Link by Rob Rang
http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/story/14697702
He tweeted that this page will be updated
http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/story/14697702
He tweeted that this page will be updated
McShay had Cobb at #4 in his RB rankings not too long ago. Very interesting.Maybe more interesting, Bengals sent their RB coach and Cobb did run some RB drills. So they could be interested in both Cobb and Locke. Cobb wasn't expecting to run RB drills (he's played QB, RB and WR but teams have him pegged at WR) so there might be something to the Bengals RB coach being there and suddenly Cobb's running the RB drills.
Did you read the two sentences before that said, "tight upper body and almost zero quickness or acceleration off the line or out of breaks. He lacks zero elusiveness running after the catch, too"?Lande says Baldwin's day is a bust but doesn't delve into it more than saying he trapped a couple balls? Sounds a little biased.
That's part of his bias. I'm looking for pro day specifics, not what's been already been bandied about. Unless he was showing his elusiveness against ghosts, that has nothing to do with what he did yesterday.Did you read the two sentences before that said, "tight upper body and almost zero quickness or acceleration off the line or out of breaks. He lacks zero elusiveness running after the catch, too"?Lande says Baldwin's day is a bust but doesn't delve into it more than saying he trapped a couple balls? Sounds a little biased.
I got the exact same impression. The things he wrote just didn't add up.'Steed said:Lande says Baldwin's day is a bust but doesn't delve into it more than saying he trapped a couple balls? Sounds a little biased.
- how bad can it be?"traps way too many balls against his body" but "he didn't drop a pass"
- how many 1st and 2nd rounders are drafted to be a backup WR?"called a first-round prospect by some in the media" and "turning off many NFL people who would have considered him as a backup receiver"
- but was one of the most athletic guys at the combine and was elusive enough in college to average almost 20 ypc and score a TD every 8 catches."He is a big receiver with a tight upper body and almost zero quickness or acceleration off the line or out of breaks. He lacks zero elusiveness running after the catch, too"
6'5", 230 pound men don't need burst or elusivness to run through bump coverage, shield an inbound ball from, or jump over 5'10", 190 pound defenders.IOW... there are lots of ways to get open. And not every receiver needs to be able to use every method.Not saying Baldwin's going to be a star - just that this commentary isn't very useful. Baldwin isn't looking to be the next Steve Smith. He's hoping he's the next Plaxico Burress.'Andy Dufresne said:Did you read the two sentences before that said, "tight upper body and almost zero quickness or acceleration off the line or out of breaks. He lacks zero elusiveness running after the catch, too"?'Steed said:Lande says Baldwin's day is a bust but doesn't delve into it more than saying he trapped a couple balls? Sounds a little biased.
Snipped last sentence.they sure do in the NFL. Guy will be lucky to last a year if he has no route running awareness, elusiveness, or burst. There's been plenty of especially successful CBs that were 5-9 to 5-11. They were successful against taller WRs. This is the best of the best. One trick ponies get exposed quickly.I don't know this guy well enough to say whether this is accurate for him, but I strongly disagree with what you said. it's the NFL.6'5", 230 pound men don't need burst or elusivness to run through bump coverage, shield an inbound ball from, or jump over 5'10", 190 pound defenders.IOW... there are lots of ways to get open. And not every receiver needs to be able to use every method.'Andy Dufresne said:Did you read the two sentences before that said, "tight upper body and almost zero quickness or acceleration off the line or out of breaks. He lacks zero elusiveness running after the catch, too"?'Steed said:Lande says Baldwin's day is a bust but doesn't delve into it more than saying he trapped a couple balls? Sounds a little biased.
Russ Lande wasn't even there just as I suspected.'Andy Dufresne said:Did you read the two sentences before that said, "tight upper body and almost zero quickness or acceleration off the line or out of breaks. He lacks zero elusiveness running after the catch, too"?'Steed said:Lande says Baldwin's day is a bust but doesn't delve into it more than saying he trapped a couple balls? Sounds a little biased.
Imposing Pitt wide receiver Jonathan Baldwin wanted to set the record straight, emphasizing that he's not a body catcher as he responded to criticism of his Pro Day workout.
"The Pro Day went very well, no drops at all and I used my hands for every catch," Baldwin told National Football Post today in a telephone inteview. "My hands weren't a problem at all. I always pride myself on catching with my hands.
"I always tell the other guys you're taking a 50-50 chance when you catch it with your body. I didn't drop a pass. Body catching is definitely a no-no. I always catch it with my hands."
In an article for the Sporting News regarding Baldwin's workout on Tuesday, respected former NFL scout Russ Lande wrote that projections of Baldwin as a first-round draft prospect is "just crazy talk."
