Top ten steals of the NFL draft so-far in 2012 (1 Viewer)

[Bracie Smathers]

maybe you guys can help settle an argument, right now do you consider Russell Wilson to be an above average NFL QB ?

Do I consider Russell Wilson to be an above average quarterback at this time?No.

He's a rookie and an average NFL QB is over making rookie mistakes but its not fair to think that a rookie playing the quarterback position in the National Football League would not make typical rookie mistakes. An average NFL QB has had to overcome making rookie mistakes and none of the rookie QBs this year have been error free. They've all made mistakes.

I thought this part of the above Matt Williamson All-Rookie team would have generated some debate:

Williamson chose Richardson over Tampa Bay's Doug Martin, which likely will stir up some debate. "Choosing between Richardson and Martin was really splitting hairs, but I let the fact that I think Richardson will soon rival Adrian Peterson as the best running back in the NFL sway me just a bit," Williamson wrote.

Williamson made his case. What do others think of Trent Richardson getting the nod on an All-Rookie team at the halfway mark of the 2012 season?

 

[Hooper31]

maybe you guys can help settle an argument, right now do you consider Russell Wilson to be an above average NFL QB ?

Answer the question yourself. How do you define "average NFL QB"? If you can't do that its a pointless discussion. Use QBR or the old school rating system. Either is probably a fair and objective analysis.