What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Trump's EO banning WeChat and TikTok (1 Viewer)

The Z Machine

Footballguy
Looks like Trump is following through on his pledge to ban these apps for national security reasons.  

From https://www.npr.org/2020/08/06/900019185/trump-signs-executive-order-that-will-effectively-ban-use-of-tiktok-in-the-u-s

President Trump on Thursday invoked his emergency economic powers to impose broad sanctions against TikTok, a move that steps up pressure on the Chinese-owned app to sell its U.S. assets to an American company.

In the order, which takes effect in 45 days, any transactions between TikTok's parent company, ByteDance, and U.S. citizens will be outlawed for national security reasons.

In practice, experts told NPR the order likely will mean the viral video service could no longer receive advertising from American companies and the app could be removed from Apple and Google's app stores.

TECHNOLOGY

Class-Action Lawsuit Claims TikTok Steals Kids' Data And Sends It To China

For the more than 100 million Americans who have downloaded TikTok, experts say the app may no longer be sent software updates, rendering TikTok unmanageable, and eventually nonfunctional, with time.

"When we talk about sanctions against Russian oligarchs and kleptocrats, well, the sanctions are that no American can do business with them," Stewart Baker, the former general counsel at the National Security Agency, told NPR last month when speculation about the order first began to spread.

Now, that same sanction has been used against TikTok.

In the order, the White House says TikTok captures vast swaths of information from its users, including location data and Internet search history.

TikTok is open about what data it collects, an amount that is on par with what is harvested by apps owned by American tech companies Google, Facebook and Apple.

"While TikTok is being singled out in this executive order, their data collection and sharing practices are fairly standard in the industry," said University of Notre Dame technology professor Kirsten Martin. "In fact, many fitness apps were banned from use in the military for tracking location data, but we did not ban them from all U.S. citizens."

Yet the White House says what makes TikTok distinct is the theoretical possibility of it handing over data to Chinese authorities, as the Trump administration wages an intensifying trade war against China.

"This data collection threatens to allow the Chinese Communist Party access to Americans' personal and proprietary information — potentially allowing China to track the locations of Federal employees and contractors, build dossiers of personal information for blackmail, and conduct corporate espionage," the executive order reads.

TikTok has downplayed its ties to Beijing, saying data it captures on U.S. users is stored mostly in Virginia. Officials at TikTok also insist the company has never turned over any data to Chinese authorities, despite the county's broad national powers to request such data from private companies.

A federal class-action lawsuit involving dozens of American families claims an independent security review of TikTok revealed that the app is siphoning data, including the facial profiles of American children, and sending it to Chinese servers, though the suit does not provide evidence any information has ever been transferred to the Chinese Communist Party.

Since the Trump administration began turning up the heat on TikTok, software giant Microsoft has confirmed it is among a handful of companies in early talks to acquire the short-form video service.

For Microsoft, a $1.5 trillion company that has focused its business mostly on corporate clients by selling software and cloud computing services, buying TikTok would be its first major foray into a social media platform popular among young users.

Microsoft already owns game console company Xbox, networking site LinkedIn and messaging service Skype.

Officials at Microsoft say it is examining a TikTok acquisition that would potentially buy TikTok's American, Canadian, Australian and New Zealand services, but officials close to the deal say the final offer may include operations in even more countries.

Trump's executive order comes on the same day Facebook launched a new product Reels, a video-sharing app that mimics TikTok's core features.

TikTok has accused Facebook of introducing a "copycat" service, arguing that the social network is trying to capitalize on the administration's zeal to punish China for its own benefit.

Trump on Thursday also signed an executive order to restrict the business between China-based Tencent Holdings, the owner of WeChat, and U.S. citizens.

More than a billion people in China use WeChat, an all-in-one app used for messaging, social media and making mobile payments. It is a popular tool for chatting and transactions among Chinese citizens living in the U.S., but the Trump administration says the app could have a nefarious use by authorities in Beijing.

