What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The 'other' Rule Changes for 2010...discuss (1 Viewer)

Black

Footballguy
How will these change the game??

I think the first one is going to change the passing game significantly. At first, there's going to be alot of flags thrown.

NFL rule changes for 2010

• A defenseless player cannot be hit in the head or neck by an opponent who launches himself and uses his helmet, shoulder or forearm to make contact. Previously, this applied only to receivers.

• When a ballcarrier loses his helmet, the whistle will blow and the ball will be placed at the spot where the player lost it.

• The umpire will be stationed behind the offensive backfield rather than in the linebackers area.

• During a field goal or extra point, no player can line up directly across from the snapper. Previously, a player needed to have his helmet outside the snapper's shoulder pads.

• A dead ball personal foul on the final play of the second or fourth quarters will cause a 15-yard penalty on the second-half or overtime kickoff. Previously, no penalty was enforced.

• If a punt returner makes a fair catch signal and muffs the ball, he is entitled to a "reasonable opportunity" to catch the muff before it hits the ground without interference of the coverage team. In case of a penalty, the ball will be placed at the spot of the interference but no yardage marked off.

• When a ball strikes a videoboard (as one punt did last preseason at Cowboys Stadium), guide wire or sky cam, the play is whistled dead and replayed. The game clock is reset to when the play started.

• If the clock is stopped in the final minute of either half for a replay review but would not have stopped without the review, officials will run off 10 seconds before resuming play. Either team can take a timeout to avoid the runoff.

 
Didn't the muff rule always exist? I know the covering team has been flagged for not allowing a returner to recover if it bounces off of him into the air

 
• When a ballcarrier loses his helmet, the whistle will blow and the ball will be placed at the spot where the player lost it.

- good for the game, but why stop at the ballcarrier? If you're gonna have this rule, then make it apply to ALL players on offense.

• The umpire will be stationed behind the offensive backfield rather than in the linebackers area.

- Absolutely devastating for the Football Follies.

• During a field goal or extra point, no player can line up directly across from the snapper. Previously, a player needed to have his helmet outside the snapper's shoulder pads.

- Why is this one even necessary? Are they trying to devalue the long snapper?

• A dead ball personal foul on the final play of the second or fourth quarters will cause a 15-yard penalty on the second-half or overtime kickoff. Previously, no penalty was enforced.

- like it.

• If a punt returner makes a fair catch signal and muffs the ball, he is entitled to a "reasonable opportunity" to catch the muff before it hits the ground without interference of the coverage team. In case of a penalty, the ball will be placed at the spot of the interference but no yardage marked off.

- like it. The fair catch "halo" should stay in effect until the moment the ball hits the ground. Then again, what if a player deliberately muffs the catch and then starts bobbling the ball while running forward? Couldn't he take it all the way to the endzone without being touched??

• When a ball strikes a videoboard (as one punt did last preseason at Cowboys Stadium), guide wire or sky cam, the play is whistled dead and replayed. The game clock is reset to when the play started.

- like it. Prevents a team from exploiting the rules and running off the clock.

• If the clock is stopped in the final minute of either half for a replay review but would not have stopped without the review, officials will run off 10 seconds before resuming play. Either team can take a timeout to avoid the runoff.

- see scenario in next post

 
• When a ballcarrier loses his helmet, the whistle will blow and the ball will be placed at the spot where the player lost it.

there might be an interesting dipute when this is combined with a fumble . was the helmut off ( whistle) before or after fumble

• The umpire will be stationed behind the offensive backfield rather than in the linebackers area.

this one seems like the biggest change because of the picks that are run in the nfl using the ump at the lb spot for a wr to get open . i dont have numbers, but seemed like this particular "pick" is one of the most common nfl wr routes and part of the "basic route tree" in pro football.

 
How will these change the game??

I think the first one is going to change the passing game significantly. At first, there's going to be alot of flags thrown.

NFL rule changes for 2010

• A defenseless player cannot be hit in the head or neck by an opponent who launches himself and uses his helmet, shoulder or forearm to make contact. Previously, this applied only to receivers.

Who counts as defenseless? If this includes idiots not paying attention because the play isn't near them, I hate it. 1st rule of football: If you're on the field, you're in the game. Keep your head on a swivel.

• When a ballcarrier loses his helmet, the whistle will blow and the ball will be placed at the spot where the player lost it.

• The umpire will be stationed behind the offensive backfield rather than in the linebackers area.

This could be big. It wasn't uncommon for receivers to run a pick using the umpire in the linebacker box. This makes that impossible.

• During a field goal or extra point, no player can line up directly across from the snapper. Previously, a player needed to have his helmet outside the snapper's shoulder pads.

• A dead ball personal foul on the final play of the second or fourth quarters will cause a 15-yard penalty on the second-half or overtime kickoff. Previously, no penalty was enforced.

