Sidney Rice - where does he rank among rook wr's? (1 Viewer)

[Banger]

I don't get to see many Minn. games and have never seen Rice play but for those who have how does he look? I know the stats aren't great but T. Jackson is probably the worst starter in the league and their passing attack is anemic. I don't see them wasting another year with Jackson and Rice has no competition for the #1 wr spot and they have a decent line. I know they are always going to be a run 1st team with Peterson and their line but they definitely need a passing threat to improve.

How would you rank him among the other rookie wr's, 3rd behind Bowe and Calvin? How do you view his long term outlook assuming that they can get a decent QB?

 

[metoo]

Where I have always had him ranked #2 behind only Calvin.

 

[Banger]

Where I have always had him ranked #2 behind only Calvin.

Really? Better than Bowe? I've seen Bowe quite a few games and he's very impressive.

 

[greenf7cat]

Where I have always had him ranked #2 behind only Calvin.

Really? Better than Bowe? I've seen Bowe quite a few games and he's very impressive.

As of right now, Bowe is playing better than Calvin. I dont know if that will continue over the long term, but Bowe is probably the #2 right now if you are looking long term. Based on this year, Bowe is #1 purely based on his #'s.

 

[Banger]

Where I have always had him ranked #2 behind only Calvin.

Really? Better than Bowe? I've seen Bowe quite a few games and he's very impressive.

As of right now, Bowe is playing better than Calvin. I dont know if that will continue over the long term, but Bowe is probably the #2 right now if you are looking long term. Based on this year, Bowe is #1 purely based on his #'s.

Agreed but Calvin's talent is >>> over Bowe or any other wr in this draft.

 

[greenf7cat]

Where I have always had him ranked #2 behind only Calvin.

Really? Better than Bowe? I've seen Bowe quite a few games and he's very impressive.

As of right now, Bowe is playing better than Calvin. I dont know if that will continue over the long term, but Bowe is probably the #2 right now if you are looking long term. Based on this year, Bowe is #1 purely based on his #'s.

Agreed but Calvin's talent is >>> over Bowe or any other wr in this draft.

can't argue with that!!!

 

[az_prof]

It's too early to tell but I like him. People who claim Bowe looks better? Well, we all knew Bowe had probably the best situation of any rookie WR. I expected Bowe to have the best first year. But I am not sold on him long term. When you consider the offense Rice is in it is amazing. Same for Ted Ginn Jr., who has done really well in quite possibly the worst NFl offense. Right now it is hard to rank but I would put all these guys in the same tier:

Rice, Bowe, Ginn

CJ2 has been a disappointment, but I still feel he will be the best of the group. He won't do it as quickly as people thought and he was way overrated for redraft leagues.

I still like Meachem to join the group above but I think he must have been hurt worse than anyone knew. Next year he should start and make some noise.

 

[nyftbl_giants]

It's too early to tell but I like him. People who claim Bowe looks better? Well, we all knew Bowe had probably the best situation of any rookie WR. I expected Bowe to have the best first year. But I am not sold on him long term. When you consider the offense Rice is in it is amazing. Same for Ted Ginn Jr., who has done really well in quite possibly the worst NFl offense. Right now it is hard to rank but I would put all these guys in the same tier:Rice, Bowe, GinnCJ2 has been a disappointment, but I still feel he will be the best of the group. He won't do it as quickly as people thought and he was way overrated for redraft leagues.I still like Meachem to join the group above but I think he must have been hurt worse than anyone knew. Next year he should start and make some noise.

Meachem recently got some on field advice from Steve Smith in the Carolina New Orleans pre game warm up. Smith was actually running routes with the rookie giving him advice. He is determined and certainly in a WR friendly offensive program. That said Im still glad the guy before me took him leaving rice on the board for me. If the vikes can get some steady QB play with ADP opening up the pass Sydney could be exciting.

