Post your Top 30 QBs (1 Viewer)

[Clayton Gray]

OK. I can admit it when I make a mistake. Please accept my apologies for the debacle that was the polls method of rankings. There were a few flaws with the polls method of rankings that I really didn't trust the integrity of the output. So we're back to square one (except that I will keep the results from PK and Def/ST as those positions rarely see much attention with this method).

Post your Top 30 QBs (please number them and use first and last names)

Your list must be posted before Midnight Eastern on Sunday the 15th.

Other positions:

Overall QB RB WR TE

Assume this would be a 12 team re-draft league with the following scoring system:

4 pts = TD pass

6 pts = TD run/catch

1 pt = 20 YD pass

1 pt = 10 YD run/catch

-1 pt = INT

 

[Megatron]

1 Daunte Culpepper 2 Donovan McNabb3 Peyton Manning 4 Rich Gannon5 Jeff Garcia 6 Aaron Brooks7 Drew Bledsoe 8 Michael Vick9 Steve McNair 10 Brett Favre11 Chad Pennington12 Kerry Collins13 Trent Green14 Kurt Warner15 Jake Plummer16 Tom Brady 17 Tommy Maddox18 Brad Johnson19 Drew Brees20 Matt Hasselbeck21 Jake Delhomme22 Joey Harrington23 David Carr24 Kordell Stewart25 Kelly Holcombe 26 Jay Fiedler27 Jon Kitna28 Patrick Ramsey 29 Mark Brunell30 Tim Couch

 

[Harv72b]

1. Donovan McNabb2. Daunte Culpepper3. Michael Vick4. Peyton Manning5. Rich Gannon6. Jeff Garcia7. Matt Hasselbeck8. Brett Favre9. Aaron Brooks10. Steve McNair11. Chad Pennington12. Tom Brady13. Tommy Maddox14. Joey Harrington (not a typo)15. Kerry Collins16. Trent Green17. Drew Bledsoes18. Patrick Ramsey19. Marc Bulger20. Kordell Stewart21. Brad Johnson22. Jake Plummer23. Mark Brunell24. Jon Kitna25. Drew Brees26. Jay Fiedler27. Kelly Holcomb28. David Carr29. Jeff Blake30. Kurt Warner

 

[CASS101]

1. Daunte Cullpepper2. Michael Vick3. Donovan McNabb4. Peyton Manning5. Kurt Warner6. Rich Gannon7. Matt Hasselbeck8. Drew Bledsoe9. Aaron Brooks10. Tommy Maddux11. Jeff Garcia12. Brett Favre13. Jake Plummer14. Steve McNair15. Tom Brady 16. Kerry Collins17. Trent Green18. Patrick Ramsey19. Brad Johnson20. Chad Pennington21. Drew Brees22. John Kitna23. Jay Fiedler24. Kordell Stewart25. Joey Harrington26. David Carr27. Tim Couch28. Kelly Holcomb29. Mark Brunell30. Jeff Blake

 

[Boone22]

1. McNabb2. Gannon3. Manning4. Culpepper5. Garcia6. Warner7. Tom Brady8. Vick9. Pennington10. Brooks11. Bledsoe12. Favre13. McNair14. Maddox15. Hasselback16. Trent Green17. Brad Johnson18. Kerry Collins19. Brees20. Ramsey21. Fielder22. Holcomb23. Brunell24. Kitna25. Delhomme26. Plummer27. Kordell Stewart28. Harrington29. Blake30. Carr

 

[sstork]

1 Donovan McNabb, Phi2 Daunte Culpepper, Min3 Peyton Manning, Ind4 Rich Gannon, Oak5 Michael Vick, Atl6 Aaron Brooks, NO7 Jeff Garcia, SF8 Steve McNair, Ten9 Kurt Warner, StL10 Drew Bledsoe, Buf11 Tom Brady, NE12 Trent Green, KC13 Matt Hasselbeck, Sea14 Brett Favre, GB15 Chad Pennington, NYJ16 Tommy Maddox, Pit17 Kerry Collins, NYG18 Jake Plummer, Den19 Patrick Ramsey, Was20 Brad Johnson, TB21 Drew Brees, SD22 Kordell Stewart, Chi23 Jay Fiedler, Mia24 Joey Harrington, Det25 Mark Brunell, Jac26 David Carr, Hou27 Jeff Blake, Ari28 Jon Kitna, Cin29 KYLE BOLLER BAL30 Jake Delhomme, Car

 

[Ryno83]

