almost done. just a little over 2 rounds to go.
Fro, let me know who you want for your missed pick.
Fro, let me know who you want for your missed pick.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
SSL5 IDP Draft Commentary Thread (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Aaron Rudnicki
- Start date
Fullback Fro
yesno
Todd Pinkston
Red Herring
Footballguy
31.07 487 Rush Allen, James NOS LB
ouch.
ouch.
I get home from work, my rd 30 pick is 9 picks away, but pre-drafted, so I go to bed. When I wake up 21 picks have been made (unheard of in this draft) and my rd 31 pick is up. Not wanting to hold things up, I bypass the ussual news blogger scan and basically flush pick 31.07 down the toilet! 
Miggity
not a phallus
Question for Rude Dude about this pick. If I draft Dan Cody as a MFL DE and they switch him later, does he remain DE for my survivor team or switch to LB?
If he stays DE for my team, you can go ahead and draft him for me so you can get on with your pick. If not, I want to do something different.
If he stays DE for my team, you can go ahead and draft him for me so you can get on with your pick. If not, I want to do something different.
Fullback Fro
yesno
Trevor Pryce for skipped pick
ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
Fixed
Red Herring
Footballguy
So who wants to start the post-draft grading?
ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
Fixed again
valence
Footballguy
QB:
Donovan Mcnabb 4.05 (9)
Chad Pennington 15.12 (9)
J.P. Losman 16.05 (8)
RB:
Domanick Davis 1.12 (5)
Deshaun Foster 3.12 (9)
Ahman Green 5.12 (6)
Priest Holmes 17.12 (3)
WR:
Terrell Owens 2.05 (3)
Joey Galloway 6.05 (4)
Reggie Brown 7.12 (9)
Isaac Bruce 9.12 (7)
Antawn Randle El 20.05 (8)
Corey Bradford 25.12 (8)
Rashaun Woods 27.12 (3)
TE:
Ben Troupe 8.05 (7)
Erron Kinney 13.12 (7)
Bubba Franks 18.05 (6)
K:
Lawrence Tynes 26.05 (3)
DL:
Michael Strahan 10.05 (4)
Mike Rucker 23.12 (9)
Reggie Hayward 24.05 (6)
Tamba Hali 26.05 (3)
LB:
Shelton Quarles 11.12 (4)
Gary Brackett 12.05 (6)
Ernie Sims 14.05 (8)
E.J. Henderson 29.12 (6)
Randall Godfrey 30.12 (3)
DB:
Darren Sharper 19.12 (6)
Shawntae Spencer 21.12 (7)
Terrance Kiel 22.05 (3)
Robert Griffith 31.12 (9)
John Lynch 32.05 (4)
This is my first ever IDP draft so I don't know really how to grade it.
The only positions that I really like are TE and WR. I'd put my WR corp up against anyone in the league. QB and RB have injury risks everywhere.
Go ahead and rip it up.
Donovan Mcnabb 4.05 (9)
Chad Pennington 15.12 (9)
J.P. Losman 16.05 (8)
RB:
Domanick Davis 1.12 (5)
Deshaun Foster 3.12 (9)
Ahman Green 5.12 (6)
Priest Holmes 17.12 (3)
WR:
Terrell Owens 2.05 (3)
Joey Galloway 6.05 (4)
Reggie Brown 7.12 (9)
Isaac Bruce 9.12 (7)
Antawn Randle El 20.05 (8)
Corey Bradford 25.12 (8)
Rashaun Woods 27.12 (3)
TE:
Ben Troupe 8.05 (7)
Erron Kinney 13.12 (7)
Bubba Franks 18.05 (6)
K:
Lawrence Tynes 26.05 (3)
DL:
Michael Strahan 10.05 (4)
Mike Rucker 23.12 (9)
Reggie Hayward 24.05 (6)
Tamba Hali 26.05 (3)
LB:
Shelton Quarles 11.12 (4)
Gary Brackett 12.05 (6)
Ernie Sims 14.05 (8)
E.J. Henderson 29.12 (6)
Randall Godfrey 30.12 (3)
DB:
Darren Sharper 19.12 (6)
Shawntae Spencer 21.12 (7)
Terrance Kiel 22.05 (3)
Robert Griffith 31.12 (9)
John Lynch 32.05 (4)
This is my first ever IDP draft so I don't know really how to grade it.
The only positions that I really like are TE and WR. I'd put my WR corp up against anyone in the league. QB and RB have injury risks everywhere.
Go ahead and rip it up.
Last edited by a moderator:
Red Herring
Footballguy
A little risky, but it should last a while, IMO. The hits will easily cover for the misses for a few weeks.