 

[Frenchy Fuqua]

If Minnesota gets a QB Rice has as much potential as any rookie WR over the long haul. He doesn't have CJs size or speed but he doesn't have to compete for balls with Roy Williams either. I'd expect most defenses to key on Adrian Peterson too leaving Rice with plenty of opportunities downfield if the Vikes get a legit NFL QB.

 

[switz]

My rankings from the preseason haven't changed much.

CJ

Rice

Bowe

however...

Craig Davis has disappointed, and Ginn is better than I expected, though I am still not sold on him as a #1 WR.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

Sidney Rice reminds me of Chris Carter. Terrific body control, good vertical, and nice hands.

Kid's going to be good. I would rank them Johnson, Rice, Bowe as well.

 

[Banger]

If Minnesota gets a QB Rice has as much potential as any rookie WR over the long haul. He doesn't have CJs size or speed but he doesn't have to compete for balls with Roy Williams either. I'd expect most defenses to key on Adrian Peterson too leaving Rice with plenty of opportunities downfield if the Vikes get a legit NFL QB.

That's exactly how I view the situation. Rice is sporadic in terms of on field production but that's to be expected since he's a rookie and he's on an awful passing offense. The glimpses he does show in some replays I've seen show top notch ability and tremendous individual effort. A decent QB is the key though. I wonder if they'd go for Losman (not that I'd be in love with that move) or for a similar type player.

 

[switz]

If Minnesota gets a QB Rice has as much potential as any rookie WR over the long haul. He doesn't have CJs size or speed but he doesn't have to compete for balls with Roy Williams either. I'd expect most defenses to key on Adrian Peterson too leaving Rice with plenty of opportunities downfield if the Vikes get a legit NFL QB.

That's exactly how I view the situation. Rice is sporadic in terms of on field production but that's to be expected since he's a rookie and he's on an awful passing offense. The glimpses he does show in some replays I've seen show top notch ability and tremendous individual effort.

A decent QB is the key though. I wonder if they'd go for Losman (not that I'd be in love with that move) or for a similar type player.

So far this year, Rice has been a better QB than anyone else on the Vikings.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

Even though it's been against the Raiders and the Giants, Tarvaris Jackson has shown improvement and I wouldn't expect big moves from the Vikings regarding the QB position this off season. The McNabb rumors are just that - rumors.

 

[shadyridr]

It's too early to tell but I like him. People who claim Bowe looks better? Well, we all knew Bowe had probably the best situation of any rookie WR. I expected Bowe to have the best first year. But I am not sold on him long term. When you consider the offense Rice is in it is amazing. Same for Ted Ginn Jr., who has done really well in quite possibly the worst NFl offense. Right now it is hard to rank but I would put all these guys in the same tier:

Rice, Bowe, Ginn

CJ2 has been a disappointment, but I still feel he will be the best of the group. He won't do it as quickly as people thought and he was way overrated for redraft leagues.

I still like Meachem to join the group above but I think he must have been hurt worse than anyone knew. Next year he should start and make some noise.

Seriously? He was starting in a run heavy, Herm Edwards led offense with Huard and Croyle tossing the rock. That was a better situation then starting or being the #3 WR in a pass heavy, Mike Martz led attack with Kitna at QB?

 

[Banger]

If Minnesota gets a QB Rice has as much potential as any rookie WR over the long haul. He doesn't have CJs size or speed but he doesn't have to compete for balls with Roy Williams either. I'd expect most defenses to key on Adrian Peterson too leaving Rice with plenty of opportunities downfield if the Vikes get a legit NFL QB.

That's exactly how I view the situation. Rice is sporadic in terms of on field production but that's to be expected since he's a rookie and he's on an awful passing offense. The glimpses he does show in some replays I've seen show top notch ability and tremendous individual effort.

A decent QB is the key though. I wonder if they'd go for Losman (not that I'd be in love with that move) or for a similar type player.

So far this year, Rice has been a better QB than anyone else on the Vikings.

 

[Banger]

Even though it's been against the Raiders and the Giants, Tarvaris Jackson has shown improvement and I wouldn't expect big moves from the Vikings regarding the QB position this off season. The McNabb rumors are just that - rumors.