Lande criticized Baldwin for a lack of elusiveness after the catch and wrote: "Although he didn't drop a pass, he still traps way too many balls against his body instead of reaching out and snatching them."
Baldwin responded to that assessment.
"I really want to let them know how that guy wasnt even there," Baldwin said. "I found it to be more like a personal thing than him actually analyzing me. He was just saying stuff. I don't know how he got those assumptions and speculation. I had a good Pro Day.
"I do read those things and I'm the type of guy when I see some negativity it makes me laugh. I was thinking about it all last night and it made me want to work out eveen harder when I saw that."
A native of Aliquippa, Pa., Baldwin is looking to follow in the rich tradition of NFL players from his hometown including Darrelle Revis, Sean Gilbert and Mike Ditka.
"It means a lot to be a football player from there," said Baldwin, who's being advised by his cousin, former Cincinnati Bengals cornerback Charles Fisher and former Bengals defensive lineman John Thornton. "I want to continue that tradition, God willing, to the NFL. It's a great thing. Those guys are in my corner and I get good advice from them."
The 6-foot-4, 228-pounder ran the 40-yard dash in 4.43 seconds at the NFL scouting combine, bench pressed 225 pounds 20 times and registered a 42-inch vertical leap. He also posted a 10-9 broad jump, a 1.58 10-yard split, a 7.07 three-cone drill.
Baldwin said he was coming off a strained hamstring suffered two weeks before the combine.
"The best time I ever ran was a 4.37," Baldwin said. "If I hadn't gotten hurt I would have run a 4.3. That's what I was running before I got hurt. I couldn't do speed training for two weeks because I had to heal up.
A two-time All-Big East Conference selection, Baldwin caught 53 passes for 822 yards and five touchdowns last season.
He caught 57 passes for 1,111 yards and eight touchdowns the previous season.
"I've got a great work ethic, I'm coming in at 5:30 in the morning to watch film and work on routes and do all those extra things," Baldwin said. "I'll bring that competitive nature, all the necessities to be great. I'll be learning new things and soak everything up from the older guys."
Baldwin met with Pittsburgh Steelers coach Mike Tomlin and executive Kevin Colbert on Tuesday along with other Pitt players.
"Mr. Colbert gave me a tour," Baldwin said. "It was great to be in that facility. We share a training table with them, but that was the first time I got to be upstairs."
Baldwin has a two-year-old son and he says providing for him is a huge motivating force.
"It's a blessing, I love him to death," Baldwin said. "It definitely makes me work harder. I think about him all the time and all the things he could have with my success. I know God has put me on the right path.
"I read the Bible every day. I grew up as a Jehovah's Witness. My father sends me texts to read every day of scriptures. I'm a very spiritual guy."
Baldwin is much bigger than most defensive backs.
"In a jump ball situation, I automatically have the advantage," Baldwin said. "It definitely helps a lot. I can jump, too. It helps to have a big body to shield off smaller defenders."
Baldwin has been drawing some second-round grades from draft analysts.
He said if he doesn't go in the first round it will fuel his motivation.
"People always tell me if that does happen you just got to prove to everybody and keep working hard," Baldwin said. "You want to make all the teams that pass you regret it. You apply yourself and practice with excellence and good things will happen."
On writing about a Pro Day without actually being therePosted by Gregg Rosenthal on March 17, 2011, 3:09 PM EDTPittsburgh wide receiver Jonathan Baldwin participated in his Pro Day on Tuesday. We didn’t hear much about it except this so-so review from Russ Lande of the Sporting News on the event.“Wide receiver Jon Baldwin has been called a first-round prospect by some in the media, but that’s just crazy talk,” Lande wrote. “Although he didn’t drop a pass in Tuesday’s workout, he still traps way too many balls against his body instead of reaching out and snatching them.”Baldwin took exception to that criticism in comments to NFP, pointing out Lande wasn’t even at the Pro Day. We talked to one of Baldwin’s mentors John Thornton on Thursday, who also disputed Lande’s account.Thornton said Baldwin got terrific feedback from teams and didn’t struggle with trapping the ball whatsoever. He also noted Lande wasn’t at the Pro Day.That’s a pretty serious accusation, so we contacted Lande. Here was his response:“Baldwin is correct that I was not at the pro day. I did not attend because despite being a former NFL scout (I worked for the Browns and the Rams) I am now viewed as media and do not get the same access as current NFL employees do.“So our report on his Pro Day was based on speaking to an NFL source who told us how he worked out. I then combined what that source told me about Baldwin’s workout with what I saw on film when I evaluated his play for Pittsburgh to write the short note about how Baldwin’s performance at his Pro Day and our evaluation of his on-field play convinced us that he is not a 1st round receiver,” Lande said.The problem is that Lande never tells the reader he wasn’t at the Pro Day. In fact, the article strongly leads the reader to believe he was there. There are sections of the article which evaluates the events of the Pro Day in great detail without giving any credit to a third party.We don’t point all this out to pick on Lande; he does a credible job in general. This sort of second-hand evaluation is not that unique, but reporters need to be up front about where their information is coming from.The story points out a troubling trend in draft analysis: There is a lot of “expert” posturing. There is a lot of reliance on sources like scouts that may have an agenda to mislead.There is an almost desperate attempt at times to sound like authoritative insiders when we’re really getting educated guesswork.
