Trade Question (1 Viewer)

[Here's Johnny]

12 ppr record 3-3

RB's Kamara, Howard, Richard, Chubb, A Jones

WR's AJ, Tate, C Davis, Godwin

TE Howard, Kittle

I give: Kamara, Tate and Kittle

I get McCaffrey and Michael Thomas

It does not address my weakness at rb2, so I may just be spinning my wheels.  I have two TEs so I would be trading Kamara and Tate for McCaffrey and THomas.

 

[Gally]

I think the upgrade of Thomas is more than the downgrade to CMC so I would probably leans towards the deal.  However, I don't see Kittle as being just a throw in.  I would be starting him over Howard most weeks so I don't see that as insignificant piece.  That brings it much closer to not making the deal as it improves the other side quite a bit for me. 

 

[danashort]

I would leave kittle out of it....other than that it seems fair

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/771522-trade-assistance/

 

[beerbuff]

I'd stay put. New Orleans passing schedule will be getting tougher and Thomas's hot start has cooled off, plus I'd rather go with Kittle every week.

 

[Who am I?]

I think Thomas could finish year as #1 WR. Kamara will drop back down now that Ingram back. I would try it without Kittle first though.

 

[chapie1968]

I'd stay put. New Orleans passing schedule will be getting tougher and Thomas's hot start has cooled off, plus I'd rather go with Kittle every week.

Plus I see them going back to more of a ground game now that Ingram is back. Brees numbers weren't all that great last year when they played that style.

 

[BlueDredSo]

I agree with a few people who have responded already. I'd do it, but try to hang onto Kittle or at least get another player back.

 

[Usual21]

I agree with the above statements. Try and keep Kittle somehow. Beathard loves him.

Please see mine:https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/771551-who-do-i-drop/