I just can't see them wasting another year on him. If they had a decent QB this year they'd probably be a wildcard team.

 

[BobbyLayne]

Having seen all 3 a lot this year, I would also rank him above Bowe in talent. But both have less than optimal situations. Despite that, Sidney has made some great plays the last few weeks. He hasn't had a great breakout game yet from a FF perspective, but no question the guy is going to be a force in the NFL.

Johnson has both a good situation and unbelivable talent. For the 4th (and sometimes 5th) option he puts up decent numbers. They force fed him on Turkey Day, and it will be interesting to see if he continues to get 10-15 targets down the stretch (instead fo the 5 he was getting prior to the GB game). Like Rice, it seems like every week he makes an awe inspiring play or two, but he has yet to impose his will and take over a game.

 

[Chicago Hooligan]

Considering that he's led them to a few big wins and they're looking to finish around .500, I absolutely think Minn. will stick with Tarvaris for the near future. They're still not going to be competing for a championship next year, and I don't think shelling out a top pick for an old vet QB will do more to help them. But it would probably help Rice's stats.

(Don't forget that James Jones is putting up solid #s as a non-starting rookie WR.)

 

[Andy Dufresne]

Even though it's been against the Raiders and the Giants, Tarvaris Jackson has shown improvement and I wouldn't expect big moves from the Vikings regarding the QB position this off season. The McNabb rumors are just that - rumors.

I just can't see them wasting another year on him. If they had a decent QB this year they'd probably be a wildcard team.

Don't underestimate Brad Childresses ego.

 

[Banger]

Even though it's been against the Raiders and the Giants, Tarvaris Jackson has shown improvement and I wouldn't expect big moves from the Vikings regarding the QB position this off season. The McNabb rumors are just that - rumors.

I just can't see them wasting another year on him. If they had a decent QB this year they'd probably be a wildcard team.

Don't underestimate Brad Childresses ego.

touche!!

 

[munchkin]

It's too early to tell but I like him. People who claim Bowe looks better? Well, we all knew Bowe had probably the best situation of any rookie WR. I expected Bowe to have the best first year. But I am not sold on him long term. When you consider the offense Rice is in it is amazing. Same for Ted Ginn Jr., who has done really well in quite possibly the worst NFl offense. Right now it is hard to rank but I would put all these guys in the same tier:

Rice, Bowe, Ginn

CJ2 has been a disappointment, but I still feel he will be the best of the group. He won't do it as quickly as people thought and he was way overrated for redraft leagues.

I still like Meachem to join the group above but I think he must have been hurt worse than anyone knew. Next year he should start and make some noise.

Seriously? He was starting in a run heavy, Herm Edwards led offense with Huard and Croyle tossing the rock. That was a better situation then starting or being the #3 WR in a pass heavy, Mike Martz led attack with Kitna at QB?

Eddie Kennison's injury helped Bowe get on the field early. I think the game reps helped him mature a little faster than otherwise expected. Johnson is up against a lot of receivers in Detroit not just RWilliams. His back injury kept him out a while as well. But certainly Herm's offense and the QB situation in KC is no panacea. The expectations for Johnson were pretty high while I expect those for Bowe were fairly low.

 

[The Jacket]

Well, we all knew Bowe had probably the best situation of any rookie WR.

:( One of the most hilarious posts I've ever read."Hey, WR - come to Kansas City. We've got the great Damon Huard at QB, a fantastic offensive line which gives up more sacks than a high school OL protecting Drew Bledsoe and no other receivers to take coverage from you! Just do it!"

It's too early to tell but I like him. People who claim Bowe looks better? Well, we all knew Bowe had probably the best situation of any rookie WR. I expected Bowe to have the best first year. But I am not sold on him long term. When you consider the offense Rice is in it is amazing.

Why are you not sold? He has displayed very few weaknesses, so I'd love to hear it. The Minnesota QB may be a little worse than KC's (although it's hardly Brady vs. Cleo Lemon), the Minnesota running game is far superior, the surrounding WRs are equally as bad and the Vikings OL can actually pass block a little to give the receivers time to run a route. I can't fathom what's so much worse about Rice's situation than Bowe's. It may be a little worse, but that isn't what you said.

