rockaction
Footballguy
Oh, (eta* now) I get what you're saying. I was thinking you're talking about movies as an art form, not the Spidey movies.Accept it or don't but the movies are not canon. They even screw up the canon stories they try to tell. Especially the Spidey Franchise. Sony has mucked up that completely and what Fox did to the X-Men is a close second.I don't accept the premise, but that's fine. Not sure making a deal with the devil to save a loved one counts as ambiguous. It counts as showing that as humans, sometimes we're faced with nearly impossible moral choices, like Noah and his son.Really the movies aren't canon. Spidey did strike a deal with a demon to save Aunt May that erased his marriage to Mary Jane. He has also deliberately killed several times. A couple he was pretty nonchalant about.Spider Man, off the top of my head. Really, the worst thing Spider Man ever did because was become ambiguous in Spider Man III.regarding fla\/\/ed antiheros vs Superman types --
I agree strongly with Chaka's point that way too often having things be morally polarizing in delivery made for pretty juvenile entertainment. Maybe it was just a coincidence paired with crappy writing everywhere, but I don't think so. There's a reason show like the Sopranos and Breaking Bad have been so wildly successful in the past 15 years -- Having characters who you want to relate to but also act repulsively sometimes is inherently more interesting. It provides richer material and more thought provoking situations for stories to be written around.
For those who disagree, what are your examples for Good/Evil storytelling that is as captivating as the shows I've mentioned?
But your presumption is that we need a retelling of good and evil. Maybe those with the most creative impulses are doubtful and proficient in a doubtful age. It sort of begs the question.
eta* Actually, now that I think about it, that's why I love non-fiction and docs. There is heroism in our world, and heroic types, but our creatives can't, won't, or more importantly, aren't equipped to address it properly or subtly, IMO. Breaking Bad and the Sopranos -- I watched Season One of each -- bore the #### out of me. I have no ethical/moral problems with them, they just do.
eta2* Back To The Future, Groundhog Day, The Untouchables, etc.
To your point about television, Terriers was an exceptional story about redemption and good. And I'd honestly put that show as my favorite of the past fifteen years.
I didn't think I was talking television but Terriers wasn't bad. Although it's as much a comedy as anything.
Point taken.
But, at the risk of a declarative, Terriers was not a comedy. Those were formerly flawed characters -- but redemptive and good at the point we got to watch them -- caught up in a neo-noir. Watched it start to finish, am familiar with the genre, and that's how it struck me.
Last edited by a moderator: