Sheffield or Mclouth? (1 Viewer)

[dundeeslugger]

who would you rather have?

10 team h2h points

1=1,2=2,3=3, HR=4, RBI=2, R=2, SB=2, BB=1, SO=-1, CS=-1

and if you would rather have Mclouth would you trade Sheffield for Cueto?

 

[Finless]

who would you rather have?10 team h2h points1=1,2=2,3=3, HR=4, RBI=2, R=2, SB=2, BB=1, SO=-1, CS=-1and if you would rather have Mclouth would you trade Sheffield for Cueto?

I would trade Sheffield for Cueto if I needed the pitching. Sheff is a ? at this point.

 

[shadyridr]

Ill take Shef. Got off to a slow start HR, RBI, & R wise but its not like hes not hitting. Hes one of the few guys on that team who is actually hitting. Once the offense comes around he should be deadly in the middle of that order.

 

[Spartans Rule]

Sheffield in a points league no doubt.

Roto might be open to debate because of McLouth's steals, but your scoring looks very friendly to Shef. 2 points per R and RBI and 1 point per BB will give him a big edge over Nate.

 

[wilked]

Take the sheff

 

[thehornet]

sheff over mclouth this year. and is not close for me.

i would prob trade sheff for cueto if was desperate for Pitching help and loaded at batting.

 

[Mookie Blaylock]

sheff over mclouth this year. and is not close for me.i would prob trade sheff for cueto if was desperate for Pitching help and loaded at batting.

But would the Cueto owner trade him for Sheff? I would honestly think that the kid's ceiling is so high right now that a one for one wouldn't work for Sheff. Maybe in a redraft, but never in April in a Dynasty.

 

[thehornet]

sheff over mclouth this year. and is not close for me.i would prob trade sheff for cueto if was desperate for Pitching help and loaded at batting.

But would the Cueto owner trade him for Sheff? I would honestly think that the kid's ceiling is so high right now that a one for one wouldn't work for Sheff. Maybe in a redraft, but never in April in a Dynasty.

agreed. i have him in my keeper and there is very little that i would trade him for right now.