• If a punt returner makes a fair catch signal and muffs the ball, he is entitled to a "reasonable opportunity" to catch the muff before it hits the ground without interference of the coverage team. In case of a penalty, the ball will be placed at the spot of the interference but no yardage marked off.

• When a ball strikes a videoboard (as one punt did last preseason at Cowboys Stadium), guide wire or sky cam, the play is whistled dead and replayed. The game clock is reset to when the play started.

• If the clock is stopped in the final minute of either half for a replay review but would not have stopped without the review, officials will run off 10 seconds before resuming play. Either team can take a timeout to avoid the runoff.

So, say there are 10 seconds on the clock at the end of a play which is reviewed near the end zone. Official review determines that ballcarrier was short of the goal, and ball will be spotted. That team gets screwed, right? A team who is well trained would be able to get to the line and spike it in 10 seconds, but if 10 seconds are required to be run off, that's game over. I don't like this rule if this is the case.
 
• If the clock is stopped in the final minute of either half for a replay review but would not have stopped without the review, officials will run off 10 seconds before resuming play. Either team can take a timeout to avoid the runoff.

SCENARIO:

- Team A trails by 2 points but is within field goal range. No timeouts left.

- On 2nd down, Team A comes up just short of a 1st down at Team B's 20 yard line.

- With ~9 seconds left, Team B prepares to spike ball on 3rd down

- WAIT A MINUTE!! The booth calls for a review of the 2nd down play (even though Team A doesn't care if it gets a 1st down or not)

- refs run off the final 9 seconds of the clock. Game over. Team A is denied a chance to kick the game-winning field goal.

Seems like the review booth has the power to end a game unfairly.

 
• A defenseless player cannot be hit in the head or neck by an opponent who launches himself and uses his helmet, shoulder or forearm to make contact. Previously, this applied only to receivers.

Continued wussification of the game. A defenseless player shouldn't have made himself defenseless.

• When a ballcarrier loses his helmet, the whistle will blow and the ball will be placed at the spot where the player lost it.

Meh. Whatever.

• The umpire will be stationed behind the offensive backfield rather than in the linebackers area.

Good move unless he has a problem seeing holding. I'm sure linemen will be working on hiding their holding from his view.



• During a field goal or extra point, no player can line up directly across from the snapper. Previously, a player needed to have his helmet outside the snapper's shoulder pads.

Stupid. Why doesn't we just ban blocking a kick? We wouldn't want anyone to get hurt...

• A dead ball personal foul on the final play of the second or fourth quarters will cause a 15-yard penalty on the second-half or overtime kickoff. Previously, no penalty was enforced.

Good change.

• If a punt returner makes a fair catch signal and muffs the ball, he is entitled to a "reasonable opportunity" to catch the muff before it hits the ground without interference of the coverage team. In case of a penalty, the ball will be placed at the spot of the interference but no yardage marked off.

Awful rule. If he drops the ball the play should be live immediately. I'm curious to see how refs call this "reasonable opportunity".

• When a ball strikes a videoboard (as one punt did last preseason at Cowboys Stadium), guide wire or sky cam, the play is whistled dead and replayed. The game clock is reset to when the play started.

Good rule.

• If the clock is stopped in the final minute of either half for a replay review but would not have stopped without the review, officials will run off 10 seconds before resuming play. Either team can take a timeout to avoid the runoff.

If they always reset the clock to the time where the previous play should have been blown dead, regardless of if the play is overturned or upheld, I'm good with it.

 
• If the clock is stopped in the final minute of either half for a replay review but would not have stopped without the review, officials will run off 10 seconds before resuming play. Either team can take a timeout to avoid the runoff.

SCENARIO:

- Team A trails by 2 points but is within field goal range. No timeouts left.

- On 2nd down, Team A comes up just short of a 1st down at Team B's 20 yard line.

- With ~9 seconds left, Team B prepares to spike ball on 3rd down

- WAIT A MINUTE!! The booth calls for a review of the 2nd down play (even though Team A doesn't care if it gets a 1st down or not)

- refs run off the final 9 seconds of the clock. Game over. Team A is denied a chance to kick the game-winning field goal.

Seems like the review booth has the power to end a game unfairly.
Interesting, and troubling. Guess you need to get the snap off ASAP.

• The umpire will be stationed behind the offensive backfield rather than in the linebackers area.

I think this is going to result in alot more holding calls (and eventually more sacks). Advantage pass rushers. This will also be interesting for the Wes Welkers of the world. I like the post about this screwing up football follies.

• During a field goal or extra point, no player can line up directly across from the snapper. Previously, a player needed to have his helmet outside the snapper's shoulder pads.

Bet a Center, sick and tired of getting 'bucked', submitted this request.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top