Week 15 2025 who should I start thread **OFFICIALLY UNOFFICIAL** (5 Viewers)

[kface]

A little late to ask here but... Pick 2

Monangai
Singletary
Addison
Spears

Leaning the top 2...

I like Monangai and Singletary (I like the td potential)

Addison just seems on the outs and pollard coming off a huge game

 

[SaintsInDome2006]

Pick 2, 0.5 ppr: Judkins @ Chi, Hampton @ KC, or Tracy Vs Was

Pick 1 QB2, 6pt TD: Williams Vs Cle, or McCarthy @ Dal.

TIA

Judkins and Tracy pretty easily. They will both see more volume (IMO) than Hampton and have better matchups.

Judkins>Tracy>Hampton
================================

Tough call on QB. I think Caleb is better but, he isn't prolific. You have to hope for one of his boom games. JJ is less prolific than Caleb. Nice he threw three TDs against WAS but, can we count on that? Hmmmm... I guess I go with the upside play

Caleb>JJ

Buddy, I’m going with this. Godspeed today & good luck to your teams!

 

[Chaka]

Pick one in PPR

Deebo @ NYG
Judkins @ CHI
Neal v CAR

Judkins and his 20 opportunities then Deebo with no Ertz

Judkins>Deebo>Neal

 

[Chaka]

Worthy, BTJ, or Iosivas 1/2 ppr.

BTJ for the upside

 

[Chaka]

Need a flex in a 16 team PPR TEP IDP
• Hunter Henry Vs BUF
or
• Jordan Addison At DAL

Addison nursing an Achilles, but I love the matchup.

Henry currently in my flex spot - it’s TEP, and Pitts is my TE1.

@Chaka

Oh. Tough call but Henry has been such a safety valve for Maye and it's a good matchup.

I could go either way but, I don't trust JJ and I do trust Maye and it's TEP

Henry>Addison

 

[Chaka]

Dart with a great matchup vs. Washington (but will he run?) or Burrow at home? Do I dare start Dart over Burrow in the playoffs?
Running TDs are 6 points while passing are 4.
Thanks!

Burrow.

It's Burrow

 

[kface]

Need a flex in a 16 team PPR TEP IDP
• Hunter Henry Vs BUF
or
• Jordan Addison At DAL

Addison nursing an Achilles, but I love the matchup.

Henry currently in my flex spot - it’s TEP, and Pitts is my TE1.

@Chaka

Oh. Tough call but Henry has been such a safety valve for Maye and it's a good matchup.

I could go either way but, I don't trust JJ and I do trust Maye and it's TEP

Henry>Addison

agree

Sit back and think about what the best case scenario for Minn with JJ at qb - maybe 250 yards? There isn't enough passing to go around...HH coming off a huge game

 

[Chaka]

Devin Neal, Javonte, or Swift full PPR

Swift>Javonte>Neal

 

[xxxFTWxxx]

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

no one answered mine. Booooo

I would go with Diggs. Monangai a close second.

 

[Chaka]

Feels crazy to ask, but Playoffs, so here we are.

Dak vs a tough MIN defense
Mariotta vs a bad NYG defnese.

Still Dak IMO. It's just such a better offense than Washington.

Dak>MAR-ee-OH-tah

 

[Chaka]

1/2 point ppr and i have two tough ones in a must win week

Travis Etienne vs Javante Williams

Lean Etienne but worried Tuten steals the td and the game gets away from the Jets

Pick 2 of 3

Justin Jefferson/Aj Brown/Jamo

ETN IMO. I think he's in line for a lot of work. Tuten could see 15 touches too but, ETN will eat first.

Javonte is fine if your gut says to go with him.

ETN>Javonte

 

[Chaka]

Need flex PPR

Pittman @ Sea
McConkey @ KC
Swift Vs Cle

Swift>Pittman>Ladd

 

[Chaka]

A little late to ask here but... Pick 2

Monangai
Singletary
Addison
Spears

Leaning the top 2...

Way too late to be asking.