"Like TikTok, WeChat automatically captures vast swaths of information from its users," Trump's separate executive order reads. "In addition, the application captures the personal and proprietary information of Chinese nationals visiting the United States, thereby allowing the Chinese Communist Party a mechanism for keeping tabs on Chinese citizens who may be enjoying the benefits of a free society for the first time in their lives."

On Thursday, the Senate unanimously passed a bill to ban TikTok on government-issued devices, as the view that the app could pose a national security threat to the U.S. gains new bipartisan support in Washington.

A spokeswoman for TikTok did not immediately return a request for comment about the executive order.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Sad
Reactions: rct
My company has asked us to delete WeChat from our company phones this week.  I used it to communicate with my Chinese colleagues and suppliers.  It's so common there that people in China use WeChat for everything.  I knew that everything that I said on WeChat was available for the Chinese gov't to read.  However, if WeChat is scraping data from other apps or the native OS, then there should be repercussions.  I think that should happen for ALL apps though.

Thankfully, I don't use TikTok, and thankfully my kids don't have phones.

 
  • Sad
Reactions: rct
I assume private messages on WeChat are permanently saved and studied by the Chinese government. This could be a problem.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
How does this banning an app work?  

I don't have either app on my phone, but for the millions that do, how do you keep them from using it?  

 
  • Thinking
Reactions: rct
Doesn’t china block twitter and Facebook?
:shrug: and not sure how they do it either, which is why I'm asking.  I'd assume State owned internet, cell service, would make it a lot easier to do in China.  I have no idea how you make Google and Apple pull an app from their store, or keep people from going directly to TikTok and downloading it.  We can't keep Americans from overseas gambling, porn and other "illegal" things, how do you stop them from using TikTok?  

 
Why anybody communicating internationally without an otherwise secure connection doesn't use WhatsApp is beyond me.

TikTok sucks and I have no problem with it being banned. It's malware.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Why anybody communicating internationally without an otherwise secure connection doesn't use WhatsApp is beyond me.

TikTok sucks and I have no problem with it being banned. It's malware.
Because they all use WeChat. I don't care if the Chinese government reads my messages about fine blanked steel and injection molds.

 
Because they all use WeChat. I don't care if the Chinese government reads my messages about fine blanked steel and injection molds.
You may not, but the odds are they’re taking whatever info you are communicating, and then either using the specific info or aggregating it and using the resultant info to sabotage non-Chinese companies in the same or similar industries.

And again, that’s just the data from within that app. They’re very likely tapping into and stealing tons more info/data from outside the app as well.

 
The irony of the US acting like champions of individual privacy is too much to bear.  They’ve been fine to sell us down the river to big tech, to collect phone calls and internet traffic.  Notice that it’s acceptable for Microsoft to assume control of the ‘malware’ app.  

The US govt is a far greater threat with this data than China.  They’ve been spying on Americans and targeting civil dissidents for years.  I don’t see what the operative difference is supposed to be between Facebook and TikTok.  This is about ratcheting up tensions with China. 

 
And again, that’s just the data from within that app. They’re very likely tapping into and stealing tons more info/data from outside the app as well.
That's the much bigger problem IMO. There needs to be strict limitations on apps scraping data from left apps.  Google and Apple need to police spyware.

 
I don't really care about this...just political noise.  

I try to stay focused on the issues/topics that matter.
Interesting.  You don’t think the precedent of leveraging a cut would set would have far reaching effects?   

 
  • Thanks
Reactions: rct
Interesting.  You don’t think the precedent of leveraging a cut would set would have far reaching effects?   
Imagine if the government could get a cut of any merger that required government approval.  Think of the antitrust cases that go to the courts, etc.  I'm all for it.  But I'm a Bernie Bro.  

 
Interesting.  You don’t think the precedent of leveraging a cut would set would have far reaching effects?   
I don't think it's going to happen so it doesn't matter.  This is Trump pandering to his base.  White noise.

 
  • Sad
Reactions: rct
The irony of the US acting like champions of individual privacy is too much to bear.  They’ve been fine to sell us down the river to big tech, to collect phone calls and internet traffic.  Notice that it’s acceptable for Microsoft to assume control of the ‘malware’ app.  