 

[bmarks6161]

Long term, I think Rice will develop into something special. He has some awesome talent. I would prefer him over Bowe.

Short term, I would rank Bowe above Rice. Bowe seems more developed and Rice is more raw. Neither have great QBs.

I put Calvin above both for the short term and long term.

 

[corpcow]

The other thing a lot of people forget is that Rice is really young - he just turned 21 on Sept 1st. Bowe is 2 years older, having turned 23 on Sept 24th.

Coming into the season, Rice was definitely viewed as one of the more raw prospects, but if he continues to develop could definitely be a force.

 

[brobe4]

1. calvin

2. Bowe

3. Rice

4. Ginn

 

[strong]

While I like Rice a lot, I'm surprised so many people have Rice ranked ahead of Bowe.

I wonder how much that is influenced by Rice's score last week. Perhaps the popular opinion will be different next week.

I'd bet that quite a few dynasty Rice owners would trade him for Bowe straight up. But I doubt many Bowe owners would be willing to make the same deal.

 

[daveandken]

1. CJ

2. Bowe

3. Rice

4. James Jones

5. A Gonz

6. Ginn

 

[dpeease]

IMHO CJ is overrated. He appears to turn the easy catches into difficult ones and doesn't know how to protect himself after the catch just yet.

 

[Donnybrook]

Man thinks have changed since July. Player Spotlight: Vikings WRs . I think many thought that the Vikings made a mistake by taking Rice one pick before Dwaynee Jarrett was selected by the Panthers. Rice wasn't worthy of his own spotlight but, of course, Dwayne Jarrett was.

LHUCKS prediction that Rice would be an outright bust was a confirmation from my perspective that he would be good.

 

[Franchise Playa]

Well, we all knew Bowe had probably the best situation of any rookie WR.

One of the most hilarious posts I've ever read."Hey, WR - come to Kansas City. We've got the great Damon Huard at QB, a fantastic offensive line which gives up more sacks than a high school OL protecting Drew Bledsoe and no other receivers to take coverage from you! Just do it!"

It's too early to tell but I like him. People who claim Bowe looks better? Well, we all knew Bowe had probably the best situation of any rookie WR. I expected Bowe to have the best first year. But I am not sold on him long term. When you consider the offense Rice is in it is amazing.

Why are you not sold? He has displayed very few weaknesses, so I'd love to hear it. The Minnesota QB may be a little worse than KC's (although it's hardly Brady vs. Cleo Lemon), the Minnesota running game is far superior, the surrounding WRs are equally as bad and the Vikings OL can actually pass block a little to give the receivers time to run a route. I can't fathom what's so much worse about Rice's situation than Bowe's. It may be a little worse, but that isn't what you said.

Andre Johnson caught 100 balls with David Carr throwing him the rock....so yes its not a stretch to say Bowe fell into a better situation...regardless of who in KC was throwing him the ball he is 2nd option (first depending on how often Tony G is doubled).

 

[Vladislav Tretiak]

I know this is a Sydney Rice thread but can anybody shed some light on Aundrae Allison.

Is he worth holding onto in my dynasty league. The guy hasn't seen much activation for the games this year.

TIA

 

[phthalatemagic]

#2 right behind Bowe

 

[Banger]

Thanks for all the good info. I also went back and read a bunch of threads using the search function and a lot of the draftniks basically predicted the season that he's having but his upside appears tremendous especially considering his age.

Something to keep in mind for the Bowe is better crowd, after '03 Boldin >>>> Andre Johnson, now I wouldn't take Boldin for AJ, after last year Colston >>>>Holmes, Jennings, Marshall - going forward who knows...

 

[The Jacket]

Andre Johnson caught 100 balls with David Carr throwing him the rock....so yes its not a stretch to say Bowe fell into a better situation...regardless of who in KC was throwing him the ball he is 2nd option (first depending on how often Tony G is doubled).