Monangai>Addison>Singletary>Spears

 

[Dez]

Going to ask the same question I asked a few weeks ago but this is tougher with all of them having tougher matchups

Need 3 of the 4 guys in a full PPR (1 point all positions)

Michael Wilson at Hou
Waddle at Pitt
McBride at Hou
Bowers at Phil

WIsh I had just played Evans damn this team is loaded but sure sucks for lineup calls each week.

At RB same league need 1 between Henderson or Judkins

Oh, no. Please. I'm not sure I can handle this after last time.

But, let's do it anyway

Still Wilson and his 15 target potential in PPR. Definitely Bowers because, don't bet against Bowers...ever.

Between Waddle and McBride... geez I'm not sure you want that much of Houston but, it's PPR and Waddle probably has 7-8 target potential and McBride has 10+

Wilson>Bowers>McBride>Waddle

I had Bowers on the bench but just put him in and took out Waddle.

The "experts" at ESPN have Waddle much higher than Wilson (like 12 to 19) and FBG says I should sit Bowers has Waddle 39 flex and Bowers 59 flex

My gut is Bowers does little vs Philly

That said I giving you a chance to redeem yourself last time my mistake didn't cost me anything this time it would as we are playing for the $250K now.

Bowers is in Waddle is out

 

[Chaka]

Pick 2, 0.5 ppr: Judkins @ Chi, Hampton @ KC, or Tracy Vs Was

Pick 1 QB2, 6pt TD: Williams Vs Cle, or McCarthy @ Dal.

TIA

Judkins and Tracy pretty easily. They will both see more volume (IMO) than Hampton and have better matchups.

Judkins>Tracy>Hampton
================================

Tough call on QB. I think Caleb is better but, he isn't prolific. You have to hope for one of his boom games. JJ is less prolific than Caleb. Nice he threw three TDs against WAS but, can we count on that? Hmmmm... I guess I go with the upside play

Caleb>JJ

Buddy, I’m going with this. Godspeed today & good luck to your teams!

I'm happy to be your excuse if things go sideways.

Good luck.

 

[Chaka]

Going to ask the same question I asked a few weeks ago but this is tougher with all of them having tougher matchups

Need 3 of the 4 guys in a full PPR (1 point all positions)

Michael Wilson at Hou
Waddle at Pitt
McBride at Hou
Bowers at Phil

WIsh I had just played Evans damn this team is loaded but sure sucks for lineup calls each week.

At RB same league need 1 between Henderson or Judkins

Oh, no. Please. I'm not sure I can handle this after last time.

But, let's do it anyway

Still Wilson and his 15 target potential in PPR. Definitely Bowers because, don't bet against Bowers...ever.

Between Waddle and McBride... geez I'm not sure you want that much of Houston but, it's PPR and Waddle probably has 7-8 target potential and McBride has 10+

Wilson>Bowers>McBride>Waddle

I had Bowers on the bench but just put him in and took out Waddle.

The "experts" at ESPN have Waddle much higher than Wilson (like 12 to 19) and FBG says I should sit Bowers has Waddle 39 flex and Bowers 59 flex

My gut is Bowers does little vs Philly

That said I giving you a chance to redeem yourself last time my mistake didn't cost me anything this time it would as we are playing for the $250K now.

Bowers is in Waddle is out

I get what the "experts" think but, benching Bowers regardless of situation just seems dangerous.

Good luck to me, I like a good redemption story.

 

[Chaka]

Now, go away you degenerates. I have one minute to get my own lineup in thanks to you guys.

 

[DA RAIDERS]

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

no one answered mine. Booooo

I think I would stubbornly roll Jacobs.

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

with Jacobs expected to play, go him.

I fully expect it to be an ugly, defensive, grind it out game. Jacobs should see plenty of volume if he's active.

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

I think Judkins and his likely 20 touches. He hasn't been great but, he is the Browns run game and the Bears D aren't world beaters.

I like Monangai because the Bears run more than anyone.