Fullback Fro
yesno
Terrell Owens 2.05 (3)
Joey Galloway 6.05 (4)
Reggie Brown 7.12 (9)
Isaac Bruce 9.12 (7)
Antawn Randle El 20.05 (8)
Corey Bradford 25.12 (8)
Rashaun Woods 27.12 (3)
Very good group. Too many WRs though. I went with 5, which was a little light, but you probably could have left off Woods to solidify another position. A
Not having WR depth in a Survivor is a big NO NO. This statement is rediculous.
Joey Galloway 6.05 (4)
Reggie Brown 7.12 (9)
Isaac Bruce 9.12 (7)
Antawn Randle El 20.05 (8)
Corey Bradford 25.12 (8)
Rashaun Woods 27.12 (3)
Very good group. Too many WRs though. I went with 5, which was a little light, but you probably could have left off Woods to solidify another position. A
Not having WR depth in a Survivor is a big NO NO. This statement is rediculous.
Red Herring
Footballguy
Here's my squad. This was my first IDP draft (I've done a few IDP auctions) and first survivor format as well. I definitely miscalculated a couple times, but mostly stuck to my strategy, we'll see how it does.
QB:
Brunell, Mark WAS QB - 8 9.06
Campbell, Jason WAS QB - 8 18.11
Leinart, Matt ARI QB ® - 9 15.06
Volek, Billy TEN QB - 7 11.06
My biggest miscalculation was how late I thought I could still draft viable QB play. I ended up spending one more roster spot here than I wanted to to insure hopefully solid play here every week. C-
RB:
Alstott, Mike TBB RB - 4 26.11
Barlow, Kevan SFO RB - 7 7.06
Houston, Cedric NYJ RB - 9 17.06
Jones, Thomas CHI RB - 7 3.06
Pass, Patrick NEP RB - 6 29.06
Williams, Carnell TBB RB - 4 1.06
Solid, but unspectacular. In hindsight, I wouldnt have taken Caddy there, but the draft snuck up on me. I wasn't aware it was happening till I got a PM that I was up. I also shouldn't have grabbed Barlow as RB3 because his bye clashes with Jones; this ended up costing me 1 more roster spot than I planned. Not quite to my goal of being sure I have a RB in the flex spot each week, but pretty close. C+
WR:
Ferguson, Robert GBP WR - 6 20.11
Houshmandzadeh, T.J. CIN WR - 5 4.11
Moss, Sinorice NYG WR ® - 4 21.06
Porter, Jerry OAK WR - 3 8.11
Stokley, Brandon IND WR - 6 14.11
Another solid squad, I went with a couple guys that will be hit or miss each week. This squad won't lose games for me, and should have at least a couple where 3 have huge games together. I loved getting Stokely as late as I did, as I expect him to see a few more targets this year with Edge gone. My WR6 was a casualty of the QB miscalc, otherwise I'm satisfied here. B
TE:
Shockey, Jeremy NYG TE - 4 2.11
In hindsight I took him a little early. Part of my "strategy" going into this was to have someone that would really take advantage of the 2/ppr. Not having a backup here hurts, a result of my RB bye week problem. It came down to a choice between a backup K or TE. If both went down, a kicker would give me more points; also another TE would probably never score for me, another K could cover bad weeks. Really banking on Shockey's health, which I'm not entirely comfortable with. B+
K:
Gostkowski, Stephen NEP PK ® - 6 32.11
Hall, John WAS PK - 8 28.11
Decided to try out the QB-K pairing, and since WAS Qbs should be my scorers most weeks and Hall was close to BA at that point, thats where I went. Gotkowski was simply BA in the last round. Nothing special here overall, but they're kickers.
C+
DL:
Bernard, Robert SEA DT - 5 27.06
Glover, La' roi STL DT - 7 30.11
Henderson, John JAC DT - 6 23.06
Kerney, Patrick ATL DE - 5 16.11
Brain-fart on bye weeks here too, forcing 1 more roster spot here as well. Otherwise exactly as I wanted it. Kerney should be solid to very good all year, Henderson and Bernard will be steady. Glover was picked mainly to cover week 5, when he faces GB. B-
LB:
Arrington, Lavar NYG LB - 4 19.06
Edwards, Donnie SDC LB - 3 5.06
Hawk, A.J. GBP LB ® - 6 12.11
Johnson, Derrick O. KCC LB - 3 13.06
Ryans, DeMeco HOU LB ® - 5 24.11
Thomas, Zach MIA LB - 8 6.11
Obviously the strength of my squad. I wanted to be sure I'd get 4 very good to huge games each week. Looking back, I could have waited a couple rounds at a couple of the spots and gotten similar talent, but overall I'm very happy here. Lots of early bye weeks too. A
DB:
Minter, Mike CAR S - 9 31.06
Parrish, Tony SFO S - 7 22.11
Pool, Brodney CLE S - 6 25.06
Wilson, Gibril NYG S - 4 10.11
Exactly what I wanted here. 1 top performer, a couple more between whom I should get a solid game each week, and a solid backup. Not going to win me many games, but won't lose them either. B
The strategy was to out-perform at TE and LB and be solid everywhere else. The TE-LB part went ok, but at some other positions I'm just throwing quantity out there and hoping. I expect this squad to make it through the bye weeks, but not much more. It'd take one of the QBs being unexpectedly hot this year, Jones being a full-time starter all year, and a little more than I expect from my WRs to have a shot at winning the league.
