Time to put Eli Manning in the elite category? (1 Viewer)

[Koya]

You can't spell Elite without Eli.

yeah well you can't spell BUTTER without BUTT either... That doesn't mean that they are the same thing as I'm certainly not planning to spread the latter on my bagelsit comes down to what you define as elite really... Elite to me is top 3 and I still can't put him above Rodgers, Brees, & Brady... I have Eli 4th right now... I feel Brady did more with less overall as a team and he ALWAYS seems to do that...1.)Rodgers2.)Brees3.)Brady4.)Eli5.)Ben(note... I can't put Peyton in until I'm sure he is back to form)btw... I love your profile pic drunkenmonks

Thats a decent list. That said, Eli is a unique cat (at least thus far). Regular season he had been about 8-12 overally for a couple years with an uncanny ability to win a big game and had that one sick run to the SB. This past year he was great all year (not elite, but really really good) and had another sick run to the SB.If he has another regular season like this one and continued playoff success, its Elite all the way, but not yet. At this point, very good QB, elite ability to win SBs. I'll take that.

 

[wiscstlatlmia]

Bump

 

[lod01]

You suck Gomer.