Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Swapping OBJ and Evans (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter jmo87usc
- Start date
Spectrum
Footballguy
It's pretty even though I'd lean towards Team B for dynasty.
I'd rather have OBJ than Evans, though Winston-Evans can potentially be as good of a QB-WR there is the next few years. Assuming OBJ is up to speed soon, other teams will probably double-triple team him more than ever with all the line problems and no other WR's/TE's/RB's scaring anyone so he might give you more bad weeks than Evans.
D. Murray vs. Gurley - I don't know how many very good years Murray has left, especially with Henry there, but Gurley looks bad and could flame out.
Olsen vs. Eifert - Olsen next 2 years.
Carson - If the offensive line can improve within two years, he could be really good.
Overall: I'll lean toward what Team B gets.
https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/760370-drop-j-charles-for-james-white-or-corey-davis/
Mr. Irrelevant
IBL Representative
OBJ and Evans are a wash. I personally would take Evans over OBJ 1.01 in a startup but realize I'm in the minority on this.
Olsen and Murray are a wash. Both productive vets with RB1/TE1 potential this year and maaaaybe next, but any value as a starter you get after that will be gravy.
That leaves me with: would I rather have Gurley or Eifert + Carson? And unless it's a TE-premium league, Gurley's a pretty easy choice for me here. They're both uber-talented but Gurley's 23 (!) and generally healthy; Eifert's 27 and constantly banged up.
So even given my slight bias toward Evans over OBJ I'd lean side A here.
Olsen and Murray are a wash. Both productive vets with RB1/TE1 potential this year and maaaaybe next, but any value as a starter you get after that will be gravy.
That leaves me with: would I rather have Gurley or Eifert + Carson? And unless it's a TE-premium league, Gurley's a pretty easy choice for me here. They're both uber-talented but Gurley's 23 (!) and generally healthy; Eifert's 27 and constantly banged up.
So even given my slight bias toward Evans over OBJ I'd lean side A here.
Grigs Allmoon
Footballguy
If you're in the minority, I am, too. I don't typically put too much stock on the distant future, but in this case, OBJ could be in for dreadful QB play a lot sooner than Evans. I'd rather have Evans.
For the rest of the trade...
Olsen and Eifert are pretty much a wash to me. Eifert obviously is younger, but he is hurt so often... Olsen should be pretty decent for this year and next, at least.
As for Gurley versus Murray/Carson, I'd prefer Gurley. The Rams seem to be headed in the right direction. I think Murray is going to be phased out over the course of this season, or at the latest next. Carson is all the rage, but he's still unproven. Add the fact that the Seahawks are seemingly headed in the wrong direction on offense, and still have Rawls and Prosise as young, competent competition.
Despite liking Evans over OBJ in dynasty, I'd take Team A.
Similar threads