So Bowe was always likely to get targets. Right. And why, exactly, was Rice not? Considering the Vikings have even worse WRs than the Chiefs and no legitimate TE, I fail to see your point. If we're saying Bowe's situation is so great because he'll have all these opportunities, lets at least be consistent.

 

[FavreCo]

Where I have always had him ranked #2 behind only Calvin.

Yep. Needs a QB though. The worst possible scenario is playing out there. Tavaris Jackson completed a deep pass for a TD.

 

[FavreCo]

1. calvin

2. Bowe

3. Rice

4. Ginn

Tha'ts funny!!!!

 

[Franchise Playa]

Andre Johnson caught 100 balls with David Carr throwing him the rock....so yes its not a stretch to say Bowe fell into a better situation...regardless of who in KC was throwing him the ball he is 2nd option (first depending on how often Tony G is doubled).

So Bowe was always likely to get targets. Right. And why, exactly, was Rice not? Considering the Vikings have even worse WRs than the Chiefs and no legitimate TE, I fail to see your point. If we're saying Bowe's situation is so great because he'll have all these opportunities, lets at least be consistent.

Because unless your Stevie Wonder anyone can see T Jackson and the rotating slew of Min QB's is not a better passing situation than KC...Im not saying KC are the Colts but the passing game is better atm. They aren't running LJ like last year and have given Tony G love for years by throwing to him.Bowe got in due to an injury and has had some big plays and gets plenty of targets. With T Jackson he is throwing like 15 times or less a game sometimes...That is not a reciepe for success. In terms of passing opportunites Bowe is getting more than Rice right now. He was drafted to take pressure off Tony G and be the WR threat KC has not had in years.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

1. calvin

2. Bowe

3. Rice

4. Ginn

Tha'ts funny!!!!

Other than 2 & 3 being reversed, he's got it right.

 

[FavreCo]

1. calvin

2. Bowe

3. Rice

4. Ginn

Tha'ts funny!!!!

Other than 2 & 3 being reversed, he's got it right.

Ginn.....

I got 4 WR's not even on the list that are better than that bum (FF wise that is):

Jacoby Jones

James Jones

Laurent Robinson

Anthony Gonzales

Who is his QB again? A 26 yr. old rookie? Nice. Good luck with that one. Also remember he has a lemon backing him up.

and Steve Smith is real close.

 

[Andy Dufresne]

1. calvin

2. Bowe

3. Rice

4. Ginn

Tha'ts funny!!!!

Other than 2 & 3 being reversed, he's got it right.

Ginn.....

I got 4 WR's not even on the list that are better than that bum (FF wise that is):

Jacoby Jones

James Jones

Laurent Robinson

Anthony Gonzales

Who is his QB again? A 26 yr. old rookie? Nice. Good luck with that one. Also remember he has a lemon backing him up.

and Steve Smith is real close.

Are you talking production-wise or talent-wise? Have you seen Ginn play lately, the light is turning on. He will be a better WR than all the guys you've listed (except perhaps Gonzales, who I also believe in).Currently, you're right about him not having much FF value. Next year will be different.

 

[dmac37]

I've got 3 rookies on my dynasty:

S. Rice

L. Robinson

M. Walker (Jax IR)

Betwenn these 3 I'm hoping for one of these to be a true #1 FF WR, one to be a serviceable FF starter, and one will probably bomb out. All have young raw talent, very little competition, just need a quality QB to get them the ball once they develop.

 

[cartel]

Andre Johnson caught 100 balls with David Carr throwing him the rock....so yes its not a stretch to say Bowe fell into a better situation...regardless of who in KC was throwing him the ball he is 2nd option (first depending on how often Tony G is doubled).

So Bowe was always likely to get targets. Right. And why, exactly, was Rice not? Considering the Vikings have even worse WRs than the Chiefs and no legitimate TE, I fail to see your point. If we're saying Bowe's situation is so great because he'll have all these opportunities, lets at least be consistent.

