Review Every TD? (1 Viewer)

[ratbast]

The new "review every TD rule" is very anticlimactic. They should encourage the Ref to show more emotion, like when an umpire "punches out" a called 3rd strike. The review process is definitely going to be painful. Are they going to review breakaways?

 

[jacobo_moses]

Dude from what I understand its every score basically yeah. Talk about dragging out the game even more. What the heck

 

[shortbow]

From what I understand obvious TDs arent reviewed but if there is anything questionable its reviewed.

They have a booth watching and anytime a team scores the refs get one of two signals, clear meaning it stands or review meaning they need to go to the booth.

 

[smackdaddies]

Big Ten reviews every play I believe (certainly every td) It doesn't seem to slow the game down

 

[Ghost Rider]

I like this. College ball does it already, and they won't stop to review touchdowns where there is no question about it.

 

[ratbast]

I like this. College ball does it already, and they won't stop to review touchdowns where there is no question about it.

Well maybe if they stop focusing on the booth it will be better.

 

[Dez]

It's only gonna hurt when it is your guy losing the TD.

 

[JuSt CuZ]

I like it, anything that makes the calls right, is better to me.

 

[poopdawg]

I never get this stupid argument and quite frankly it pisses me off. Let's say a game ends 35-28. Albeit an abnormal score on the high side. Even if every single TD was challenged, it would add an extra 9 minutes onto the game. Is someone really that opposed to it? I myself would actually prefer if I had 9 more mins tO watch on a sunday....

 

[glumpy]

I never get this stupid argument and quite frankly it pisses me off. Let's say a game ends 35-28. Albeit an abnormal score on the high side. Even if every single TD was challenged, it would add an extra 9 minutes onto the game. Is someone really that opposed to it? I myself would actually prefer if I had 9 more mins to watch refill glasses on a sunday....

 

[werdnoynek]

I never get this stupid argument and quite frankly it pisses me off. Let's say a game ends 35-28. Albeit an abnormal score on the high side. Even if every single TD was challenged, it would add an extra 9 minutes onto the game. Is someone really that opposed to it? I myself would actually prefer if I had 9 more mins tO watch on a sunday....

 

[smackdaddies]

I never get this stupid argument and quite frankly it pisses me off. Let's say a game ends 35-28. Albeit an abnormal score on the high side. Even if every single TD was challenged, it would add an extra 9 minutes onto the game. Is someone really that opposed to it? I myself would actually prefer if I had 9 more mins tO watch on a sunday....

That's not how it works in the Big Ten. Not even once per game do you notice any delay. There is no challenge system - the plays are simply automatically reviewed and play continues as normal unless the replay booth notifies the field.

 

[mcintyre1]

I never get this stupid argument and quite frankly it pisses me off. Let's say a game ends 35-28. Albeit an abnormal score on the high side. Even if every single TD was challenged, it would add an extra 9 minutes onto the game. Is someone really that opposed to it? I myself would actually prefer if I had 9 more mins tO watch on a sunday....

That's not how it works in the Big Ten. Not even once per game do you notice any delay. There is no challenge system - the plays are simply automatically reviewed and play continues as normal unless the replay booth notifies the field.

Exactly, college pulls this off so much better than the NFL, it's a complete joke. Unless fans are already screaming at their TV that it was a blown call, there's not so much as a hiccup on the field.

 

[Godsbrother]

I like this. College ball does it already, and they won't stop to review touchdowns where there is no question about it.

The clock is already stopped so having the booth take a quick look at the play isn't going to slow down the game much at all.