Week 11 2025 who should I start thread **OFFICIALLY UNOFFICIAL** (10 Viewers)

[Chaka]

Thanks for encouraging me to start TreVeyon last week!

Now, with Rhamondre just now officially ruled out, should I go with Henderson again tomorrow night vs NYJ, or Jaylen Warren in the extremely favorable vs CIN matchup?

League is PPR

I am in a similar boat here. Came to ask in .5ppr start two:

Warren vs CIN
Hendy vs NYJ
Judkins vs BAL

Warren>Henderson>Judkins

I may like Juds the most as a RB but, that offense is turrible.

 

[Chaka]

Add/Drop queestion.

I think it's fair to say the JCM experiment is, to be nice, on hold. I plan to drop him (redraft) and I am debating between Chris Rodriguez, who logged a full practice today so, he's on track to start against the Dolphins and George Kittle (we combine WR & TE in this PPR league).

Would anyone start Rodriguez (@ MIA) or Kittle (@ ARI) over ETN v LAC?

 

[-OZ-]

Ppr need one
Mack Hollins vs the jets
Calvin Ridley vs Texans
Keon Coleman vs the Bucs
Leaning Mack


Ppr need 2 (yes, this could be flexing a kicker)
Troy Franklin vs chiefs
Jake bates vs eagles
Will Reichard vs bears

Third league, ppr
Tiny pollard vs Texans
JCM in Miami
Demarcado vs 49ers

 

[-OZ-]

Add/Drop queestion.

I think it's fair to say the JCM experiment is, to be nice, on hold. I plan to drop him (redraft) and I am debating between Chris Rodriguez, who logged a full practice today so, he's on track to start against the Dolphins and George Kittle (we combine WR & TE in this PPR league).

Would anyone start Rodriguez (@ MIA) or Kittle (@ ARI) over ETN v LAC?

The jags need ETN and I think he’ll get his. It’s tough to bench kittle but I think ETN

 

[kyoun1e]

Defense question. Originally thought this was a slam dunk to go with ATL but now not so sure. Had picked up KC to block my opponent.

* ATL D vs CAR -- ATL D has had six and seven sacks respectively the last two games. Put a lot of pressure on the QB. Strong pass rush, decent secondary. However, they are getting GASHED on the ground. J. Taylor went nuts last week. And guess what CAR likes to do? Run Rico. I'm starting to wonder if CAR throws more than 20 times.

* KC D @Den -- KC a better real life D than fantasy. Decent everywhere, but not particularly great anywhere. Fantasy stats are mediocre. That said, this is a must win game for KC and the Denver O and Bo Nix looked miserable last week. Don't think Dobbins being out is going to help their cause.

* CHI D @MN -- CHI secondary is fiesty. Has 13 INTs. Can put decent pressure on the QB and McCarthy has looked more than shaky. He's also had his moments. Don't love the CHI D here on the road, but if McCarthy continues to have trouble Chicago could take advantage.

Which?

Thanks

 

[jobarules]

0.5 ppr

Jamo vs Philly
Addison vs chi

Yes, I know jamo has been better the last 2 weeks but has the tougher matchup. Still feel its hard to sit him right now but hes due for a 0.

 

[LionOfGosforth]

non-ppr

Just need one from the following:

Jamo vs Eagles
Flowers @ Browns
Judkins vs Ravens
KW3 @ Rams

Normally I go Judkins but their offense has been pretty putrid. Just picked Jamo up after his owner dropped him last week but he kinda scares me, as likely to put up 0 as he is 100/1.

Thanks

 

[Chaka]

Ppr need one
Mack Hollins vs the jets
Calvin Ridley vs Texans
Keon Coleman vs the Bucs
Leaning Mack


Ppr need 2 (yes, this could be flexing a kicker)
Troy Franklin vs chiefs
Jake bates vs eagles
Will Reichard vs bears

Third league, ppr
Tiny pollard vs Texans
JCM in Miami
Demarcado vs 49ers

Hollins does this every year. He suddenly looks like a true WR1 then he goes and communes with nature for the next six weeks.

But, you don't have any clearly better options so

Hollins>Coleman>Ridley
========================================

I start Franklin just because he is seeing the targets and, IMO opportunity is king in magic football. Between the two kickers, flip a coin. Bates is on the better offense by a good margin so that is probably where I lean.

Franklin>Bates>Reichard
======================================

Demarcado is playing the best of the three by a good margin. I don't love his opportunity share but, I feel the same about the other two.

Demarcado>Pollard>JMC

 

[Chaka]

Defense question. Originally thought this was a slam dunk to go with ATL but now not so sure. Had picked up KC to block my opponent.

