Zyphros
Footballguy
Hi all, been a minute since I've been on this forum. Loved all the conversations I've had on here in the past. People I got to know a bit are probably not even here that much anymore ha. Never really post much anymore. I've been getting all my prospect talk on Twitter for a while now. And yes I'm still waiting for Preston Williams to officially become the WR1 of the league.
Anyways figured this would be a good time to workshop a bit, get some comments and show the process since I used to post lots of types of rankings around here. You see different types of rankings all the time, I always base mine off PPR and fantasy impact, not NFL impact. I don't do QB's or TE's so they're not involved here.
My process has evolved so much since I started doing this. Finally in a good place with misses like everyone else. I like where my process leads me a lot of the time. I'm mostly a tape guy and I'll add analytics a bit later on when testing and draft capital is more known. Right now I have only film grades into these tiers and it's the baseline for players during my process. Here they are:
Tier 1 = God Tier - elite of the elite (only 2 to fall into this category over the last 3 years is Tee Higgins and Ja'Marr Chase. Barkley likely would of been here as well from 2018, but I started this for the 2019 class)
WR's - None
RB's - None
Tier 2 = Demi-God's - above average NFL WR1, not elite but has long term sustainability, NFL RB1
WR's - Justyn Ross, George Pickens, David Bell
RB's - Kenneth Walker
Tier 3 = Fighter Tier - NFL WR2 usually sustains success, NFL RB1a type of role possibly more
WR's - Romeo Doubs, Drake London, Treylon Burks, Garrett Wilson
RB's - Rachaad White, Isaiah Spiller, Breece Hall
Tier 4 = Good Soldier Tier - NFL WR3 type, fantasy impact may be limited, decent players, just not special in any way. Might throw in a good year here and there. NFL backup RB
WR's - Jahan Dotson, Skyy Moore, Jameson Williams, Chris Olave, Jalen Tolbert, John Metchie, Dontario Drummond, Wan'Dale Robinson, Joshua Moore
RB's - Jashaun Corbin, Kyren Williams, Zamir White, Sincere McCormick, Keaontay Ingram, Jerrion Ealy, Brian Robinson Jr., Tyler Allgeier, ZaQuandre White
Only like maybe half of this group? I find it obvious but some might not, it's the front of the tier. The guys I like will always get that nod. so the top3 WR's and top4 RB's are my only real interest.
Tier 5 = Questionable Starter/Flyer's - Hopeful's to carve out a role, deep backups, only applicable for deep leagues
WR's - Chris Autman-Bell, Reggie Roberson, Alec Pierce, Sam Pinckney, Jaquarri Roberson
RB's - Kevin Harris, Zonovan Knight, Dameon Pierce, James Cook, Cam'Ron Harris, Jerome Ford, Tyrion Davis-Price, Hassan Haskins, Pierre Strong, Master Teague
At most there's 5 in this tier that I wouldn't mind stashing for a hopeful. But it's grim.
What's going to happen as testing and DC come out, players will move up/down a tier based on how well/early they do at the combine/NFL Draft. For example I know I'm low on Burks as an overall talent, but he'll move up to Tier2 WR's when he tests insanely. And likely to be the first NFL WR drafted, he'll likely be my WR1 when it's all said and done. Mostly this process helps me sort better, weed out outliers, and prioritize guys that NFL teams believe in more, or are better athletes.
In the end my top11 will look something like this:
Walker, Burks, Spiller, Hall, London, Ross, Pickens, Bell, Wilson, Doubs, White (but that's just me projecting their DC/athleticism)
Out of this group I have my personal favorites - Justyn Ross, Romeo Doubs, Kenneth Walker, Rachaad White
Thoughts? Comments? Who do you like from this group?
Anyways figured this would be a good time to workshop a bit, get some comments and show the process since I used to post lots of types of rankings around here. You see different types of rankings all the time, I always base mine off PPR and fantasy impact, not NFL impact. I don't do QB's or TE's so they're not involved here.
My process has evolved so much since I started doing this. Finally in a good place with misses like everyone else. I like where my process leads me a lot of the time. I'm mostly a tape guy and I'll add analytics a bit later on when testing and draft capital is more known. Right now I have only film grades into these tiers and it's the baseline for players during my process. Here they are:
Tier 1 = God Tier - elite of the elite (only 2 to fall into this category over the last 3 years is Tee Higgins and Ja'Marr Chase. Barkley likely would of been here as well from 2018, but I started this for the 2019 class)
WR's - None
RB's - None
Tier 2 = Demi-God's - above average NFL WR1, not elite but has long term sustainability, NFL RB1
WR's - Justyn Ross, George Pickens, David Bell
RB's - Kenneth Walker
Tier 3 = Fighter Tier - NFL WR2 usually sustains success, NFL RB1a type of role possibly more
WR's - Romeo Doubs, Drake London, Treylon Burks, Garrett Wilson
RB's - Rachaad White, Isaiah Spiller, Breece Hall
Tier 4 = Good Soldier Tier - NFL WR3 type, fantasy impact may be limited, decent players, just not special in any way. Might throw in a good year here and there. NFL backup RB
WR's - Jahan Dotson, Skyy Moore, Jameson Williams, Chris Olave, Jalen Tolbert, John Metchie, Dontario Drummond, Wan'Dale Robinson, Joshua Moore
RB's - Jashaun Corbin, Kyren Williams, Zamir White, Sincere McCormick, Keaontay Ingram, Jerrion Ealy, Brian Robinson Jr., Tyler Allgeier, ZaQuandre White
Only like maybe half of this group? I find it obvious but some might not, it's the front of the tier. The guys I like will always get that nod. so the top3 WR's and top4 RB's are my only real interest.
Tier 5 = Questionable Starter/Flyer's - Hopeful's to carve out a role, deep backups, only applicable for deep leagues
WR's - Chris Autman-Bell, Reggie Roberson, Alec Pierce, Sam Pinckney, Jaquarri Roberson
RB's - Kevin Harris, Zonovan Knight, Dameon Pierce, James Cook, Cam'Ron Harris, Jerome Ford, Tyrion Davis-Price, Hassan Haskins, Pierre Strong, Master Teague
At most there's 5 in this tier that I wouldn't mind stashing for a hopeful. But it's grim.
What's going to happen as testing and DC come out, players will move up/down a tier based on how well/early they do at the combine/NFL Draft. For example I know I'm low on Burks as an overall talent, but he'll move up to Tier2 WR's when he tests insanely. And likely to be the first NFL WR drafted, he'll likely be my WR1 when it's all said and done. Mostly this process helps me sort better, weed out outliers, and prioritize guys that NFL teams believe in more, or are better athletes.
In the end my top11 will look something like this:
Walker, Burks, Spiller, Hall, London, Ross, Pickens, Bell, Wilson, Doubs, White (but that's just me projecting their DC/athleticism)
Out of this group I have my personal favorites - Justyn Ross, Romeo Doubs, Kenneth Walker, Rachaad White
Thoughts? Comments? Who do you like from this group?