QB:
Brunell, Mark WAS QB - 8 9.06
Campbell, Jason WAS QB - 8 18.11
Leinart, Matt ARI QB ® - 9 15.06
Volek, Billy TEN QB - 7 11.06
My biggest miscalculation was how late I thought I could still draft viable QB play. I ended up spending one more roster spot here than I wanted to to insure hopefully solid play here every week. C-
RB:
Alstott, Mike TBB RB - 4 26.11
Barlow, Kevan SFO RB - 7 7.06
Houston, Cedric NYJ RB - 9 17.06
Jones, Thomas CHI RB - 7 3.06
Pass, Patrick NEP RB - 6 29.06
Williams, Carnell TBB RB - 4 1.06
Solid, but unspectacular. In hindsight, I wouldnt have taken Caddy there, but the draft snuck up on me. I wasn't aware it was happening till I got a PM that I was up. I also shouldn't have grabbed Barlow as RB3 because his bye clashes with Jones; this ended up costing me 1 more roster spot than I planned. Not quite to my goal of being sure I have a RB in the flex spot each week, but pretty close. C+
WR:
Ferguson, Robert GBP WR - 6 20.11
Houshmandzadeh, T.J. CIN WR - 5 4.11
Moss, Sinorice NYG WR ® - 4 21.06
Porter, Jerry OAK WR - 3 8.11
Stokley, Brandon IND WR - 6 14.11
Another solid squad, I went with a couple guys that will be hit or miss each week. This squad won't lose games for me, and should have at least a couple where 3 have huge games together. I loved getting Stokely as late as I did, as I expect him to see a few more targets this year with Edge gone. My WR6 was a casualty of the QB miscalc, otherwise I'm satisfied here. B
TE:
Shockey, Jeremy NYG TE - 4 2.11
In hindsight I took him a little early. Part of my "strategy" going into this was to have someone that would really take advantage of the 2/ppr. Not having a backup here hurts, a result of my RB bye week problem. It came down to a choice between a backup K or TE. If both went down, a kicker would give me more points; also another TE would probably never score for me, another K could cover bad weeks. Really banking on Shockey's health, which I'm not entirely comfortable with. B+
K:
Gostkowski, Stephen NEP PK ® - 6 32.11
Hall, John WAS PK - 8 28.11
Decided to try out the QB-K pairing, and since WAS Qbs should be my scorers most weeks and Hall was close to BA at that point, thats where I went. Gotkowski was simply BA in the last round. Nothing special here overall, but they're kickers.
C+DL:
Bernard, Robert SEA DT - 5 27.06
Glover, La' roi STL DT - 7 30.11
Henderson, John JAC DT - 6 23.06
Kerney, Patrick ATL DE - 5 16.11
Brain-fart on bye weeks here too, forcing 1 more roster spot here as well. Otherwise exactly as I wanted it. Kerney should be solid to very good all year, Henderson and Bernard will be steady. Glover was picked mainly to cover week 5, when he faces GB. B-
LB:
Arrington, Lavar NYG LB - 4 19.06
Edwards, Donnie SDC LB - 3 5.06
Hawk, A.J. GBP LB ® - 6 12.11
Johnson, Derrick O. KCC LB - 3 13.06
Ryans, DeMeco HOU LB ® - 5 24.11
Thomas, Zach MIA LB - 8 6.11
Obviously the strength of my squad. I wanted to be sure I'd get 4 very good to huge games each week. Looking back, I could have waited a couple rounds at a couple of the spots and gotten similar talent, but overall I'm very happy here. Lots of early bye weeks too. A
DB:
Minter, Mike CAR S - 9 31.06
Parrish, Tony SFO S - 7 22.11
Pool, Brodney CLE S - 6 25.06
Wilson, Gibril NYG S - 4 10.11
Exactly what I wanted here. 1 top performer, a couple more between whom I should get a solid game each week, and a solid backup. Not going to win me many games, but won't lose them either. B
The strategy was to out-perform at TE and LB and be solid everywhere else. The TE-LB part went ok, but at some other positions I'm just throwing quantity out there and hoping. I expect this squad to make it through the bye weeks, but not much more. It'd take one of the QBs being unexpectedly hot this year, Jones being a full-time starter all year, and a little more than I expect from my WRs to have a shot at winning the league.
