Rate My Draft (1 Viewer)

[chet]

10 teams, NL only 5x5

1c, 1 1b, 1 2b, 1 ss, 1 3b, 1 MI, 1 CI, 5 OF, 1 U, 9 P, 3 Bench

1.10 Beltran NYM OF

2.1 R Howard Phi 1B

3.10 S Victorino Phi OF

4.1 A GonzalezSD 1B

5.10 R Ludwick Stl OF

6.1 R Zimmerman Was 3B

7,10 L Milledge Was OF

8.1 J Vazquez Atl SP

9.10 F Lewis SF OF

10.1 O Perez NYM SP

11.10 Y Escobar Atl SS

12.1 F Sanchez Pit 2B

13.10 M Pelfrey NYM SP

14.1 E Renteria SF SS

15.10 C Blake LAD 1B

16.1 u Jiminez Col SP

17.10 P Maholm Pit SP

18.1 T Wellemeyer Stl SP/RP

19.10 I Snell Pit SP

20.1 J Garland Ari SP

21.10 B Howry SF RP

22.1 S Shell Was RP

23.10 m Hoffpauir ChC OF

24.1 A Escobar Mil SS

25.10 C Ruiz Pit C

I know I don't have a catcher or saves but am looking for brutal feedback. Most of the GMs are new to fantasy bball--don't be shy.

 

[Eephus]

Pretty solid offense but you're really punting SVs. You'll be lucky to hit double digits with your RPs. I don't know when the last closer went in your draft. If there were any on the board in rounds 10 or 12, you should have picked one instead of Ollie Perez or Freddie Sanchez.

I'm big on Paul Maholm this year.

 

[chet]

Pretty solid offense but you're really punting SVs. You'll be lucky to hit double digits with your RPs. I don't know when the last closer went in your draft. If there were any on the board in rounds 10 or 12, you should have picked one instead of Ollie Perez or Freddie Sanchez.I'm big on Paul Maholm this year.

Yeah, I should have picked up a closer in 10-12--there were lots available.One guy has 4: Valverde (Astros--rd 6), Bell (SDP--rd9), Wilson (SF rd 10) and Lindstrom (FLA rd 12).I am going to try to trade for Lindstrom.

 

[guru_007]

I'll rate it a C+

In a one division league that mandates a starting catcher (or a two division league that mandates 2 starting catchers) it would be best not to wait to draft a catcher until the end, as those who have a good one (i.e. Soto, Martin, McCann) will have a huge advantage (imo) over those that don't have a good one (Ruiz).

Your offense is very good - but I think you're going to have to move some people to get some pitching. Your relief pitching is non-existent, although I've seen plenty of teams punt saves and win leagues. But your starting pitching has a chance to be awful in WHIP & ERA. You should be solid in K's and wins.....maybe package a high strikeout, high whip pitcher like Oliver Perez with a guy that gets off to a fast start (I would not hesitate to move Adrian Gonzalez if he starts off fast) to get a stud reliever and maybe a low WHIP starter (A guy like Greg Maddux used to fit this bill perfectly, as his WHIP was awesome, but his k's were so-so, current day guys maybe like a Derek Lowe?).

g'luck

 

[The Hank]

25.10 C Ruiz Pit C

Who is this?

(Pirates Homer)

