Rank the NFL RBs in terms of real life talent(not FF) (1 Viewer)

[jwvdcw]

I think this is a very interesting question, and it will produce some good debate. Where do you rank LJ and SA for example? Are they just products of their great o-lines or legit talents? Its a tough question to answer because so much of a RBs success hinges upon surrounding talent. Take everything into consideration from rushing ability to pass protection to leadership. Heres my top 10:

1. LT2

2. Tiki Barber

3. S Alexander

4. Edge

5. Portis

6. LJ

7. B Westbrook

8. W Dunn

9. J Lewis

10. T Jones

Just missed()in no particular order): McGahee, S Jackson, L Jordan

Note: I chose not to rank the rookies in here because I didn't want this to turn into another Reggie Bush thread. FWIW he would definitely be in my top 10 if I had. I also don't have any RBs on my list who were rookies last year. This wasn't totally intentional, as I would've put one on the list if they deserved it, but I do value consistency somewhat and none of them had proven enough to me.

 

[Grigs Allmoon]

Pretty darn accurate list you have there, IMO.

I'd have to think about it, but mine wouldn't be a while lot different in the top 3-5.

 

[Lightning Fast Whip]

T Jones 10th? No way.

One year wonder who was too bad despite any excuses otherwise for more than one year.

 

[Noahs Troopers]

In terms of "Talent" I put McGahee and Fred Taylor both in the top 5.

 

[gump]

Slot Carnell Williams in at #7....

 

[Phlash]

In terms of "Talent" I put McGahee and Fred Taylor both in the top 5.

Jim Brown thinks that Fred Taylor is still the most talented RB in the league. If that becomes production, well that's anyone's guess.

 

[Carter_Can_Fly]

1. LT22. Tiki Barber3. S Alexander4. Edge5. Portis6. LJ7. B Westbrook8. W Dunn9. J Lewis10. T JonesJust missed()in no particular order): McGahee, S Jackson, L Jordan

1. LT22. Tiki Barber3. S Alexander4. Edge5. Portis6. LJ7. S Jackson8. L. Jordan9. B. Westbrook10. McGaheeWithout rookies here is my list. I am 100% in agreence with your first 6. I than feel that Dunn, Lewis and Jones don't deserve to be on this top 10 list.

 

[Assani Fisher]

Slot Carnell Williams in at #7....

I'm not sure if I feel he is good enough at pass protection, leadership, or proven durability yet to warrant such a high ranking.

 

[mrspree15]

In terms of "Talent" I put McGahee and Fred Taylor both in the top 5.

Jim Brown thinks that Fred Taylor is still the most talented RB in the league. If that becomes production, well that's anyone's guess.

Hopefully Fred's still got it, but he would definitely be near the top of my list throughout his career. The man's got (had?) speed and power and wiggle.

 

[gump]

Slot Carnell Williams in at #7....

I'm not sure if I feel he is good enough at pass protection, leadership, or proven durability yet to warrant such a high ranking.

Leadership is there...he has been nothing but outstanding in every way off the field, including making sure he was in camp on time by signing a contract at the wee hours of the morning and driving to Orlando immediately to get there by the first morning practice.I agree on the pass protection and durability questions, but looking at some of the others ranked like Westbrook and Taylor, don't see much of a difference.I think Carnell is better at running the football than everyone but the top 6.

 

[Banger]

I think this is a very interesting question, and it will produce some good debate. Where do you rank LJ and SA for example? Are they just products of their great o-lines or legit talents? Its a tough question to answer because so much of a RBs success hinges upon surrounding talent. Take everything into consideration from rushing ability to pass protection to leadership. Heres my top 10:1. LT22. Tiki Barber3. S Alexander4. Edge5. Portis6. LJ7. B Westbrook8. W Dunn9. J Lewis10. T JonesJust missed()in no particular order): McGahee, S Jackson, L JordanNote: I chose not to rank the rookies in here because I didn't want this to turn into another Reggie Bush thread. FWIW he would definitely be in my top 10 if I had. I also don't have any RBs on my list who were rookies last year. This wasn't totally intentional, as I would've put one on the list if they deserved it, but I do value consistency somewhat and none of them had proven enough to me.

Good list. I'd go...LTTikiPortisSA McGaheeEdge LJDunnCMart (when healthy)Westbrook

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Pinner down?

 

[Blick]

In terms of "Talent" I put McGahee and Fred Taylor both in the top 5.

Jim Brown thinks that Fred Taylor is still the most talented RB in the league. If that becomes production, well that's anyone's guess.

Hopefully Fred's still got it, but he would definitely be near the top of my list throughout his career. The man's got (had?) speed and power and wiggle.

Amen. Why no love??

 

[Liquid Tension]

I think this is a very interesting question, and it will produce some good debate. Where do you rank LJ and SA for example? Are they just products of their great o-lines or legit talents? Its a tough question to answer because so much of a RBs success hinges upon surrounding talent. Take everything into consideration from rushing ability to pass protection to leadership. Heres my top 10:1. LT22. Tiki Barber3. S Alexander4. Edge5. Portis6. LJ7. B Westbrook8. W Dunn9. J Lewis10. T JonesJust missed()in no particular order): McGahee, S Jackson, L JordanNote: I chose not to rank the rookies in here because I didn't want this to turn into another Reggie Bush thread. FWIW he would definitely be in my top 10 if I had. I also don't have any RBs on my list who were rookies last year. This wasn't totally intentional, as I would've put one on the list if they deserved it, but I do value consistency somewhat and none of them had proven enough to me.

I have trouble after the top 2 so I am only going to list the top 2.Without a doubt, LT2 is the most talented back in the NFL. My 2nd one will be debated, but Willis Mcgahee is #2. If he were on KC or Seattle, he would be the 1st pick in the draft. He is UBER talented

 

[jurb26]

Awful hard after the top 5 or so, so I'll just go through them:

LT

Portis

McGahee

Edge

SA

 

[Grigs Allmoon]

Without a doubt, LT2 is the most talented back in the NFL. My 2nd one will be debated, but Willis Mcgahee is #2. If he were on KC or Seattle, he would be the 1st pick in the draft. He is UBER talented

Wow...McGahee is barely above average. What are you looking at? Old college film?