Taylor or McCaffery??? (1 Viewer)

[rothy15]

I've got the first pick in a 12 team non-PPR keeper league. I'm keeping Mixon, and will add a stud RB. League gives bonuses for yards (60, 90, 120...) and length of TD's. Was set on Taylor but now I'm wavering. CMC injury history scares me off a bit, but there is so much upside, IF he says healthy. Thoughts?

 

[northern exposure]

Too many IFs with CMC, I would draft Taylor.

 

[SquashBug]

Taylor. No two ways about it. McCaffery is very good but, as you say, the injury situation scares me a bit and right now Taylor is the man.

 

[Gally]

Taylor is the safe pick. CMC is the gamble pick on upside. Are you a gambler? For me I would take Taylor but I have no problem with CMC. I have him in a couple leagues where I ended up with 1.02 and Taylor was gone.

 

[fooserman55]

I'd go with McCaffrey if it was a PPR league, but since it is not, definitely Taylor.