Robinson Jr for Reed vs. Chase Brown for MHJ (2 Viewers)

[RaidersAreOne]

Which trade do you prefer, or are they both good? Specifically 0.5 PPR.

 

[iamkoza]

would need to know roster to give analysis

 

[RaidersAreOne]

would need to know roster to give analysis

Apologies:

I'm 4-3, 12 man, 0.5 PPR. My current roster:

• Daniels
• AJ Brown, Davante Adams, Jennings, Wicks
• JT, Achane, Robinson Jr, Chase Brown, Allgeier, Braelon Allen, Sean Tucker
• Pitts, Hockenson
• Broncos

Chase Brown for MHJ or Brian Robinson Jr for Jayden Reed. There might be a few extra pieces to come shortly but this would be the meat of the deal.

 

[1320kid]

You are set at RB imo with JT back, Achane gets the Tua offense, and Rob Jr is the dude in WAS and Daniels shouldn't be out long. The rest is depth.

I like Rob Jr over C Brown ROS. But I like Reed over MHJ as he hasn't clicked with Kyler. He actually looked disconnected from the game, like his mind was elsewhere playing the Chargers imo. Not a good sign. If he can figure it out he will be a stud but we are in week 8 and it hasn't happened yet.

Givin your lineup and needs I would lean for getting Reed. AJ Brown is a beast and Adams/Rodgers may click? If they don't though you are thin and need a better WR which Reed is over MHJ. Even though you are losing the better RB in Rob Jr, you still have two good ones and C Brown is no slouch and should be a fine RB3.

 

[RaidersAreOne]

You are set at RB imo with JT back, Achane gets the Tua offense, and Rob Jr is the dude in WAS and Daniels shouldn't be out long. The rest is depth.

I like Rob Jr over C Brown ROS. But I like Reed over MHJ as he hasn't clicked with Kyler. He actually looked disconnected from the game, like his mind was elsewhere playing the Chargers imo. Not a good sign. If he can figure it out he will be a stud but we are in week 8 and it hasn't happened yet.

Givin your lineup and needs I would lean for getting Reed. AJ Brown is a beast and Adams/Rodgers may click? If they don't though you are thin and need a better WR which Reed is over MHJ. Even though you are losing the better RB in Rob Jr, you still have two good ones and C Brown is no slouch and should be a fine RB3.

Thanks for the insight man!

We've been going back and forth a ton and he's officially offered Reed + Mattison for Robinson Jr + Jennings. I countered for Reed + Diontae Johnson for Robinson Jr + Jennings.

 

[RaidersAreOne]

Well boys the trade went through!

Received:

• Reed, Diontae Johnson, Tua

Sent:

• Robinson Jr, Jennings, Wicks

My new roster:

• Daniels, Tua
• JT, Achane, Chase Brown, Allgeier, Braelon Allen, Tucker
• AJ Brown, Reed, Adams, Dionte Johnson
• Hockenson, Pitts
• Broncos

I picked up Jennings and Wicks on the WW a couple days ago so I am happy overall.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

As long as Achane stays healthy I think you are fine but like Robinson over Chase. Hopefully it works out for you.

See mine please: https://forums.footballguys.com/threads/dynasty-gibbs-late-2025-1st-for-jjacobs-ncollins.814618/

 

[Jaruby]

I wouldn’t have traded Robinson Jr. but nice trade especially if Diontae gets traded to a good team or at least a team with a QB.