Red Herring
Footballguy
I'll take your word for it. As I said above, this was my first survivor. Not having a couple extra WR may come back to bite me then. It just seemed that with the quality he had 1-6, 7 could have gone to something he wasnt as happy with.
Fullback Fro
yesno
Your team is doomed because of lack of WR's. WR is essential in survivor leagues and you have too few as wr scoring is eratic. Week 6 is trouble.I'll take your word for it. As I said above, this was my first survivor. Not having a couple extra WR may come back to bite me then. It just seemed that with the quality he had 1-6, 7 could have gone to something he wasnt as happy with.
pretender
Footballguy
Have at her guys!
Our (co-owned team) strategy was to get 1 really good solid stud at each position and good solid backups and try and stay away from the bye week blues. We also had targeted the defensive studs early (linebacker and DL) a little later on DB's. They seem to be more volatile from year to year and generally looked for solid talent.
Never been part of a survivor team before and fairly new at IDP ( 3rd year) all though my co-owner I believe has done survivor before and has tons of IDP experience. He had most of the rough drafting after all the real talent was gone. And I was out of town. Overall I think we did well weak at WR more than anywhere else in IMHO.
Quarterbacks
6.12 Roethlisberger, Ben PIT QB 4
10.12 Rivers, Philip SDC QB 3
Big Ben should be solid and by week 4 Rivers should be in the swing. If Rivers doesn't adjust well and Ben has health issues - could be a problem. I won't give a grade as I'm not real sure what sort of grading system to use. You guys go ahead and tear us up.
Running Backs
1.05 Brown, Ronnie MIA RB 8
2.12 Jones, Julius DAL RB 3
9.05 Staley, Duce PIT RB 4
15.05 Calhoun, Brian DET RB ® 8
28.12 Sellers, Mike WAS RB 8
30.12 Smith, Antowain HOU RB 5
Bye week blues and lack of depth cost us a roster spot or 2. Tryed to get the RB depth of players that will get points from receiving as well as rushing yardage. If Brown breaks out and Jones stays healthy - should be solid.
Wide Receivers
3.05 Wayne, Reggie IND WR 6
5.05 Mason, Derrick BAL WR 7
16.12 McCareins, Justin NYJ WR 9
20.12 Taylor, Travis MIN WR 6
23.05 Price, Peerless BUF WR 8
31.05 Colbert, Keary CAR WR 9
This might be our weakest spot. Wayne should be huge this year and Mason if McNair goes to Baltimore - watchout. No real #3 receiver. Took a leap at Colbert at the end hoping he can perform as he did as a rookie (providing his bad ankle last season was the cause of his demise. Price and Taylor and McCariens provide depth.
Tight Ends
7.05 Stevens, Jerramy SEA TE 5
21.05 Clark, Desmond CHI TE 7
Solid Tight Ends - top tier gone but should get good points from Stevens and Clark is a solid backup
Kicker
25.05 Reed, Jeff PIT PK 4
27.05 Wilkins, Jeff STL PK 7
Good solid kickers.
Defensive Lineman
8.12 Taylor, Jason MIA DE 8
17.05 Kampman, Aaron GBP DE 6
24.12 Keisel, Brett PIT DE Fri 4
Taylor should be huge for us. Kampman has steadily improved each year and Keisel is great backup. Hopfully enough depth at this position.
Linebackers
4.12 Vilma, Jonathan NYJ LB 9
12.12 Mitchell, Kawika KCC LB 3
14.12 Greenway, Chad MIN LB ® 6
18.12 Wilson, Al DEN LB 4
32.12 Ingram, Clint JAC LB ® 6
Vilma will provide us good points each weak. Maybe asking too much of rookies with Greenway and Ingram. Took the last draft pick to go with a LB that might get that starting spot and provide some good points. Al Wilson - not spectacular but steady.
Defensive Backs
11.05 Barber, Ronde TBB CB 4
13.05 Tillman, Charles CHI CB 7
19.05 Hope, Chris TEN S 7
22.12 Ferguson, Nick DEN S 4
26.12 Vincent, Troy BUF S 8
29.05 Hill, Renaldo MIA CB 8
Again very good solid group of DB's. With the flex positions our depth at this position could be our salvation. Was glad to see we got such good talent in the later rounds.
Overall grade - Above average
- time will tell. 
Our (co-owned team) strategy was to get 1 really good solid stud at each position and good solid backups and try and stay away from the bye week blues. We also had targeted the defensive studs early (linebacker and DL) a little later on DB's. They seem to be more volatile from year to year and generally looked for solid talent.
Never been part of a survivor team before and fairly new at IDP ( 3rd year) all though my co-owner I believe has done survivor before and has tons of IDP experience. He had most of the rough drafting after all the real talent was gone. And I was out of town. Overall I think we did well weak at WR more than anywhere else in IMHO.
