Trade offer... (1 Viewer)

[IAmTheBruteSquad]

I'm taking over a team in a 11 team rotisserie dynasty league (40 man roster). I've played FF for the last four years and was talked into taking this team by a friend. So I'm totally new to baseball.

Not sure if this was the right forum to post this but would like some advice as to whether or not I should take this trade.

I would get:

Ordonez, Juan Pierre, Huston Street, Chin-Lung Hu, and Jordan Schafer

I would give:

Manny Ramirez, Joe Nathan, Dustin Pedroia, Matt Diaz, and Jose Guillen

My team:

C- A.J. Pierzynski, D. Navarro, J. Estrada

1B- R. Howard, Delgado, Chris Marrero

2B- Brian Roberts, Pedroia, Polanco

3B- Mike Lowell, Casey Blake, Mark Reynolds, S. Rolen

SS- Johnny Peralta, Ryan Theriot, Elvis Andrus

OF- M. Ramirez, A. Soriano, B. Giles, Jay Bruce, M. Diaz, Jose Guillen, Fernando Martinez,

DH- Sheffield, Piazza

SP- C. Young, Blanton, Buehrle, Burnett, Harden, Hudson, K. Rogers, C. Schilling, Gio Gonzalez, C. Kershaw, Wade Davis,

RP- Papelbon, Nathan, M. Rivera, B. Hennessey

Their team:

C- Johjima, Molina

1B- Morneau, D. Young, R. Aurilia

2B- F. Sanchez, Grudzielanek

3B- Garciaparra, Glaus

SS- J. Rollins, Chin-Lung Hu,

OF- Burel, Ibanez, Matthews Jr., Ordonez, J. Pierre, Kubel, B. Bonds, R. Winn, Schafer, R. Church

DH- Thome

SP- Glavine, Halladay, Gorzelanny, Byrd, Jimenez, Kendrick, Loaiza, Gaudin, M. Owings, R. Porcello, Jerrod Parker

RP- H. Bell, T. Jones, H. Street, Guerrier, Morrow, Sherrill

Start: C, C, 1B, 2B, 3B, 2B/SS, 1B/3B, OF, OF, OF, OF, UTIL, SP x 7, RP x 5

Limit 1600 innings pitched, 2100 games played

The kicker here is that they really want Nathan being Minn. Twins fans.

Thanks...

 

[Bobcat10]

You're gonna have to post your roster and the categories to get some love around here.

 

[boom king]

your team is good, HOLD ONTO KERSHAW, i know hes not in the deal, but dont let anyone steal him from you. i would maybe wait for a better deal. its not a bad offer, but it doesnt improve your team enough to jusity it. youre in the drivers seat.

 

[Bobcat10]

your team is good, HOLD ONTO KERSHAW, i know hes not in the deal, but dont let anyone steal him from you. i would maybe wait for a better deal. its not a bad offer, but it doesnt improve your team enough to jusity it. youre in the drivers seat.

What do you think if he took the closers out of the deal? Doing that favors him, but is that enough? I think I might pull it, but wouldn't be sold for sure.

 

[Bobcat10]

At second glance, this guy seems to have needs at 2B and RP. What do you think about offering him Pedroia, Rivera and Guillen (and Diaz if he wants him) for ManRam? Probably not enough to get him?

 

[weisguy0831]

i would pass on the deal in the original post.