1 M vick2 P Manning3 D Mcnabb4 A Brooks5 R Gannon6 J Garcia7 B Favre8 D Culpepper9 D Bledsoe10 T Brady11 T Maddox12 S Mcnair13 C Pennington14 T green15 B Johnson16 K Collins17 D Brees18 J Kitna19 J Plummer20 M Hasslebeck21 K Holcomb22 M Brunell23 P Ramsey24 J Harrington25 M Bulger26 T Couch27 B Griese28 J Blake29 D Carr30 K Warner

 

[Burning Sensation]

1. Michael Vick2. Donovan McNabb3. Daunte Culpepper4. Aaron Brooks5. Peyton Manning6. Rich Gannon7. Jeff Garcia8. Drew Bledsoe9. Tommy Maddox10. Matt Hassleback11. Chad Pennington12. Steve McNair13. Tom Brady14. Brett Favre15. Jake Plummer 16. Patrick Ramsey17. Kerry Collins18. Trent Green19. Kurt Warner20. Tim Couch21. Brad Johnson22. Jake Delhomme23. Jon Kitna24. Joey Harrington25. Drew Brees26. Mark Brunnell27. David Carr28. Jeff Blake 29. Kordell Stewart30. Jay Fiedler

 

[rzrback77]

1) Dante Culpepper 2) Mike Vick 3) Donovan McNabb 4) Peyton Manning 5) Kurt Warner 6) Rich Gannon 7) Steve McNair 8) Drew Bledsoe 9) Aaron Brooks10) Trent Green11) Jeff Garcia12) Matt Hasselbeck13) Jake Plummer 14) Tom Brady 15) Jon Kitna16) Kerry Collins 17) Brett Favre18) Kordell Stewart19) Brad Johnson20) Chad Pennington21) Drew Brees22) Patrick Ramsey23) Jay Fiedler24) Tommy Maddox25) Joey Harrington26) David Carr27) Jeff Blake 28) Kelly Holcomb29) Mark Brunell30) Kyle Boller

 

[shmagu]

1) Donovan McNabb2) Mike Vick3) Peyton Manning4) Daunte Culpepper5) Rich Gannon6) Jeff Garcia7) Aaron Brooks8) Brett Favre9) Kurt Warner10) Drew Bledsoe11) Trent Green12) Steve McNair13) Tom Brady14) Chad Pennington15) Tommy Maddox16) Matt Hasselbeck17) Kerry Collins18) Jake Plummer19) Drew Brees20) Brad Johnson21) Jay Fiedler22) Patrick Ramsey23) Joey Harrington24) Kordell Stewart25) Mark Brunell26) Jon Kitna27) David Carr28) Jeff Blake29) Kelly Holcombe30) Tim Couch

 

[Forgiven]

1. Donovan McNabb2. Daunte Culpepper3. Rich Gannon4. Kurt Warner5. Michael Vick6. Peyton Manning7. Jeff Garcia8. Brett Favre9. Aaron Brooks10. Drew Bledsoe11. Tom Brady12. Steve McNair13. Trent Green14. Chad Pennington15. Matt Hasselbeck16. Kerry Collins17. Patrick Ramsey18. Tommy Maddox19. Jake Plummer20. Brad Johnson21. Kordell Stewart22. Mark Brunell23. Drew Brees24. Jon Kitna25. Joey Harrington26. David Carr27. Jay Fiedler28. Jeff Blake29. Tim Couch30. Rodney Peete

 

[Steelers4Life]

1 Daunte Culpepper2 Donovan McNabb3 Michael Vick4 Peyton Manning5 Rich Gannon6 Aaron Brooks7 Steve McNair8 Matt Hasselbeck 9 Brett Favre10 Kurt Warner11 Patrick Ramsey12 Tom Brady13 Tommy Maddox14 Chad Pennington15 Jake Plummer16 Trent Green 17 Kerry Collins18 Jay Fiedler19 Drew Brees20 Jon Kitna 21 Brad Johnson22 Drew Bledsoe23 Joey Harrington24 Kordell Stewart25 Kelly Holcomb/Tim Couch26 Jake Delhomme27 David Carr28 Mark Brunell29 Chad Hutchinson30 Jeff Blake

 

[Dutch Kincade]