I'm spooked enough about Jacobs's knee that I would go

Judkins>Monangai>Jacobs>Diggs

Diggs is an interesting case but, his floor is so low that I don't think I could risk it personally. If you really need a BOOM play then, maybe I would run with him and cross my fingers.

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

no one answered mine. Booooo

I would go with Diggs. Monangai a close second.

Stubbornly went with Jacobs. Just couldn’t look at 2 browns in my starting lineup (Fannin). Diggs will probably go off since he was initially in my line up.

Good luck everyone! Thanks for the all the different answers.

 

[Chaka]

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

no one answered mine. Booooo

I think I would stubbornly roll Jacobs.

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

with Jacobs expected to play, go him.

I fully expect it to be an ugly, defensive, grind it out game. Jacobs should see plenty of volume if he's active.

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

I think Judkins and his likely 20 touches. He hasn't been great but, he is the Browns run game and the Bears D aren't world beaters.

I like Monangai because the Bears run more than anyone.

I'm spooked enough about Jacobs's knee that I would go

Judkins>Monangai>Jacobs>Diggs

Diggs is an interesting case but, his floor is so low that I don't think I could risk it personally. If you really need a BOOM play then, maybe I would run with him and cross my fingers.

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

no one answered mine. Booooo

I would go with Diggs. Monangai a close second.

Stubbornly went with Jacobs. Just couldn’t look at 2 browns in my starting lineup (Fannin). Diggs will probably go off since he was initially in my line up.

Good luck everyone! Thanks for the all the different answers.

It's not stubborn at all. It's Josh Jacobs, he always has multi TD upside.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Need a flex in a 16 team PPR TEP IDP
• Hunter Henry Vs BUF
or
• Jordan Addison At DAL

Addison nursing an Achilles, but I love the matchup.

Henry currently in my flex spot - it’s TEP, and Pitts is my TE1.

@Chaka

Oh. Tough call but Henry has been such a safety valve for Maye and it's a good matchup.

I could go either way but, I don't trust JJ and I do trust Maye and it's TEP

Henry>Addison

agree

Sit back and think about what the best case scenario for Minn with JJ at qb - maybe 250 yards? There isn't enough passing to go around...HH coming off a huge game

That’s also the league I have a 62 point Pitts in, so the priority of my last flex spot isn’t as critical to my outcome as it was when I initially posed this question.

 

[Dez]

Going to ask the same question I asked a few weeks ago but this is tougher with all of them having tougher matchups

Need 3 of the 4 guys in a full PPR (1 point all positions)

Michael Wilson at Hou
Waddle at Pitt
McBride at Hou
Bowers at Phil

WIsh I had just played Evans damn this team is loaded but sure sucks for lineup calls each week.

At RB same league need 1 between Henderson or Judkins

Oh, no. Please. I'm not sure I can handle this after last time.

But, let's do it anyway

Still Wilson and his 15 target potential in PPR. Definitely Bowers because, don't bet against Bowers...ever.

Between Waddle and McBride... geez I'm not sure you want that much of Houston but, it's PPR and Waddle probably has 7-8 target potential and McBride has 10+

Wilson>Bowers>McBride>Waddle

I should left my lineup alone as I set it last night

Put in Bowers over Waddle at 12:50 PM
Worst yet I put in Judkins over Henderson at 12:54 PM

Stupid rankings caused me to sit Henderson everyone had him lower brutal beyond brutal considering what ETN, Chase, McBride did for me today

Sucks rankings suck I hate them

 

[Chaka]

Gotta apologize to all my brothers and sister for recommending Judkins and Burrow so much this week.

I stand by my logic but, oooooooooooooooooofff.

 

[DA RAIDERS]

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

no one answered mine. Booooo

I think I would stubbornly roll Jacobs.

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

with Jacobs expected to play, go him.

I fully expect it to be an ugly, defensive, grind it out game. Jacobs should see plenty of volume if he's active.

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

I think Judkins and his likely 20 touches. He hasn't been great but, he is the Browns run game and the Bears D aren't world beaters.

I like Monangai because the Bears run more than anyone.