The US govt is a far greater threat with this data than China.  They’ve been spying on Americans and targeting civil dissidents for years.  I don’t see what the operative difference is supposed to be between Facebook and TikTok.  This is about ratcheting up tensions with China. 
i don't really think that individual privacy has been suggested as an impetus for this move at any point.  it is because the U.S. government doesn't want China to have information that could give them more power.  Individual rights have #### all to do with it and I don't think that anyone is claiming otherwise.

 
What the hell is a TicToc?
I am guessing that I could live without it?
My question wasn’t about tiktok itself, I’m old too (40’s) and don’t give a #### about it .  It’s about Trump trying to get a cut of the sale he’s forcing.    

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't think it's going to happen so it doesn't matter.  This is Trump pandering to his base.  White noise.
K. Cool.  Won’t force it.  Just wonder if this would be the same attitude if Bernie was in office “pandering to his base” on socialist actions.  

 
I really have zero idea what you’re getting out here or have zero idea who this person is you tweeted. All of this has absolutely nothing to do with what I asked you about.  The question I asked you was about Trump trying to force retaining a portion of the sale for their fee on a sale he’s forcing. I don’t give a #### about Tiktok, (which for the record my opinion has changed absolutely none so again why you’re replying to me about opinions changing I don’t understand) substitute whatever company name you want for it.

 
I really have zero idea what you’re getting out here or have zero idea who this person is you tweeted. All of this has absolutely nothing to do with what I asked you about.  The question I asked you was about Trump trying to force retaining a portion of the sale for their fee on a sale he’s forcing. I don’t give a #### about Tiktok, (which for the record my opinion has changed absolutely none so again why you’re replying to me about opinions changing I don’t understand) substitute whatever company name you want for it.
David Hogg got his 15 minutes from the MSM after the Stoneman Douglas High School shooting.
He's already been used up by the left and discarded...but still thinks that he's relevant.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Laughing
Reactions: rct
David Hogg got his 15 minutes from the MSM after the Stoneman Douglas High School shooting.
He's already been used up and still thinks that he's relevent.
Ok. Cool. Thanks.  So do you have any desire to answer my question or just keep talking about this kid that has doing at all to do with what I was asking.  If not cool, just say so and I’ll drop it. 

 
David Hogg got his 15 minutes from the MSM after the Stoneman Douglas High School shooting.
He's already been used up by the left and discarded...but still thinks that he's relevant.
And for clarity sake when I quoted you it wasn’t to start a fight or play gotcha, was honestly just looking for your thoughts.  

 
i don't really think that individual privacy has been suggested as an impetus for this move at any point.  it is because the U.S. government doesn't want China to have information that could give them more power.  Individual rights have #### all to do with it and I don't think that anyone is claiming otherwise.
It has.  They are.  Sounds like you're buying their bogus rationale for shutting down a legitimate tech application.  

Americans should download the app “only if you want your private information in the hands of the Chinese Communist Party,” Pompeo suggested during the interview.

It's dangerous, tons of Americans left/right/center are going along with Trump's war on China.  

 
Shouldn't capitalism take care of this?  Why does the government need to get involved?
capitalism doesn't mean ZERO government control/oversight/whatever, especially when it comes to foreign governments tracking US Citizens.

Even companies ban malware/spyware/virusware and the like from their platforms.  Think of it as the US Government banning spyware.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
https://www.yahoo.com/news/trump-wants-u-cut-tiktok-152002871.html
 

This is absolutely mind blowing to me.  Would love some thoughts from the pro-T crowd.  @Opie @BladeRunner @HellToupee  @TripItUp  Thanks fellas.  
My thoughts are that if they want to ban Tik-Tok - fine.  He has that oversight and power to do that.  Not sure I care enough because, personally, all social media is evil to me.  So the more we can get rid of, the better.

As far as getting a cut - not sure that's any of their business.  Don't see how that fits in line with his seeing Tik-Tok as essentially spyware.   So, it's okay to use as long as the US gets a cut?  Is that what he is saying?  If so, that's not cool or any of the governments business (aside from taxes, of course).