Quarterbacks
6.12 Roethlisberger, Ben PIT QB 4
10.12 Rivers, Philip SDC QB 3
Big Ben should be solid and by week 4 Rivers should be in the swing. If Rivers doesn't adjust well and Ben has health issues - could be a problem. I won't give a grade as I'm not real sure what sort of grading system to use. You guys go ahead and tear us up.
Running Backs
1.05 Brown, Ronnie MIA RB 8
2.12 Jones, Julius DAL RB 3
9.05 Staley, Duce PIT RB 4
15.05 Calhoun, Brian DET RB ® 8
28.12 Sellers, Mike WAS RB 8
30.12 Smith, Antowain HOU RB 5
Bye week blues and lack of depth cost us a roster spot or 2. Tryed to get the RB depth of players that will get points from receiving as well as rushing yardage. If Brown breaks out and Jones stays healthy - should be solid.
Wide Receivers
3.05 Wayne, Reggie IND WR 6
5.05 Mason, Derrick BAL WR 7
16.12 McCareins, Justin NYJ WR 9
20.12 Taylor, Travis MIN WR 6
23.05 Price, Peerless BUF WR 8
31.05 Colbert, Keary CAR WR 9
This might be our weakest spot. Wayne should be huge this year and Mason if McNair goes to Baltimore - watchout. No real #3 receiver. Took a leap at Colbert at the end hoping he can perform as he did as a rookie (providing his bad ankle last season was the cause of his demise. Price and Taylor and McCariens provide depth.
Tight Ends
7.05 Stevens, Jerramy SEA TE 5
21.05 Clark, Desmond CHI TE 7
Solid Tight Ends - top tier gone but should get good points from Stevens and Clark is a solid backup
Kicker
25.05 Reed, Jeff PIT PK 4
27.05 Wilkins, Jeff STL PK 7
Good solid kickers.
Defensive Lineman
8.12 Taylor, Jason MIA DE 8
17.05 Kampman, Aaron GBP DE 6
24.12 Keisel, Brett PIT DE Fri 4
Taylor should be huge for us. Kampman has steadily improved each year and Keisel is great backup. Hopfully enough depth at this position.
Linebackers
4.12 Vilma, Jonathan NYJ LB 9
12.12 Mitchell, Kawika KCC LB 3
14.12 Greenway, Chad MIN LB ® 6
18.12 Wilson, Al DEN LB 4
32.12 Ingram, Clint JAC LB ® 6
Vilma will provide us good points each weak. Maybe asking too much of rookies with Greenway and Ingram. Took the last draft pick to go with a LB that might get that starting spot and provide some good points. Al Wilson - not spectacular but steady.
Defensive Backs
11.05 Barber, Ronde TBB CB 4
13.05 Tillman, Charles CHI CB 7
19.05 Hope, Chris TEN S 7
22.12 Ferguson, Nick DEN S 4
26.12 Vincent, Troy BUF S 8
29.05 Hill, Renaldo MIA CB 8
Again very good solid group of DB's. With the flex positions our depth at this position could be our salvation. Was glad to see we got such good talent in the later rounds.
Overall grade - Above average
- time will tell.
in a non-IDP league, I'd be more inclined to agree with you. With 16 starters each week though, 3 WRs will usually account for only about 20% of your scoring. I think you can survive in an IDP league without great depth at almost any single position.
Fullback Fro
yesno
Aren't WR's the one single position that scores the most points per position alotment?
probably. but, you can get some huge weeks from your LBs and DBs and RBs too.
Miggity
not a phallus
That was a lot of fun. I enjoyed not being saddled with ADP numbers and having the freedom to grab guys I liked wherever.
I missed the bolded picks so can't take credit/blame for those. Overall it looks like a decent team to me - waiting until round 11 for the first D pick means the O should be solid.
There are questions at LB and DB, but if a couple of those giant upside guys hit then I should be in good shape. I like my DL Hall and Smith a lot. Outisde of Briggs and Marshall, the LB corps looks like boom or bust, but I like the potential of all the other LBs on the team.
I waited too long on DBs, multiple times, so that is an area of concern. Interesting to see a couple of strategies at play, seems most guys went for the safeties - I noticed Arud went the opposite way and drafted all CB. Maybe in a survivor format multiple CBs give better production with INT than multiple S do with consistent tackle numbers. We'll see.