This is such a horsecrap strawman arguement. I've been to plenty of pro days as a fan and a lot of them are run with the media/agents/fans right on the sidelines with NFL personnel on the field with prospects and college coaches. There's no reason Lande couldn't have been 30 yards away from the action and make an assessment. Instead he just relied on someone telling him Baldwin "body caught" a couple balls and passed off his opinion as him being there. I think we know why he's a former NFL scout. I used to think his rankings were good because they were against the grain, now i'm beginning to wonder if it's because he's a hack.“Baldwin is correct that I was not at the pro day. I did not attend because despite being a former NFL scout (I worked for the Browns and the Rams) I am now viewed as media and do not get the same access as current NFL employees do.
“So our report on his Pro Day was based on speaking to an NFL source who told us how he worked out. I then combined what that source told me about Baldwin’s workout with what I saw on film when I evaluated his play for Pittsburgh to write the short note about how Baldwin’s performance at his Pro Day and our evaluation of his on-field play convinced us that he is not a 1st round receiver,” Lande said.
did anyone going out and watch the highlight reel on this kid?it is hilarious. obviously, the level of competition is pretty weak but it's just play after play of him flattening and cleaning up people left and right.technique = knocking people on their tails. funny funny stuff.that's a huge number of reps. kudos to him.Some DL from Colorado School of Mines bench pressed 225 lbs 52 times.http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/03/19/pro-day-prospect-bests-combine-bench-press-record/Though this shouldn't come as a surprise. The kid squatted 905lbs at age 21.
That'd be too funny if it was taped before and presented as a live feed. Everyone in the college AV class gets a 4.0 for Green's one handed catch while leaping over the bleachers.Is that Montana kid even going to be drafted? or invited onto an NFL team as an undrafted FA? It's nice and all but why so much love for him?For those of us left scratching our heads...Green's pro-day sounds like it was a fiasco!
The NFL is so ridiculous. Seriously.That'd be too funny if it was taped before and presented as a live feed. Everyone in the college AV class gets a 4.0 for Green's one handed catch while leaping over the bleachers.Is that Montana kid even going to be drafted? or invited onto an NFL team as an undrafted FA? It's nice and all but why so much love for him?For those of us left scratching our heads...Green's pro-day sounds like it was a fiasco!
This Georgia ProDay thing sounds like something out of the NCAA.The NFL is so ridiculous. Seriously.
I guess this is the key part:Is that Montana kid even going to be drafted? or invited onto an NFL team as an undrafted FA? It's nice and all but why so much love for him?
They needed someone to throw to Green, and that was the guy they found to do it. If the above wasn't true, they'd just tell the Montana guy to go home and let NFL personnel throw.The complexities of not being able to use ex-NFL players and non-NFL staffers has caused issues at pro days, but this situation is believed to be the first time scouts and GMs watched a live feed instead of witnessing things from close range.
You mean too lazy to use the Pro-Day links already provided?For those of us left scratching our heads...Green's pro-day sounds like it was a fiasco!
Which link would that be? The one you were too lazy to bump?You mean too lazy to use the Pro-Day links already provided?For those of us left scratching our heads...Green's pro-day sounds like it was a fiasco!
They may be right about Baldwin, but this is pretty ####ty IMO.Baldwin ... has had public altercations with the Sporting News' Russ Lande and Chris Steuber of NFL Draft Scout, both for no good reason.
The other from Sporting News:Receiver Leonard Hankerson, who ran a better-than-expected 40 time at the combine, looked good running routes. Hankerson was quick and fluid into breaks and smooth in his movements. He struggled with catching the ball. Hankerson was working with a brand new quarterback brought in for the pro day. Nevertheless, he has moved into the draft's initial 40 selections and has a workout scheduled with the Kansas City Chiefs in the beginning of April.
