm.bing.net%2Fth%3Fid%3DOIP.8tSdoCFr7oJAXVA23k4h3wHaMO%26pid%3DApi&f=1ffmail4me said:Saw it this weekend with my 12 year old son. Thought it was great. I also think Rey (can't recall actresses name) might be one of the most beautiful women in Hollywood right now. Her mouth and smile...oh my lord it just kills me. I think she's gorgeous, is it just me?