Not to change the topic but will Collie even make it back? This dude has taken some real hits and the concussions are no joke. If Collie doesn't make it back then Manning has to find Garcon with even more regularity right? Unless you think White can fill Collie's role?
Like I said above,
Manning seems to be going to the slot WR and TE checkoffs with much more regularity this year. Just check his YPA #s.
Sometimes older QBs lose accuracy on the deep pass late in their careers. It happened to Warner last year, IMO it's happening to Favre this season, and I wonder if it's happening to Peyton right now... As you mention Peyton's YPA is down, 7.9 YPA last season and 6.9 YPA this year, and the other outside receiver, Reggie Wayne, has experienced a decrease in catch% as well as YPC this year as well. It's possible that it's purely attributed to the injuries suffered to offensive skill position players, poor oline play, etc., but some of those things I've come to expect a transcendental talent like Manning to overcome. Offensive injuries aside, in the games I have seen him play this season, I haven't seen Manning throw downfield with the same level of accuracy as in past seasons.
I imagine it's blasphemous to suggest that a HOF, best QB of his era type, like Manning, might be suffering an erosion of skills, but for some reason he's not connecting on deeper patterns with any regularity, but shorter passes haven't been an issue, regardless of who he's been throwing to (including Garcon on some short throws). His game this season reminds me more of Chad Pennington than Peyton Manning.
That's not to make any excuses for Garcon's shortcomings, I just wonder if Manning is reaching a stage in his career where age is robbing him of some accuracy on the deeper passes.