Brees, Drew NOS QB - 7
Culpepper, Daunte MIA QB - 8
Anderson, Mike BAL RB - 7
Dillon, Corey NEP RB - 6
Fason, Ciatrick MIN RB - 6
Gado, Samkon GBP RB - 6
Jordan, Lamont OAK RB - 3
Chambers, Chris MIA WR - 8
Evans, Lee BUF WR - 8
Holmes, Santonio PIT WR ® - 4
Holt, Torry STL WR - 7
Jackson, Chad NEP WR ® - 6
Johnson, Keyshawn CAR WR - 9
Crumpler, Alge ATL TE - 5
Johnson, Eric SFO TE - 7
Carney, John NOS PK - 7
Graham, Shayne CIN PK - 5
Brown, Alex CHI DE - 7
Cole, Trent PHI DE - 9
Hall, James DET DE - 8
Smith, Will NOS DE - 7
Bockwoldt, Colby NOS LB - 7
Briggs, Lance CHI LB - 7
Cowart, Sam HOU LB - 5
Hill, Leroy SEA LB - 5
Marshall, Lemar WAS LB - 8
McCoy, Matt PHI LB - 9
Allen, Jason MIA CB ® - 8
McGee, Terrence BUF CB - 8
Williams, Darrent DEN CB - 4
Jackson, Dexter CIN S - 5
Milloy, Lawyer ATL S - 5
I missed the bolded picks so can't take credit/blame for those. Overall it looks like a decent team to me - waiting until round 11 for the first D pick means the O should be solid.
There are questions at LB and DB, but if a couple of those giant upside guys hit then I should be in good shape. I like my DL Hall and Smith a lot. Outisde of Briggs and Marshall, the LB corps looks like boom or bust, but I like the potential of all the other LBs on the team.
I waited too long on DBs, multiple times, so that is an area of concern. Interesting to see a couple of strategies at play, seems most guys went for the safeties - I noticed Arud went the opposite way and drafted all CB. Maybe in a survivor format multiple CBs give better production with INT than multiple S do with consistent tackle numbers. We'll see.
Brees, Drew NOS QB - 7
Culpepper, Daunte MIA QB - 8
Anderson, Mike BAL RB - 7
Dillon, Corey NEP RB - 6
Fason, Ciatrick MIN RB - 6
Gado, Samkon GBP RB - 6
Jordan, Lamont OAK RB - 3
Chambers, Chris MIA WR - 8
Evans, Lee BUF WR - 8
Holmes, Santonio PIT WR ® - 4
Holt, Torry STL WR - 7
Jackson, Chad NEP WR ® - 6
Johnson, Keyshawn CAR WR - 9
Crumpler, Alge ATL TE - 5
Johnson, Eric SFO TE - 7
Carney, John NOS PK - 7
Graham, Shayne CIN PK - 5
Brown, Alex CHI DE - 7
Cole, Trent PHI DE - 9
Hall, James DET DE - 8
Smith, Will NOS DE - 7
Bockwoldt, Colby NOS LB - 7
Briggs, Lance CHI LB - 7
Cowart, Sam HOU LB - 5
Hill, Leroy SEA LB - 5
Marshall, Lemar WAS LB - 8
McCoy, Matt PHI LB - 9
Allen, Jason MIA CB ® - 8
McGee, Terrence BUF CB - 8
Williams, Darrent DEN CB - 4
Jackson, Dexter CIN S - 5
Milloy, Lawyer ATL S - 5
beto
Footballguy
I've done pretty well in survivors (top 3 in MBSL3 two years running) and have gotten by without WR depth. It's really more of a matter of picking solid guys early because the position gets picked over pretty quickly.
I will try to post my team for comment when I get a few minutes.
LOL at Miggity bolding the guys he didn't pick.
1.13 McGahee, Willis BUF RB
I considered Rudi here. Knew I could get a top WR in the 2nd
2.04 Fitzgerald, Larry ARI WR
Wanted Steve Smith. Bit of a gamble taking Fitz but hopefully he
wasn't a fluke. Some decent RBs left but didn't like the #1 WRs that
would be around at 3.13. Thought about Owens but couldn't pull the
trigger. Got a piece later by taking Bledsoe.
3.13 Bell, Tatum DEN RB
Getting into the RBBC committee guys here. I'm hoping Bell won't
share much once the season starts. Can't remember who else I
was considering here. Probably CuMar and Addai. QBs are not
flying off the board like in some survivors I've been in so I'm not
hot to take one yet. Hopefully Denver uses Bell in the passing game.
4.04 Driver, Donald GBP WR
Another risky pick as Favre still hadn't announced. I figured he
probably would play. He is a very solid survivor player. Can't
remember if I considered anyone else here. I don't pick another
WR for a while so glad I got the Driver.
5.13 Bledsoe, Drew DAL QB
These are the best WRs he has had that I can remember. I've had
him the past 2 years in MBSL3 but usually get him later. I think I was
set to take Urlacher if he fell. He and Vilma were guys I would have
taken here. Trent Green was prolly my second choice which is a little
bit different than most boards.
6.04 McMichael, Randy MIA TE
Tough one here as TEs are pretty valuable in this format. I liked Galloway
but didn't want to take a 3rd WR this early. Deciding to wait on D since guys
like Donnie Edwards are long gone. Wasn't super comfortable with remaining
TEs as my TE1.
