Should replay challenges be allowed for penalties? (1 Viewer)

[Gally]

Make it one challenge per season.  If you waste it in week 5 don’t come crying later when a playoff berth is on the line.  

Why even do it all then? 

I have never understood why challenges are limited beyond the need to have a time out available.  You are penalized a missed challenge by losing your time out.  I don't understand why you can't challenge as long as you have a time out remaining.  So you can challenge 10 times in the first half and get them all correct (the whole point of making replay challenges available at all is to get a call correct)  as long as you have a time out to lose if you get it wrong.  I also think you should be able to dip into your second half time outs (in the first half) if you so desire.

 

[Parrothead]

Robot refs.  I mean, it's freaking 2019.  Can we stop putting all of our greatest engineers on building the thinnest folding phone ever and maybe make some actual gosh darn robots?!? 

robots that look like real zebras would be awesome

 

[TheIronSheik]

robots that look like real zebras would be awesome

Like that Big Dog robot from Boston Dynamics.  Paint him black and white.  

 

[TheIronSheik]

Is this real?  Seems like the decision came out of nowhere after reports surfaced that the idea was shot down.

Link

 

[Nathan R. Jessep]

YOU'RE #*^@#(& RIGHT THEY DID!!! 

 

[Statorama]

Is this real?  Seems like the decision came out of nowhere after reports surfaced that the idea was shot down.

Link

This is surprising, because everything I heard was that Coach Payton was sulking around early yesterday like the vote was going to go the other way.

Knowing fate like I do, there is absolutely no way this doesn't come back to have a negative impact on the Saints this year.

 

[Ilov80s]

This year it is PI, next year it will be roughing the passer and the next it will holding and eventually everything gets reviewed. Awful. 

 

[Ilov80s]

Is this real?  Seems like the decision came out of nowhere after reports surfaced that the idea was shot down.

Link

Yes and on top of that, the NFL said the refs missed a PI on Cooks in that SB pass that was broken up. They said that should have been Rams ball at the 1 because in super slo-mo you could see the DB hooked his arm for a microsecond. 

 

[Dez]

There is your first TD taken back on this new replay rule.  I knew this would happen.  It sucks.