 
  • Laughing
Reactions: rct
It has.  They are.  Sounds like you're buying their bogus rationale for shutting down a legitimate tech application.  

Americans should download the app “only if you want your private information in the hands of the Chinese Communist Party,” Pompeo suggested during the interview.

It's dangerous, tons of Americans left/right/center are going along with Trump's war on China.  
i'm not buying anything.  I'm just telling you what I have seen people saying.  And even in those tweets, I think that it is closer to not wanting the Chinese to have the info rather than just generally not wanting the info to be tracked.  

If there is a message that somehow if the company is owned by Americans then the data is actually "safe" and helping people keep your privacy, then I certainly agree with you that it is highly disingenuous. 

 
My thoughts are that if they want to ban Tik-Tok - fine.  He has that oversight and power to do that.  Not sure I care enough because, personally, all social media is evil to me.  So the more we can get rid of, the better.

As far as getting a cut - not sure that's any of their business.  Don't see how that fits in line with his seeing Tik-Tok as essentially spyware.   So, it's okay to use as long as the US gets a cut?  Is that what he is saying?  If so, that's not cool or any of the governments business (aside from taxes, of course).
Thanks. Yeah as far as tiktok itself and if it gets banned or not I couldn’t care less. I don’t have a social media presence and believe it’s a corner stone to a lot of societal problems today.

But from what I gather Trump is trying to do here is that he saying because he, the treasury dept., is facilitating the deal they should get a large cut of the deal. There’s issues with this on multiple levels in my opinion, starting with the fact he’s forcing the deal to happen on treat of banning it.   Etc etc etc.  

 
Thanks. Yeah as far as tiktok itself and if it gets banned or not I couldn’t care less. I don’t have a social media presence and believe it’s a corner stone to a lot of societal problems today.

But from what I gather Trump is trying to do here is that he saying because he, the treasury dept., is facilitating the deal they should get a large cut of the deal. There’s issues with this on multiple levels in my opinion, starting with the fact he’s forcing the deal to happen on treat of banning it.   Etc etc etc.  
i agree.  The only thing the Government needs to be involved in is the taxes coming from the sale of Tik-Tok to Microsoft.  Nothing else. 

 
The irony of the US acting like champions of individual privacy is too much to bear.  They’ve been fine to sell us down the river to big tech, to collect phone calls and internet traffic.  Notice that it’s acceptable for Microsoft to assume control of the ‘malware’ app.  

The US govt is a far greater threat with this data than China.  They’ve been spying on Americans and targeting civil dissidents for years.  I don’t see what the operative difference is supposed to be between Facebook and TikTok.  This is about ratcheting up tensions with China. 
This goes right along with what you're talking about.

Hundreds of apps have hidden tracking software used by the government

 
  • Thinking
Reactions: rct
Long Ball Larry said:
If there is a message that somehow if the company is owned by Americans then the data is actually "safe" and helping people keep your privacy, then I certainly agree with you that it is highly disingenuous. 
This.  American digital privacy laws are so lax they may as well not exist at all.  We'd be much better if is this data was collected by members of the EU subject to GDPR.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I was on a work call this morning, joining a weekly project call for the first time.  All other participants were native mandarin speakers, so they had about 15 mins chit chatting in Chinese before they got down to business.  They didn't notice that I had joined, so I didn't interupt to introduce myself.  It was a mix of people from my company (some based in China, some in USA, and a supplier in China).

I definitely heard them talking about WeChat and having to remove it from their phones, and discussing using VPNs.  I wish I would have recorded it and asked a mandarin speaker to translate for me...

I bet they were wondering if they could use their personal phones to continue to use WeChat over VPN even if it gets banned in the USA.  Definitely heard the word Whatsapp once or twice too.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Whether you like social media or hate it, useTikTok or not is irrelevant. In no way should that impact anyone's thoughts here because next time, it could be something you do like and use. 
Also, he's "banning" TikTok for revenge, not for national security. That should give everyone pause, and just one more reason why we need this wanna-be dictator out.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top