rank these pitchers (1 Viewer)

[littletank]

6 win, -2loss, 1inning, 1k, -1 every 2hits, -1 every 3bb's, -1 every 2er's.

Baker

Slowey

Maholm

Volstad

Kershaw

 

[Onions]

6 win, -2loss, 1inning, 1k, -1 every 2hits, -1 every 3bb's, -1 every 2er's.BakerSloweyMaholmVolstadKershaw

SloweyBakerKershawMaholmVolstad

 

[blackjack23]

6 win, -2loss, 1inning, 1k, -1 every 2hits, -1 every 3bb's, -1 every 2er's.BakerSloweyMaholmVolstadKershaw

SloweyBakerKershawMaholmVolstad

volstad is really good

 

[blackjack23]

Id rank them:

Volstad

Slowey

Baker

Maholm

Kershaw

 

[Onions]

6 win, -2loss, 1inning, 1k, -1 every 2hits, -1 every 3bb's, -1 every 2er's.

Baker

Slowey

Maholm

Volstad

Kershaw

SloweyBaker

Kershaw

Maholm

Volstad

volstad is really good

He's not bad, but in my opinion, Volstad is clearly five of five on this particular list. Don't be fooled by his numbers over his first 100 IP...He walks alot of hitters and doesn't strike out enough to be discussed with the others (except possibly Maholm).

Edited to add: My rankings are based on the 2009 season...I think Volstad will develop moving forward (whereas Maholm doesn't have much upside), and will be a very productive big league pitcher. He's just going to have to endure some growing pains first)

 

[Notinuse]

Kershaw

Volstad

Slowey

Maholm

Baker

 

[blackjack23]

I think weve confused littletank more than helped

 

[Onions]

I think weve confused littletank more than helped

 

[Spartans Rule]

6 win, -2loss, 1inning, 1k, -1 every 2hits, -1 every 3bb's, -1 every 2er's.

This scoring system HEAVILY favors strikeout pitchers. The negative points won't add up very fast, but 1 point per K will.I would rank them:Kershaw - Dream scoring system for him. The gems will outweigh the beatings.Slowey - Would be the best on this list in most formats.Volstad - K rate is improving.Baker - I know it's early, but 7 HR in 8.2 IP is ridiculously bad.Maholm - Awful scoring system for him. Everything he does well is undervalued.

 

[littletank]

I think weve confused littletank more than helped

Yeah, a little. I currently have Baker and Kershaw and was hoping there was a pitcher definately better then 1 of those so I would have the opp. to pick up Smoltz and put him on the DL. (We have to drop a player at the position to pick up another player at that position)Another thing that makes it more difficult is that Baker goes twice this week, although that doesn't mean much considering how he's pitched.I guess, I'll wait 1 more week and see if they both still suck and hope that Smoltz isn't grabbed next weekend.

 

[cosjobs]

6 win, -2loss, 1inning, 1k, -1 every 2hits, -1 every 3bb's, -1 every 2er's.

This scoring system HEAVILY favors strikeout pitchers. The negative points won't add up very fast, but 1 point per K will.I would rank them:Kershaw - Dream scoring system for him. The gems will outweigh the beatings.Slowey - Would be the best on this list in most formats.Volstad - K rate is improving.Baker - I know it's early, but 7 HR in 8.2 IP is ridiculously bad.Maholm - Awful scoring system for him. Everything he does well is undervalued.

I pretty much agree with this, but take Kershaw down a notch for this season and rasie baker a notch because of last season:SloweyKershawBaker/VolstadMaholm