Because unless your Stevie Wonder anyone can see T Jackson and the rotating slew of Min QB's is not a better passing situation than KC...Im not saying KC are the Colts but the passing game is better atm. They aren't running LJ like last year and have given Tony G love for years by throwing to him.Bowe got in due to an injury and has had some big plays and gets plenty of targets. With T Jackson he is throwing like 15 times or less a game sometimes...That is not a reciepe for success. In terms of passing opportunites Bowe is getting more than Rice right now. He was drafted to take pressure off Tony G and be the WR threat KC has not had in years.

Bowe is on pace to exceed 1000 yards as a rookie and that includes a game he was completely ineffective due to an injury. This is with being at best a second option on a team with utter junk at qb. He may be in a better situation then Minny but not that much better. This guys performance thus far would IMO jump him over S Rice (even taking into account the disparity in the situation).

 

[Banger]

Andre Johnson caught 100 balls with David Carr throwing him the rock....so yes its not a stretch to say Bowe fell into a better situation...regardless of who in KC was throwing him the ball he is 2nd option (first depending on how often Tony G is doubled).

So Bowe was always likely to get targets. Right. And why, exactly, was Rice not? Considering the Vikings have even worse WRs than the Chiefs and no legitimate TE, I fail to see your point. If we're saying Bowe's situation is so great because he'll have all these opportunities, lets at least be consistent.

Because unless your Stevie Wonder anyone can see T Jackson and the rotating slew of Min QB's is not a better passing situation than KC...Im not saying KC are the Colts but the passing game is better atm. They aren't running LJ like last year and have given Tony G love for years by throwing to him.Bowe got in due to an injury and has had some big plays and gets plenty of targets. With T Jackson he is throwing like 15 times or less a game sometimes...That is not a reciepe for success. In terms of passing opportunites Bowe is getting more than Rice right now. He was drafted to take pressure off Tony G and be the WR threat KC has not had in years.

Bowe is on pace to exceed 1000 yards as a rookie and that includes a game he was completely ineffective due to an injury. This is with being at best a second option on a team with utter junk at qb. He may be in a better situation then Minny but not that much better. This guys performance thus far would IMO jump him over S Rice (even taking into account the disparity in the situation).

from a dynasty perspective though? Yes, he is and has been better than Rice this year but I don't know that that will have much bearing two years from now.

 

[switz]

1. calvin

2. Bowe

3. Rice

4. Ginn

Tha'ts funny!!!!

Other than 2 & 3 being reversed, he's got it right.

Ginn.....

I got 4 WR's not even on the list that are better than that bum (FF wise that is):

Jacoby Jones

James Jones

Laurent Robinson

Anthony Gonzales

Who is his QB again? A 26 yr. old rookie? Nice. Good luck with that one. Also remember he has a lemon backing him up.

and Steve Smith is real close.

Are you talking production-wise or talent-wise? Have you seen Ginn play lately, the light is turning on. He will be a better WR than all the guys you've listed (except perhaps Gonzales, who I also believe in).Currently, you're right about him not having much FF value. Next year will be different.

Having watched Ginn a bit recently, I already stated he's exceeded my expectations... BUT... I still don't see him as a #1 WR even a solid #2... he's getting forced a lot of balls recently, and not doing much with them. I see a better long term career for at least James Jones and Laurent Robinson.

 

[kupcho1]

Having watched Ginn a bit recently, I already stated he's exceeded my expectations... BUT... I still don't see him as a #1 WR even a solid #2... he's getting forced a lot of balls recently, and not doing much with them. I see a better long term career for at least James Jones and Laurent Robinson.

You say that like its a bad thing.

 

[cartel]

Andre Johnson caught 100 balls with David Carr throwing him the rock....so yes its not a stretch to say Bowe fell into a better situation...regardless of who in KC was throwing him the ball he is 2nd option (first depending on how often Tony G is doubled).

So Bowe was always likely to get targets. Right. And why, exactly, was Rice not? Considering the Vikings have even worse WRs than the Chiefs and no legitimate TE, I fail to see your point. If we're saying Bowe's situation is so great because he'll have all these opportunities, lets at least be consistent.