7.13 Vick, Michael ATL QB
Would have taken Lofa Tatupu if he would have lasted. Going to wait on LBs
at this point. If Vick plays well this will be a good pair at QB for team Beto.
8.04 Williams, Demorrio ATL LB
This was a panic pick. I see Thurman and Brooking go off the table (good drafting guys) and reach for the youngster from ATL. Do not want to pick my 1st LB in the 9th.
9.13 Jones, Greg JAC RB
My sleeper for '06. Glad to get him here. RB cupboard is empty.
10.04 Brooks, Derrick TBB LB
Glad to see him still here. Did you guys pass on him because of his
age? In possible start 4 LB league I needed to get another top 20 guy.
11.13 Curtis, Kevin STL WR
Finally go WR3. Again, lots of WRs I would have taken went between 10.04 and
11.13, nice job guys. I still like Curtis but he won't put up consistent numbers
unless Bruce or Holt get hurt.
12.04 Dawkins, Brian PHI S
13.13 Vrabel, Mike NEP LB
14.04 Freeney, Dwight IND DE
Filling out the D with players I like. Prolly would have taken Matt Jones in Freeney's spot.
15.13 Winslow, Kellen CLE TE
I really like this pick but probably shouldn't. I'm not a Winslow fan but I thought
he represented value here.
16.04 244 Beto Harrison, Rodney NEP S
Don't know much about his recovery but could be great value.
17.13 Hargrove, Tony STL DE
18.04 Caldwell, Reche NEP WR
19.13 Foote, Larry PIT LB
20.04 Vanderjagt, Mike DAL PK
21.13 Arrington, J.J. ARI RB
22.04 Chavous, Corey STL S
23.13 Dilfer, Trent SFO QB
24.04 Curry, Ronald OAK WR
All these picks made while I was on vacation. Can't remember how many
came from my pre-draft list. Was pissed to see Nick Collins went when I
got back.
25.13 Haynes, Verron PIT RB
26.04 Edwards, Kalimba DET DE
27.13 Kasay, John CAR PK
28.04 Polley, Tommy BAL LB
29.13 Berrian, Bernard CHI WR
30.04 Roman, Mark GBP S
31.13 Finneran, Brian ATL WR
32.04 Canty, Chris DAL DE
Tried to take some WR depth late. Don't know it will do any good.
I think Kasay and Vany will be good K
McMichael and Winslow good TEs
I will try to post my team for comment when I get a few minutes.
LOL at Miggity bolding the guys he didn't pick.
1.13 McGahee, Willis BUF RB
I considered Rudi here. Knew I could get a top WR in the 2nd
2.04 Fitzgerald, Larry ARI WR
Wanted Steve Smith. Bit of a gamble taking Fitz but hopefully he
wasn't a fluke. Some decent RBs left but didn't like the #1 WRs that
would be around at 3.13. Thought about Owens but couldn't pull the
trigger. Got a piece later by taking Bledsoe.
3.13 Bell, Tatum DEN RB
Getting into the RBBC committee guys here. I'm hoping Bell won't
share much once the season starts. Can't remember who else I
was considering here. Probably CuMar and Addai. QBs are not
flying off the board like in some survivors I've been in so I'm not
hot to take one yet. Hopefully Denver uses Bell in the passing game.
4.04 Driver, Donald GBP WR
Another risky pick as Favre still hadn't announced. I figured he
probably would play. He is a very solid survivor player. Can't
remember if I considered anyone else here. I don't pick another
WR for a while so glad I got the Driver.
5.13 Bledsoe, Drew DAL QB
These are the best WRs he has had that I can remember. I've had
him the past 2 years in MBSL3 but usually get him later. I think I was
set to take Urlacher if he fell. He and Vilma were guys I would have
taken here. Trent Green was prolly my second choice which is a little
bit different than most boards.
6.04 McMichael, Randy MIA TE
Tough one here as TEs are pretty valuable in this format. I liked Galloway
but didn't want to take a 3rd WR this early. Deciding to wait on D since guys
like Donnie Edwards are long gone. Wasn't super comfortable with remaining
TEs as my TE1.
7.13 Vick, Michael ATL QB
Would have taken Lofa Tatupu if he would have lasted. Going to wait on LBs
at this point. If Vick plays well this will be a good pair at QB for team Beto.
8.04 Williams, Demorrio ATL LB
This was a panic pick. I see Thurman and Brooking go off the table (good drafting guys) and reach for the youngster from ATL. Do not want to pick my 1st LB in the 9th.
9.13 Jones, Greg JAC RB
My sleeper for '06. Glad to get him here. RB cupboard is empty.
10.04 Brooks, Derrick TBB LB
Glad to see him still here. Did you guys pass on him because of his
age? In possible start 4 LB league I needed to get another top 20 guy.
