SHOULD THE CARDINALS KEEP KEVIN KOLB OR CUT HIM?
Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kevin Kolb didn’t exactly astound the fans in Tempe with his skills under center during the 2011 season. Subsequently, many people have begun speculating about his future with the team.
In the opinion of NFL Network correspondent Jason La Canfora, the Cardinals would be able to cut ties with Kolb this spring without suffering serious fiscal repercussions. And if this were to happen (or if Arizona were to broker a trade), Colb may be headed to Cleveland.
In many ways, such a move would make sense both for Colb and for the Cardinals. As Browns beat writer Tony Grossi has observed, Kolb excels when playing in a West Coast offense, a type of offense that Arizona decidedly doesn’t use.
For his part, Kolb has even expressed his own difficulties in adapting to the Cardinals’ offense this past season. In fact, it’s unlikely that Kolb ever did so, at least not completely — his lack of command over the offense and injuries both prevented Kolb from proving himself to be the marquee quarterback for which Arizona and its fans were hoping.
Instead, the Cardinals’ administration and the team’s faithful are likely to remember the latter part of the season, which was primarily spearheaded by Colb’s understudy, John Skelton. During that run, the Cardinals managed some close wins against the Rams (twice), the Browns, the Eagles, the Cowboys, the 49ers and the Seahawks. Significantly, Kolb only started during one of those wins (Cowboys, Week 13), while the rest saw Skelton as a starter; not to mention, three of those wins during this time were in Overtime as well.
So will Skelton ultimately become Arizona’s franchise quarterback? With Matt Flynn on the market and a host of skilled young quarterbacks available in the draft, it isn’t likely. However, as some experts have observed, Kolb might do very well in the Browns’ system, which runs a West Coast Offense similar to the one under which Kolb played in Philadelphia.
But what about Colt McCoy, you may ask? Well, not to long ago, Browns president Mike Holmgren said that he had numerous reservations about naming McCoy (who only had four wins last season) as the team’s starting quarterback this fall. Kolb’s own status with the Cardinals could mean that he’s in an ideal position to fill Cleveland’s needs — that is, assuming he’s either released or put up for trade.
As for the Cardinals’ financial incentives to either cut or trade Kolb — as part of the trade from the Eagles, Kolb agreed to a 5-year contract extension worth a maximum of $63.5 million, with $21 million guaranteed. That deal also included a $7 million roster bonus by next month (March) that the Cardinals could sidestep if Kolb were to be cut loose. Additionally, as La Canfora observes, Kolb’s $9 million salary and $2 million roster bonus for the 2013 season would be eliminated, and the Cardinals would only suffer minor salary cap penalties as a result.
Thus far, the Cardinals’ front office hasn’t released any decision regarding Kolb’s future with the franchise; however, if he stays on the roster, he’ll be counting $10.5 million against the team’s 2012 cap. By contrast, Skelton will earn a measly $490,000 in 2012, which is barely a fraction of what Kolb is scheduled make.
From a purely pragmatic perspective for this coming season, then, Arizona would do much better to spend that $7 million bonus on a linebacker or a receiver. The same is true in the long-term for the Cardinals as well — it would be an excellent move to cut (or trade) Kolb and stoically suffer the cap penalty, just so the team could fill its needs at other positions. And were Arizona to be absolutely unwilling to start Skelton, the team could easily try and grab Matt Flynn or trade up in the draft for a chance to get a quarterback (as we previously mentioned).
On the other hand, it’s hard to believe the Cardinals have now used a top 10 first round pick on one quarterback and then later given up both a starting cornerback and 2nd round pick for another one. If the administration cuts Kolb, they will effectively be admitting defeat with nothing to show for either one of those transactions — and with that in mind, it’s not entirely clear that the franchise is ready to take that step.
In all likelihood, Kolb will return in a Cardinals uniform this fall, even if it isn’t the best possible outcome either for himself or for his team.