Because unless your Stevie Wonder anyone can see T Jackson and the rotating slew of Min QB's is not a better passing situation than KC...Im not saying KC are the Colts but the passing game is better atm. They aren't running LJ like last year and have given Tony G love for years by throwing to him.Bowe got in due to an injury and has had some big plays and gets plenty of targets. With T Jackson he is throwing like 15 times or less a game sometimes...That is not a reciepe for success. In terms of passing opportunites Bowe is getting more than Rice right now. He was drafted to take pressure off Tony G and be the WR threat KC has not had in years.

Bowe is on pace to exceed 1000 yards as a rookie and that includes a game he was completely ineffective due to an injury. This is with being at best a second option on a team with utter junk at qb. He may be in a better situation then Minny but not that much better. This guys performance thus far would IMO jump him over S Rice (even taking into account the disparity in the situation).

from a dynasty perspective though? Yes, he is and has been better than Rice this year but I don't know that that will have much bearing two years from now.

The best way to predict future performance is past performance. He is putting up WR2/3 numbers as a rookie in a crap system. I am not saying he will be better then Rice but I do think he is a more sure thing going forward.

 

[cstu]

It's too early to tell but I like him. People who claim Bowe looks better? Well, we all knew Bowe had probably the best situation of any rookie WR. I expected Bowe to have the best first year. But I am not sold on him long term. When you consider the offense Rice is in it is amazing. Same for Ted Ginn Jr., who has done really well in quite possibly the worst NFl offense. Right now it is hard to rank but I would put all these guys in the same tier:Rice, Bowe, GinnCJ2 has been a disappointment, but I still feel he will be the best of the group. He won't do it as quickly as people thought and he was way overrated for redraft leagues.I still like Meachem to join the group above but I think he must have been hurt worse than anyone knew. Next year he should start and make some noise.

Meachem recently got some on field advice from Steve Smith in the Carolina New Orleans pre game warm up. Smith was actually running routes with the rookie giving him advice. He is determined and certainly in a WR friendly offensive program. That said Im still glad the guy before me took him leaving rice on the board for me. If the vikes can get some steady QB play with ADP opening up the pass Sydney could be exciting.

I'm a Meachem owner but I'm getting the feeling the guy is just plain lazy. He came in overweight and out of shape and then got injured. I also read that he admitted not working hard enough to rehab after the injury. If there's any hope for him it's that Devery Henderson, Terrance Copper and David Patten are in the last year of their contracts. Maybe Meachem is just in Payton's doghouse and will work hard to get out of it - I'm not holding my breath though. Question - how many WR's didn't have a catch their rookie year in which they didn't have a major injury and went on to have productive careers?

 

[brobe4]

1. calvin

2. Bowe

3. Rice

4. Ginn

Tha'ts funny!!!!

Other than 2 & 3 being reversed, he's got it right.

Ginn.....

I got 4 WR's not even on the list that are better than that bum (FF wise that is):

Jacoby Jones

James Jones

Laurent Robinson

Anthony Gonzales

Who is his QB again? A 26 yr. old rookie? Nice. Good luck with that one. Also remember he has a lemon backing him up.

and Steve Smith is real close.

I'm not a expert like alot of people, but i do watch alot of games plus some homework. I Think Ginn has alot of upside plus I like his situation much better then most. Gonzales would be next in line for me with all the rumors about harrison and possible retirement after this year boost his stock a liitle.

 

[kellumsboys]

as a Rice owner, I am very excited about his future.

BUT, Minny must get a QB.

I hope they draft one of several good ones coming out this year.

right now I would rank then

CJ

Bowe

Rice (very close behind)

I expect Rice to surpass Bowe in the long run.

but, it wouldn't surprise me if Gonzalez has a more productive career than Rice or Bowe.

just like Wayne being so productive next to Marvin, when Harrison retires, Gonzalez could put up WR #1 numbers in that offense next to Wayne.