Trade Offered: Thurman for R. Williams? (1 Viewer)

[merc]

There is another owner in a 12 team dynasty league, who has got the hots for Odell Thurman and has made me this offer.

I get Ricky Williams

and

I give Odell Thurman

Should I do this deal?

We are at the end of the 10th round in our draft and here is my roster so far:

QB: Hasslebeck

RB: Alexander

WR: T. Owens

FL: J. Jones

FL: L. Coles

TE: Heap

K:

IDP: M. Peterson

IDP: O. Thurman

IDP:

Bench(8): M. Moore, Michael Clayton

Here is our scoring:

Offensive Scoring:25yds pass = 1, 10yds rush/rec = 1, , 1 reception = .5, Interception = -2, Fumble Lost = -2, All Touchdowns = 6, 50yds return = 1, Two-point conversion = 2.

Defensive Scoring:Solo tackle = 1, Sack = 2, INT = 3, Fumble Forced = 3, Fumble Recovered = 3, Blocked Kick = 3, Safety = 4, Pass Defensed = 1, 50yds return = 1.

Kicker Scoring: FG 0-39yds = 3, FG 40-49yds = 4, FG 50+yds = 5, PAT = 1.

So... should I do this deal or not?

Thanks for your help in this decision...

Take Care,

merc

 

[Renegades of Funk]

All depends on what IDP's are still on the board. For dynasty Thurman will be a stud for years to come. Even if Ricky gets a full time job he probably only has a couple good years left.

 

[merc]

Thanks for the help!

Here are the LBs that are still available from the list:

9. Ray Lewis

13. Zach Thomas

16. Takeo Spikes

17. Derrick Johnson - R

18. Lance Briggs - 3

19. Cato June - 3

21. Dan Morgan

22. AJ Hawk®

23t. Karlos Dansby - 2

23t. Kirk Morrison - R

25. Jeremiah Trotter

26. Lemar Marshall - 4

27. James Farrior

29. Will Witherspoon 4

30. Kawika Mitchell

31. Derrick Brooks

32. Marcus Washington

33. Morlon Greenwood

34t. Danny Clark

34t. Ian Gold

36. Kailee Wong

37. Channing Crowder

38. LeRoy Hill

39. Lavar Arrington

 

[Mike]

Absolutely you should take this deal. No doubt. My God, someone please send me an offer like this.

 

[Pick]

Much easier to reload at LB than at RB. 2 decent seasons from Ricky would make it worth it. Anything after that is gravy.

 

[stevec]

Take it & run.

 

[merc]

Thank you all very much for your help and reassurance. After reading your posts, I decided to accept the deal.... my team is starting to shape up nicely....but I hope I don't regret losing Thurman?

 

[Tick]

Nah, you won't regret it - take an old scoring machine like Thomas or Lewis. You can always fill in with a returning DB later.