Trading Antonio Brown (Redraft .5 PPR) (1 Viewer)

[Mr. Know-It-All]

Question - I have Antonio Brown, Demaryius Thomas and Maclin (plus Dorsett and Julius Thomas) at WR (start 3) - my rbs are CJ Anderson, DeAgelo, Duke Johnson, Chris Thompson, Shane Vereen (start 2).

Proposed trade would have me send Brown and Johnson to another team for David Johnson and Will Fuller.  On one hand it would give me two really good RBs, but on the other I am giving away the consistency of Antonio Brown.  I am VERY tempted.  Thoughts?

If it matters it is a .5 ppr,

 

[NeverEnough]

That's not a bad offer, but I think I keep AB

 

[Timmy1310]

Try to get a better wr fuller is good but I have a feeling he will be inconsistent. Antonio brown will for the most part be a consistent 20+ player besides last week 

 

[atcdav]

very fair. tough call, look at play off schedules to help you decide

 

[Skoo]

I wouldn't do it.

It's not that the trade is so unbalanced or anything, but IMO it doesn't help you much. Yes, you'll be very strong at RB but now you'll be weak at WR instead.

Personally, if I'm going to trade the hands down #1 player in fantasy football, it needs to be so good I would have to be insane not to take it. And even then it would be tough.

 

[Warhogs]

I don't like it.  I'll take Brown over anyone in a PPR league.  Duke Johnson caught a ton of balls last year and he will this year.  Where I think the offer falls short for me is Will Fuller.  He has had a nice start but is more of a burner that was known for inconsistent hands.  I'm afraid he will put up a lot of stinkers.  Overall, at this time it looks like this is a fair offer I just prefer A. Brown as the best player in the deal.

 

[msudaisy26]

I wouldn't do the trade. Brown is money in the bank. He has a game like he had last week like once a year.