Who to believe?According to sources, Hankerson ran sharp and precise routes, while looking very smooth, fluid and athletic in all of his drills. He also caught the ball well throughout the day. With his size (6-1 5/8, 205), he is the front-runner among a group of three receivers battling to be the No. 3 wide receiver drafted after A.J. Green and Julio Jones.
http://aol.sportingnews.com/nfl/feed/2011-01/2011-nfl-draft/story/draft-dish-nevadas-kaepernick-makes-his-case-as-ace-qbAlso:The "consensus" among NFL people present at the Nevada Pro Day was that Colin Kaepernick will be a second-round pick in April.NFL.com's Gil Brant reports that Kaepernick was "very impressive" in front of officials from 26 teams, and confirms Kaepernick has established himself as a "high-round draft prospect." Russ Lande of the Sporting News has Kaepernick rated as the No. 2 quarterback in the draft, behind only Blaine Gabbert. We have him teetering between the Seahawks at No. 25 and Bills at No. 34.
Nevada QB Colin Kaepernick worked out well this week. In addition to throwing well, he also showed the elite physical tools that tend to excite NFL teams. Although Cam Newton's rare physical talent has teams willing to overlook the fact he played in a run-option offense at Auburn, Kaepernick is still dealing with questions about having played against a lower level of competition in the WAC while playing in the Wolf Pack's "pistol" offense. He has provided enough answers from the Senior Bowl through his pro day where some team likely will take him early in the second round. Few — if any — quarterbacks in this class have Kaepernick's combination of elite natural skills and great intangibles. There is plenty of buzz about one of the teams drafting in the top 15 trading up to take one of the top quarterbacks in this class, but for many teams coveting such a passer, they have been more diligent in breaking down film of the potential best prospects from the Class of '12. They are simply taking that group — including Stanford's Andrew Luck, USC's Matt Barkley and Arizona's Nick Foles — and seeing how it compares to Newton, Kaepernick and others. This isn't either new or surprising, but it means some teams aren't sold on any of this year's quarterbacks and most are always looking at the big picture in the future to help them make smarter decisions about the present.
I leaning towards the second one, I don't remember anyone questioning his catching abilities or struggles. His workouts are the best I've seen of any WRs in this class.Two different reports on Leonard Hankerson. One from SI.com:
The other from Sporting News:Receiver Leonard Hankerson, who ran a better-than-expected 40 time at the combine, looked good running routes. Hankerson was quick and fluid into breaks and smooth in his movements. He struggled with catching the ball. Hankerson was working with a brand new quarterback brought in for the pro day. Nevertheless, he has moved into the draft's initial 40 selections and has a workout scheduled with the Kansas City Chiefs in the beginning of April.Who to believe?According to sources, Hankerson ran sharp and precise routes, while looking very smooth, fluid and athletic in all of his drills. He also caught the ball well throughout the day. With his size (6-1 5/8, 205), he is the front-runner among a group of three receivers battling to be the No. 3 wide receiver drafted after A.J. Green and Julio Jones.
Clemson DE Da'Quan Bowers (knee) turned in unofficial forty times of 4.91 and 4.85 at his Pro Day workout Friday.Bowers measured in at 6'3.5", 276 lbs with a 9'-6" broad jump and a 34.5 vertical leap. Onlookers suggested Bowers was still moving at less than full speed. "If he's fully healed, it doesn't look like it," writes the Charlotte Observer's Darin Gantt. Bowers could be in for a free-fall, as he's failed to definitively quiet concerns about his knee.
The Cleveland Plain Dealer backs up previous reports from SI's Peter King and ESPN's Todd McShay that some teams won't draft Clemson DE Da'Quan Bowers even if he works out well on Friday.Bowers underwent meniscus surgery in January. The teams reportedly believe he also has "more severe problems" in his knee that could resurface down the line. The Plain Dealer suspects the Browns would pass on Bowers if he falls to No. 6 overall because they are "sensitive" to their poor first-round track record. The team is expected to go the safe route instead.
North Carolina DE Robert Quinn "put on a show" at the Tar Heels' Pro Day Thursday.Quinn is an impressive athlete, so it's no surprise that he posted a 33-inch vertical, 10-5 1/2 broad jump, 4.26 seconds in the short shuttle and 24 reps on the bench press. Quinn also improved his forty time from 4.70 to 4.57. He did nothing to hurt his top-12 draft stock. UNC quarterback Tyler Yates, a late-round prospect, completed an amazing 110-of-112 passes at his workout.
Footage begins at 1:20 mark where he clearly looks hobbled.Bowers looked solid during position drills, displaying good movement skills and flexibility. He showed a good degree of quickness throughout the session and was smooth on his feet. Bowers also looked winded at times, huffing and puffing his way through the workout.
Read more: http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/football/nfl/nfl-draft-pro-days-2011/index.html#ixzz1IK8xwwCN
Not only making #### up after not seeing him, but it would also seem that Lande's taking stenography from the wrong people.Wide receiver Jon Baldwin has been called a first-round prospect by some in the media, but that's just crazy talk.