Pirates 40-Man Roster

Active Roster | 40-Man Roster | Non-Roster Invitees | Depth Chart

40-Man Roster

Pitchers B/T Ht Wt DOB

* 46 Jimmy Barthmaier R/R 6-5 215 01/06/84

17 Sean Burnett L/L 6-1 200 09/17/82

55 Matt Capps R/R 6-2 245 09/03/83

43 Jesse Chavez R/R 6-2 170 08/21/83

* 50 David Davidson L/L 6-1 200 04/23/84

57 Zach Duke L/L 6-2 205 04/19/83

* 32 Phil Dumatrait R/L 6-2 200 07/12/81 15-day Disabled List

* 24 Tom Gorzelanny L/L 6-2 200 07/12/82

34 John Grabow L/L 6-2 205 11/04/78

38 Craig Hansen R/R 6-6 225 11/15/83

27 Jeff Karstens R/R 6-3 185 09/24/82

28 Paul Maholm L/L 6-2 225 06/25/82

47 Evan Meek R/R 6-0 220 05/12/83

49 Ross Ohlendorf R/R 6-4 235 08/08/82

45 Ian Snell R/R 5-11 200 10/30/81

* 61 Jeff Sues R/R 6-4 230 06/08/83

* 63 Ronald Uviedo R/R 6-1 160 10/07/86

* 76 Virgil Vasquez R/R 6-3 205 06/07/82

56 Donald Veal L/L 6-4 230 09/18/84

30 Tyler Yates R/R 6-4 250 08/07/77

Catchers B/T Ht Wt DOB

* 23 Robinzon Diaz R/R 5-11 220 09/19/83

41 Ryan Doumit S/R 6-1 215 04/03/81

35 Jason Jaramillo S/R 6-0 200 10/09/82

* 64 Steven Lerud L/R 6-1 210 10/13/84

Infielders B/T Ht Wt DOB

* 53 Pedro Alvarez L/R 6-3 235 02/06/87

* 10 Brian Bixler R/R 6-1 195 10/22/82

36 Luis Cruz R/R 6-1 215 02/10/84

25 Adam LaRoche L/L 6-3 205 11/06/79

15 Andy LaRoche R/R 6-1 210 09/13/83

12 Freddy Sanchez R/R 5-10 190 12/21/77

5 Ramon Vazquez L/R 5-11 170 08/21/76

* 19 Neil Walker S/R 6-3 215 09/10/85

2 Jack Wilson R/R 6-0 200 12/29/77

Outfielders B/T Ht Wt DOB

16 Eric Hinske L/R 6-1 235 08/05/77

13 Nate McLouth L/R 5-11 180 10/28/81

3 Nyjer Morgan L/L 6-0 175 07/02/80

44 Brandon Moss L/R 6-0 205 09/16/83

* 51 Steve Pearce R/R 5-11 215 04/13/83

* 31 Jose Tabata R/R 5-11 215 08/12/88

 

[chet]

25.10 C Ruiz Pit C

Who is this?

(Pirates Homer)

Pirates 40-Man Roster

Active Roster | 40-Man Roster | Non-Roster Invitees | Depth Chart

40-Man Roster

Pitchers B/T Ht Wt DOB

* 46 Jimmy Barthmaier R/R 6-5 215 01/06/84

17 Sean Burnett L/L 6-1 200 09/17/82

55 Matt Capps R/R 6-2 245 09/03/83

43 Jesse Chavez R/R 6-2 170 08/21/83

* 50 David Davidson L/L 6-1 200 04/23/84

57 Zach Duke L/L 6-2 205 04/19/83

* 32 Phil Dumatrait R/L 6-2 200 07/12/81 15-day Disabled List

* 24 Tom Gorzelanny L/L 6-2 200 07/12/82

34 John Grabow L/L 6-2 205 11/04/78

38 Craig Hansen R/R 6-6 225 11/15/83

27 Jeff Karstens R/R 6-3 185 09/24/82

28 Paul Maholm L/L 6-2 225 06/25/82

47 Evan Meek R/R 6-0 220 05/12/83

49 Ross Ohlendorf R/R 6-4 235 08/08/82

45 Ian Snell R/R 5-11 200 10/30/81

* 61 Jeff Sues R/R 6-4 230 06/08/83

* 63 Ronald Uviedo R/R 6-1 160 10/07/86

* 76 Virgil Vasquez R/R 6-3 205 06/07/82

56 Donald Veal L/L 6-4 230 09/18/84

30 Tyler Yates R/R 6-4 250 08/07/77

Catchers B/T Ht Wt DOB

* 23 Robinzon Diaz R/R 5-11 220 09/19/83

41 Ryan Doumit S/R 6-1 215 04/03/81

35 Jason Jaramillo S/R 6-0 200 10/09/82

* 64 Steven Lerud L/R 6-1 210 10/13/84

Infielders B/T Ht Wt DOB

* 53 Pedro Alvarez L/R 6-3 235 02/06/87

* 10 Brian Bixler R/R 6-1 195 10/22/82

36 Luis Cruz R/R 6-1 215 02/10/84

25 Adam LaRoche L/L 6-3 205 11/06/79

15 Andy LaRoche R/R 6-1 210 09/13/83

12 Freddy Sanchez R/R 5-10 190 12/21/77

5 Ramon Vazquez L/R 5-11 170 08/21/76

* 19 Neil Walker S/R 6-3 215 09/10/85

2 Jack Wilson R/R 6-0 200 12/29/77

Outfielders B/T Ht Wt DOB

16 Eric Hinske L/R 6-1 235 08/05/77

13 Nate McLouth L/R 5-11 180 10/28/81

3 Nyjer Morgan L/L 6-0 175 07/02/80

44 Brandon Moss L/R 6-0 205 09/16/83

* 51 Steve Pearce R/R 5-11 215 04/13/83

* 31 Jose Tabata R/R 5-11 215 08/12/88

my badhe's on the phillies