Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Rank the top 20 NFL QB's from today forward... (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter biggamer3
- Start date
Lucky Lefty
Footballguy
I would move Stafford up ahead of Bradford...
Last edited by a moderator:
biggamer3
Footballguy
Stafford is really the NFL's Greg Oden. He just cant stay on the field. Not sure he would go above any of the guys ahead of him
scrumptrulescent
Footballguy
Eli rarely gets any love. He sure makes a solid backup.
B Maverick
Footballguy
Careful Sarnoff doesnt see you listing his buddy Tebow below Big Ben!!!
I like your listings although I would have flacco at the bottom of his tier. And trade cassel and Tebow. I think cassel had a surprise good year but i dont see another. And yes, NE was a good year but the talent there was better. I dont see him as a long term guy.
I like your listings although I would have flacco at the bottom of his tier. And trade cassel and Tebow. I think cassel had a surprise good year but i dont see another. And yes, NE was a good year but the talent there was better. I dont see him as a long term guy.
Carolina Hustler
Footballguy
Nice list.. Pretty good ranking
I think Cassell is a dark horse with the ability to move into tier 2
Freeman should probably be in tier 3...
I think Cassell is a dark horse with the ability to move into tier 2
Freeman should probably be in tier 3...
FUBAR
Footballguy
Pretty solid list. I have only Rodgers and Vick as my tier one and Romo gets into tier two. Freeman and Bradford ahead of Schaub and Tebow moves up a tier. I probably put McNabb and :gasp: maybe even VY ahead of Henne.
underdogx3
Footballguy
I would move Cutler up to Tier 2 and include Kolb and Palmer ahead of Henne and Tebow. Nice list.
biggamer3
Footballguy
Yeah I was thinking about putting him and Stafford in next tier but I can easily see them putting up real nice numbers next year and they are far above the few guys in tier 3 IMOI am not a big fan of Cutler and can't see him being drafted before any of the guys on the list really unless you have lots of Bears homersCarolina Hustler said:
SaintsInDome2006
Footballguy
C'mon, this list won't look the same by end of next year.
My guess is tier 1 remains the same but (if they all stay healthy) Stafford, Tebow and Freeman will be near the top of Tier 2 end of 2011.
My guess is tier 1 remains the same but (if they all stay healthy) Stafford, Tebow and Freeman will be near the top of Tier 2 end of 2011.
Instinctive
Footballguy
I think just the opposite on Freeman. I think the spot for him is 9, although I might rather have him than some of the other guys as well if my team was still young and RB-less.
I know everyones scoring systems are different but in most leagues I'm in Freeman was between 7-10 in Qb's scoring with a very young team I'm not sure why he wouldn't move up. I understand Ben missed 4 games and Bradford will only get better but the people saying Teir three I just don't get.
since you specifically say fantasy-wise i will disagree with this statement. he was the no. 9 overall QB and no. 11 if you go by PPG and move orton and roethlisberger ahead of him.
bulger2holt
Footballguy
Where would Bradford be if he had a true #1 WR ?
Iwannabeacowboybaby!
Footballguy
How could Stafford be considered in the same Tier as Big Ben when Stafford's hardly played in his professional career. There's too many guys in that 2nd Tier IMO. I don't think Flacco is in there either, he's in a flight down.
He's got him ranked 13. That would be the #1 backup.
Breesisdaman
Footballguy
TIER 1
1 Rodgers
2 Brees
3 P Manning
4 Rivers
TIER 2
5 Brady
6 Vick
7 Romo
8 Big Ben
TIER 3
9 Stafford
10 Schaub
11 Flacco
12 Ryan
TIER 4
13 Bradford
14 Eli Manning
15 Josh Freeman
16 Sanchez
TIER 5
17 Cutler
18 Tebow
19 Cassel
20 Henne
1 Rodgers
2 Brees
3 P Manning
4 Rivers
TIER 2
5 Brady
6 Vick
7 Romo
8 Big Ben
TIER 3
9 Stafford
10 Schaub
11 Flacco
12 Ryan
TIER 4
13 Bradford
14 Eli Manning
15 Josh Freeman
16 Sanchez
TIER 5
17 Cutler
18 Tebow
19 Cassel
20 Henne
Last edited by a moderator:
biggamer3
Footballguy
I could see all the guys from my second tear right near the Big Bens or Matt Ryans by next years end. Its crazy how much of a dropoff there is from like QB #18- #30 from the guys before 18. The NFL has like 10 QB's after the elite ones who are almost interchangable in rankings and then the bottom 10 qb's who really really suck
Similar threads