1. Donovan McNabb2. Daunte Culpepper3. Aaron Brooks4. Chad Pennington5. Peyton Manning6. Rich Gannon7. Jeff Garcia8. Drew Bledsoe9. Tommy Maddox10. Michael Vick11. Kurt Warner12. Matt Hassleback13. Steve McNair14. Tom Brady15. Brett Favre16. Jake Plummer 17. Patrick Ramsey18. Kerry Collins19. Trent Green20. Tim Couch21. Brad Johnson22. Jake Delhomme23. Jon Kitna24. Joey Harrington25. Drew Brees26. Mark Brunnell27. David Carr28. Jeff Blake 29. Kordell Stewart30. Jay Fiedler

 

[HAM]

1. Donovan McNabb2. Michael Vick3. Jeff Garcia4. Daunte Culpepper5. Rich Gannon6. Tom Brady7. Drew Bledsoe8. Peyton Manning9. Kurt Warner10. Kerry Collins11. Brett Farve12. Chad Pennington13. Aaron Brooks14. Steve McNair15. Trent Green16. Matt Hasselbeck17. Tommy Maddox18. John Kitna19. Brian Griese20. Brad Johnson21. Jake Plummer22. David Carr23. Kordell Stewart24. Drew Brees25. Kelly Holcomb26. Joey Harrington27. Patrick Ramsey28. Chris Redman29. Mark Brunell30. Byron Leftwich

 

[joffer]

1 Donovan McNabb 2 Daunte Culpepper 3 Michael Vick4 Peyton Manning 5 Jeff Garcia 6 Aaron Brooks 7 Steve McNair8 Rich Gannon 9 Drew Bledsoe10 Kurt Warner 11 Trent Green12 Tom Brady13 Brett Favre 14 Tommy Maddox15 Matt Hasselbeck16 Chad Pennington17 Kerry Collins18 Kordell Stewart19 Jake Plummer20 Brad Johnson21 Kelly Holcomb22 Jay Fiedler23 Drew Brees24 Jeff Blake25 Jon Kitna26 Patrick Ramsey27 Mark Brunell28 David Carr29 Chris Redman30 Joey Harrington

 

[VikingMan87]

01 Donovan McNabb02 Dante Culpepper03 Michael Vick04 Rich Gannon05 Peyton Manning06 Aaron Brooks07 Jeff Garcia08 Kurt Warner09 Tom Brady10 Steve McNair11 Tommy Maddox12 Drew Bledsoe13 Brett Favre14 Trent Green15 Chad Pennington16 Matt Hasslebeck17 Kerry Collins18 Jake Plummer19 Brad Johnson20 Jay Fiedler21 Drew Brees22 Patrick Ramsey23 Kordell Stewart24 Jon Kitna25 Mark Brunell26 Joey Harrington27 Brian Greise28 Marc Bulger29 Chad Hutchinson30 Tim Couch

 

[CSH]

1. D. Culpepper2. D. McNabb3. K. Warner4. P. Manning5. J. Garcia6. M. Vick7. A. Brooks8. R. Gannon9. M. Hasselbeck10. D. Bledsoe11. B. Favre12. T. Green13. S. McNair14. T. Brady15. C. Pennington16. T. Maddox17. J. Plummer18. K. Collins19. P. Ramsey20. J. Delhomme21. B. Johnson22. J. Kitna23. D. Brees24. M. Brunnell25. T. Couch26. K. Stewart27. J. Fiedler28. C. Redman29. D. Carr30. J. Harrington

 

[Keith R]

1 Daunte Culpepper 2 Donovan McNabb3 Michael Vick4 Peyton Manning 5 Rich Gannon6 Aaron Brooks7 Drew Bledsoe 8 Jeff Garcia 9 Brett Favre10 Steve McNair 11 Kurt Warner12 Matt Hasselbeck13 Chad Pennington14 Kerry Collins15 Jake Plummer16 Tom Brady 17 Tommy Maddox18 Trent Green19 Brad Johnson20 Drew Brees21 Patrick Ramsey 22 Joey Harrington23 David Carr24 Kordell Stewart25 Kelly Holcombe 26 Jay Fiedler27 Jon Kitna28 Jeff Blake29 Jake Delhomme30 Mark Brunell

 

[Pietaster]

1 Daunte Culpepper2 Michael Vick3 Donovan McNabb4 Peyton Manning5 Jeff Garcia6 Rich Gannon7 Aaron Brooks8 Brett Favre9 Steve McNair10 Kurt Warner11 Kerry Collins12 Tommy Maddox13 Matt Hasselbeck14 Trent Green15 Tom Brady16 Drew Bledsoe17 Chad Pennington18 Jake Plummer19 Jay Fiedler20 Tim Couch21 Brad Johnson22 Jon Kitna23 Patrick Ramsey24 Kordell Stewart25 Mark Brunell26 Drew Brees27 Jeff Blake28 David Carr29 Joey Harrington30 Chris Redman