11.13 Curtis, Kevin STL WR
Finally go WR3. Again, lots of WRs I would have taken went between 10.04 and
11.13, nice job guys. I still like Curtis but he won't put up consistent numbers
unless Bruce or Holt get hurt.
12.04 Dawkins, Brian PHI S
13.13 Vrabel, Mike NEP LB
14.04 Freeney, Dwight IND DE
Filling out the D with players I like. Prolly would have taken Matt Jones in Freeney's spot.
15.13 Winslow, Kellen CLE TE
I really like this pick but probably shouldn't. I'm not a Winslow fan but I thought
he represented value here.
16.04 244 Beto Harrison, Rodney NEP S
Don't know much about his recovery but could be great value.
17.13 Hargrove, Tony STL DE
18.04 Caldwell, Reche NEP WR
19.13 Foote, Larry PIT LB
20.04 Vanderjagt, Mike DAL PK
21.13 Arrington, J.J. ARI RB
22.04 Chavous, Corey STL S
23.13 Dilfer, Trent SFO QB
24.04 Curry, Ronald OAK WR
All these picks made while I was on vacation. Can't remember how many
came from my pre-draft list. Was pissed to see Nick Collins went when I
got back.
25.13 Haynes, Verron PIT RB
26.04 Edwards, Kalimba DET DE
27.13 Kasay, John CAR PK
28.04 Polley, Tommy BAL LB
29.13 Berrian, Bernard CHI WR
30.04 Roman, Mark GBP S
31.13 Finneran, Brian ATL WR
32.04 Canty, Chris DAL DE
Tried to take some WR depth late. Don't know it will do any good.
I think Kasay and Vany will be good K
McMichael and Winslow good TEs
Last edited by a moderator:
Fullback Fro
yesno
Fullback Fro
Hasselbeck, Matt SEA QB - 5
Plummer, Jake DEN QB - 4
Bush, Reggie NOS RB ® - 7
Davenport, Najeh GBP RB - 6
Gore, Frank SFO RB - 7
Parker, Willie PIT RB - 4
Battle, Arnaz SFO WR - 7
Clayton, Michael TBB WR - 4
Jackson, Vincent SDC WR - 3
Jurevicius, Joe CLE WR - 6
Pinkston, Todd PHI WR - 9
Robinson, Koren MIN WR - 6
Robinson, Marcus MIN WR - 6
Toomer, Amani NYG WR - 4
Heap, Todd BAL TE - 7
Lewis, Marcedes JAC TE ® - 6
Mare, Olindo MIA PK - 8
Nedney, Joe SFO PK - 7
Abraham, John ATL DE - 5
Carter, Kevin MIA DE - 8
Pryce, Trevor BAL DE - 7
Rice, Simeon TBB DE - 4
Brooking, Keith ATL LB - 5
Bruschi, Tedy NEP LB - 6
Dansby, Karlos ARI LB - 9
Lehman, Teddy DET LB - 8
Pierce, Antonio NYG LB - 4
Lucas, Ken CAR CB - 9
Mathis, Rashean JAC CB - 6
Vasher, Nathan CHI CB - 7
Brown, Mike CHI S - 7
Huff, Michael OAK S ® - 3
Hasselbeck, Matt SEA QB - 5
Plummer, Jake DEN QB - 4
Bush, Reggie NOS RB ® - 7
Davenport, Najeh GBP RB - 6
Gore, Frank SFO RB - 7
Parker, Willie PIT RB - 4
Battle, Arnaz SFO WR - 7
Clayton, Michael TBB WR - 4
Jackson, Vincent SDC WR - 3
Jurevicius, Joe CLE WR - 6
Pinkston, Todd PHI WR - 9
Robinson, Koren MIN WR - 6
Robinson, Marcus MIN WR - 6
Toomer, Amani NYG WR - 4
Heap, Todd BAL TE - 7
Lewis, Marcedes JAC TE ® - 6
Mare, Olindo MIA PK - 8
Nedney, Joe SFO PK - 7
Abraham, John ATL DE - 5
Carter, Kevin MIA DE - 8
Pryce, Trevor BAL DE - 7
Rice, Simeon TBB DE - 4
Brooking, Keith ATL LB - 5
Bruschi, Tedy NEP LB - 6
Dansby, Karlos ARI LB - 9
Lehman, Teddy DET LB - 8
Pierce, Antonio NYG LB - 4
Lucas, Ken CAR CB - 9
Mathis, Rashean JAC CB - 6
Vasher, Nathan CHI CB - 7
Brown, Mike CHI S - 7
Huff, Michael OAK S ® - 3
Twilight
Footballguy
This is covered in my weekly notes, and look SSL-IDP in the link in my Sig.But Red Herring is first out.