* ATL D vs CAR -- ATL D has had six and seven sacks respectively the last two games. Put a lot of pressure on the QB. Strong pass rush, decent secondary. However, they are getting GASHED on the ground. J. Taylor went nuts last week. And guess what CAR likes to do? Run Rico. I'm starting to wonder if CAR throws more than 20 times.

* KC D @Den -- KC a better real life D than fantasy. Decent everywhere, but not particularly great anywhere. Fantasy stats are mediocre. That said, this is a must win game for KC and the Denver O and Bo Nix looked miserable last week. Don't think Dobbins being out is going to help their cause.

* CHI D @MN -- CHI secondary is fiesty. Has 13 INTs. Can put decent pressure on the QB and McCarthy has looked more than shaky. He's also had his moments. Don't love the CHI D here on the road, but if McCarthy continues to have trouble Chicago could take advantage.

Which?

Thanks

I still go with the ATL defense because they get after the QB so well and the Panthers have one of the worst starting QBs in the league. Plus, they're at home and desperate for a win.

I guess I go with CHI next because JJ has looked so shaky but, I don't think they're a particularly good defense.

KC is a good IRL defense but, DEN can run well enough, pass well enough and score well enough to prevent any big bonus production from defensive scoring. Nix also has the best sack rate in the league. It's difficult to get to him before he gets rid of the ball.

ATL>CHI>KC

 

[Chaka]

0.5 ppr

Jamo vs Philly
Addison vs chi

Yes, I know jamo has been better the last 2 weeks but has the tougher matchup. Still feel its hard to sit him right now but hes due for a 0.

Addison has the target upside and, maybe the higher floor but, Jameson has a significantly better QB and is on a significantly better offense. He has been great in three of his last four games (with a zero in between).

Addison is a fine choice, maybe even a safer one but, for me

Jamo>Addison

 

[Chaka]

non-ppr

Just need one from the following:

Jamo vs Eagles
Flowers @ Browns
Judkins vs Ravens
KW3 @ Rams

Normally I go Judkins but their offense has been pretty putrid. Just picked Jamo up after his owner dropped him last week but he kinda scares me, as likely to put up 0 as he is 100/1.

Thanks

Non PPR I rule out Flowers and, frankly KWIII has been very uninspiring and, he hasn't broken 100 yards or scored a TD in the last five games. He is now facing the #2 scoring defense in the league.

Judkins will see plenty of volume, is probably your safest option and, has TD upside even on this terrible offense.

Jamo is on the best offense, has the best QB and is, maybe the 3rd option for defenses to focus on. He has also been on a very solid run over the last four games. Personally, he is who I would start (remember I am an unabashed Jamo fan boy) but, I can see the smart move being

Judkins>Jamo>Flowers>KWIII

 

[amnesiac]

i may just be a disgruntled Browns fan, but while Judkins passes the eyeball test for me, this offense is just dysfunctional right now.

personally i'm not starting Judkins unless i have to.

especially if the Browns are playing anyone with a decent offense.

 

[amnesiac]

OK, i was laughed at a bit a few weeks ago for asking this question, but Mahomes looked very human at Buffalo. (and Herbert lit up Tennessee)

this week he has to go to Denver. (albeit off of a bye)

Herbert didn't look good against Pittsburgh, but goes to Jacksonville this week.

any opinions on

Mahomes AT Denver

or

Herbert AT Jacksonville

 

[Payne]

PPR league

QB:
Caleb @ Min
Darnold @ LAR

I really have no idea where to go here. Caleb does very well against mid and bad defenses but, Minnesota is desperate for a win and, their D can definitely rise to the occasion. I tentatively lean towards Darnold.

Interesting reading all the replies. I have this exact decision and I never even considered Darnold. It was Caleb from the start.
Now I am reconsidering. Also have Purdy available on waivers.

 

[jobarules]

0.5 ppr

Need a rb2 out of these scrubs

Chris Rodriguez vs Mia
Jordan mason vs bears
Pollard/Spears vs Hou

Yikes

 

[Rubi]

OK, i was laughed at a bit a few weeks ago for asking this question, but Mahomes looked very human at Buffalo. (and Herbert lit up Tennessee)

this week he has to go to Denver. (albeit off of a bye)

Herbert didn't look good against Pittsburgh, but goes to Jacksonville this week.

any opinions on

Mahomes AT Denver

or

Herbert AT Jacksonville

I can make a case for either
I have them pretty close this week,especially if Gadsen plays
Hard to bench Patrick in a big division matchup
His game should be close all day
If The Chargers have a lead in the fourth quarter you know Harbaugh will pound it on the ground
So maybe Patrick gets the edge in pass attempts
So based on that...Patrick

 

[Rubi]

0.5 ppr

Need a rb2 out of these scrubs

Chris Rodriguez vs Mia
Jordan mason vs bears
Pollard/Spears vs Hou

Yikes

Pollard/Spears
and I lean Spears