Olave or Devonta as a keeper and why? (1 Viewer)

[Savatage79]

Would love a few opinions thanks

 

[DensestBobcat17]

Personally Olave - coming from an eagles fan.

Smith faces comp between AJ and Goedert. Even though Hurts is better than Carr, in a keeper format I’m banking that a year of Carr/Olave chemistry building will benefit Olave huge next year compared to Smith

 

[farfromforgotten]

I’d go Olave as well. As Bobcat stated above he’s got less competition for targets and looks to be a big part of the Saints plans going forward. Carr is nothing special but he can feed a WR. Kamara was always top dog but that’s going to change. While I’m not as worried about size compared to some posters on this board Olave does have a sturdier build as well, if that means anything to you.

 

[DensestBobcat17]

I’d go Olave as well. As Bobcat stated above he’s got less competition for targets and looks to be a big part of the Saints plans going forward. Carr is nothing special but he can feed a WR. Kamara was always top dog but that’s going change. While I’m not as worried about size compared to some posters on this board Olave does have a sturdier build as well, if that means anything to you.

If either one of you wants to take a peak at the post I just threw up on the board. It’s for draft strategy ideas

 

[houston]

Tough call for sure. I really like Olave and think he has all the makings to be a top 5 WR for 6-8 years. I like Devonta as well, but his smaller size is always a concern for me, as well as all of the other talent in the Eagles offense.

Good luck! Please take a look at my question from earlier, with a similar keeper decision.

 

[Gally]

I would go with Smith because a better offense and better QB even with the better competition. I am not sure what NO's is going to be like on offense with all the changes.