I'm spooked enough about Jacobs's knee that I would go

Judkins>Monangai>Jacobs>Diggs

Diggs is an interesting case but, his floor is so low that I don't think I could risk it personally. If you really need a BOOM play then, maybe I would run with him and cross my fingers.

Here’s a tricky one:
Jacobs. Would be a no brainer, but that knee and that Denver d
Diggs against his old team
Or a flyer on monangai/corum/judkins

Currently have diggs in the line up

Standard ppr

no one answered mine. Booooo

I would go with Diggs. Monangai a close second.

Stubbornly went with Jacobs. Just couldn’t look at 2 browns in my starting lineup (Fannin). Diggs will probably go off since he was initially in my line up.

Good luck everyone! Thanks for the all the different answers.

It's not stubborn at all. It's Josh Jacobs, he always has multi TD upside.

So far so good. up 21 with Boswell left, against gainwell

 

[Bad_Mo2]

Flex player in a PPR, bonus for 100 yards rush/rec. Special scoring for TEs but Gadsden is firmly with *** on my bench.

DK Metcalf v. MIA
Aaron Jones @ DAL


AND...

Def ST choice between MIA (@ PIT) or LAR (v. DET)? thanks

I think I go with DK. He's on a one game hot streak in a decent matchup and, still an important game for the Steelers.

DK>AJ
================================
I understand the thought of the Dolphins but, the Rams are just a far superior defensive unit. Tough matchup but, defenses are random number generators so, I go with the best unit.

Thanks...always appreciate another perspective.

I went with Miami instead of LAR for DST. LAR scored me 1 point so hoping MIA does better than that. Went with DK over Jones so I'm hoping PIT has to throw and chase some points. Down 13 and he is done. Not counting the chickens yet...

 

[Dez]

Going to ask the same question I asked a few weeks ago but this is tougher with all of them having tougher matchups

Need 3 of the 4 guys in a full PPR (1 point all positions)

Michael Wilson at Hou
Waddle at Pitt
McBride at Hou
Bowers at Phil

WIsh I had just played Evans damn this team is loaded but sure sucks for lineup calls each week.

At RB same league need 1 between Henderson or Judkins

Oh, no. Please. I'm not sure I can handle this after last time.

But, let's do it anyway

Still Wilson and his 15 target potential in PPR. Definitely Bowers because, don't bet against Bowers...ever.

Between Waddle and McBride... geez I'm not sure you want that much of Houston but, it's PPR and Waddle probably has 7-8 target potential and McBride has 10+

Wilson>Bowers>McBride>Waddle

For the record you got it right to sit Waddle but you got the order wrong McBride was the #1 boss this week

The one that murdered me is my switching Henderson out to Judkins last minute but you did get the call right sit Waddle on this one

 

[Chaka]

Going to ask the same question I asked a few weeks ago but this is tougher with all of them having tougher matchups

Need 3 of the 4 guys in a full PPR (1 point all positions)

Michael Wilson at Hou
Waddle at Pitt
McBride at Hou
Bowers at Phil

WIsh I had just played Evans damn this team is loaded but sure sucks for lineup calls each week.

At RB same league need 1 between Henderson or Judkins

Oh, no. Please. I'm not sure I can handle this after last time.

But, let's do it anyway

Still Wilson and his 15 target potential in PPR. Definitely Bowers because, don't bet against Bowers...ever.

Between Waddle and McBride... geez I'm not sure you want that much of Houston but, it's PPR and Waddle probably has 7-8 target potential and McBride has 10+

Wilson>Bowers>McBride>Waddle

For the record you got it right to sit Waddle but you got the order wrong McBride was the #1 boss this week

The one that murdered me is my switching Henderson out to Judkins last minute but you did get the call right sit Waddle on this one

You need to trust the process. Starting Henderson over Judkins, on its surface didn't make sense. Judkins was in line for 20 touches, or more against a bad run defense. His efficiency has been bad since his hot start but, he was the volume play.

There was every reason Rhamondre, who saw a 67% snap share to 48% for Henderson, would see more than 9 touches.

It didn't break well but, your process was still right