 

[snido10]

1 Donavan McNabb2 Peyton Manning3 Dante Culpepper4 Jeff Garcia5 Michael Vick6 Kurt Warner7 Aaron Brooks8 Rich Gannon9 Matt Hasselbeck10 Brett Favre11 Jake Plummer12 Drew Bledsoe13 Trent Green14 Kerry Collins15 Steve McNair16 Tom Brady17 Jay Fiedler18 Chad Pennington19 Brad Johnson20 Jon Kitna21 Drew Brees22 Tommy Maddox23 Patrick Ramsey24 Mark Brunell25 Kordell Stewart26 Tim Couch27 Joey Harrington28 David Carr29 Jeff Blake30 Chris Redman

 

[smlevin]

1. Donovan McNabb2. Peyton Manning3. Mike Vick4. Rich Gannon 5. Duante Culpepper6. Kurt Warner 7. Jeff Garcia8. Aaron Brooks 9. Steve McNair10. Chad Pennington11. Brett Favre 12. Trent Green 13. Tommy Maddox 14. Drew Bledsoe15. Tom Brady16. Matt Hasselbeck 17. Kerry Collins 18. Brad Johnson 19. Jake Plummer20. Patrick Ramsey 21. Kordell Stewart22. Drew Brees23. Jay Fiedler24. Jake Delhomme25. John Kitna 26. Harrington27. Mark Brunell28. Kelly Holcombe or Tim Couch (whichever wins the job)29. David Carr30. Jeff Blake31. Chris Redman or Kyle Boller (whichever wins the job)

 

[smlevin]

1. Donovan McNabb2. Peyton Manning3. Mike Vick4. Rich Gannon 5. Duante Culpepper6. Kurt Warner 7. Jeff Garcia8. Aaron Brooks 9. Steve McNair10. Chad Pennington11. Brett Favre 12. Trent Green 13. Tommy Maddox 14. Drew Bledsoe15. Tom Brady16. Matt Hasselbeck 17. Kerry Collins 18. Brad Johnson 19. Jake Plummer20. Patrick Ramsey 21. Kordell Stewart22. Drew Brees23. Jay Fiedler24. Jake Delhomme25. John Kitna 26. Joey Harrington27. Mark Brunell28. Kelly Holcombe or Tim Couch (whichever wins the job)29. David Carr30. Jeff Blake31. Chris Redman or Kyle Boller (whichever wins the job)

 

[smlevin]

Sorry - ignore the first one.

 

[Clayton Gray]

Sorry - ignore the first one.

Sorry, but I'm going to have to ignore them both as we can't have two players listed as an either/or. Just one name per line please.

 

[Pietaster]

1 Daunte Culpepper2 Donovan McNabb3 Michael Vick4 Peyton Manning5 Rich Gannon6 Aaron Brooks7 Steve McNair8 Matt Hasselbeck 9 Brett Favre10 Kurt Warner11 Patrick Ramsey12 Tom Brady13 Tommy Maddox14 Chad Pennington15 Jake Plummer16 Trent Green 17 Kerry Collins18 Jay Fiedler19 Drew Brees20 Jon Kitna 21 Brad Johnson22 Drew Bledsoe23 Joey Harrington24 Kordell Stewart25 Kelly Holcomb/Tim Couch26 Jake Delhomme27 David Carr28 Mark Brunell29 Chad Hutchinson30 Jeff Blake

Jeff Garcia isn't a top 30 QB?Do you know something that we don't?

 

[Miz4]

1 McNabb, Donovan2 Vick, Michael3 Culpepper, Dante4 Gannon, Rich 5 Manning, Peyton6 Garcia, Jeff7 Warner, Kurt8 Farve, Brett 9 Bledsoe, Drew10 Brooks, Aaron11 McNair, Steve12 Pennington, C13 Green, Trent 14 Hasselback, M15 Brady, Tom 16 Maddox, Tom17 Collins, Kerry18 Johnson,Brad19 Plummer, Jake20 Ramsey, Patrick21 Holcomb, Kelly22 Fielder, Jay 23 Brunell, Mark24 Kitna, Jon25 Carr, Dave26 Stewart, K27 Brees, Drew28 Harrington, J29 Hutchinson, C30 Peete, R.