Should a retired player that chooses to come back go right back to the (1 Viewer)

[scottybo]

Example:

Corey Dillon retired while Team A had him on their Fantasy Team.

Corey Dillon is now thinking of returning to the NFL.

Team B wants to pick him up, but should Team A have the choice first?

 

[DA RAIDERS]

if he dropped him, he dropped him.

 

[JohnnyU]

I meant to vote no. I was thinking it was the NFL team, not the fantasy team.

 

[bigmurd]

if he dropped him, he dropped him.

The only answer.

 

[Dope]

Happened to me with Robert Smith.

He led the league in rushing...then he just up and retired.

I kept him on my roster for a few weeks into the next season, but I eventually had to drop him.

Tough luck. This is what happens with Dynasty leagues that are older than 2 years. You'll see stuff like this happening more and more often.

 

[kevinray]

They only reason he should have first chance at him is if the league rules forced him to drop retired players.

 

[Ketamine Dreams]

No, you lose rights to them when you drop them...

 

[-OZ-]

I could see establishing league rules that provide for this, but in the absence thereof, no.

 

[QuizGuy66]

There's a dude in one of my leagues who DRAFTED Dillon (and has actually kept him all year). The answer to this poll is HELL NO.

-QG

 

[bigfoamfinger]

[Yes, that team that owned him should get him if they want him. [ 3 ] [5.66%] ]

I am shocked, that is 3 more than I thought would have said yes.

He is fair game for whatever the leagues pick up rules are, unless of course he was drafted. My brother drafted Barry Sanders for 4 years after he retired, convinced that he was coming back.

 

[montana_grizzly_bears]

Did Dillon ever actually retire?

 

[Perfect Tommy]

[Yes, that team that owned him should get him if they want him. [ 3 ] [5.66%] ]I am shocked, that is 3 more than I thought would have said yes.He is fair game for whatever the leagues pick up rules are, unless of course he was drafted. My brother drafted Barry Sanders for 4 years after he retired, convinced that he was coming back.

In any poll some people will misread the question or mark the wrong chad. Especially people in Florida.

 

[moleculo]

[Yes, that team that owned him should get him if they want him. [ 3 ] [5.66%] ]I am shocked, that is 3 more than I thought would have said yes.He is fair game for whatever the leagues pick up rules are, unless of course he was drafted. My brother drafted Barry Sanders for 4 years after he retired, convinced that he was coming back.

In any poll some people will misread the question or mark the wrong chad. Especially people in Florida.

voted yes because I live in Florida.

 

[Barooo]

A drop is a drop...I can not see the need to make an exception.

 

[MiniBears]

I'm with everyone else on this topic. I kept Barry Sanders on my roster for two friggin' years thinking he was coming back before I cut him.

 

[valhallan]

If the team who dropped him gets first dibs, then that team essentially has an extra roster spot. No dice, Chicago

 

[King of the Wolfies]

if he dropped him, he dropped him.

The only answer.

 

[BustedKnuckles]

waiver wire pick up to the worst team that wants him.