What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Week 8 who should I start thread **OFFICIAL** (1 Viewer)

Jones vs KC or Wentz vs TEN as a potential Dak replacement?

Dak is looking like a GTD so Jones is nice cause he plays Monday. Or I could just go with Wentz and forget about it 
I lean Wentz, he's been playing well and has a higher floor than Jones. It's a big home game and the Titans just came off two big home wins but I still see the Titans as a bipolar team. Either way I think this is a good game for Wentz.

Wentz>Jones

 
Between the two DJ is very interesting. Lindsay has out carried DJ but DJ is better with his carries and is unquestionably the receiving back. With Ingram gone you have to imagine he starts and sees an increase in carries.

I have no idea how to predict Gainwell. He has a better chance of finding the end zone and should see an increase in touches. But I simply don't trust Siriani.

DJ>Gainwell


Yea, initially I thought Gainwell was a lock this week but there are a lot of red flags (game flow, competition, coaching) where I could see him being a dud this week unless he catches a TD. 

 
D question. Think many are toiling with this selection (including myself):

* SF D @CHI -- No Nagy (although that may be an improvement). Fields doesn't look ready. O line vs. SF Dline could be a problem. Could see potential for ceiling here due to rookie mistakes and also can't imagine CHI is putting up a ton of points. That said, CHI could run on this D and mitigate some of their offensive risk.

OR

* PIT D @CLE -- Mayfield, Chubb, and Landry in. Gotta think they run the hell out of the ball here after seeing what A. Collins did to this D a couple weeks ago. This feels like a 20-17 type game. Probably a solid floor, but not sure about ceiing. 

Which?

Thanks

 
D question. Think many are toiling with this selection (including myself):

* SF D @CHI -- No Nagy (although that may be an improvement). Fields doesn't look ready. O line vs. SF Dline could be a problem. Could see potential for ceiling here due to rookie mistakes and also can't imagine CHI is putting up a ton of points. That said, CHI could run on this D and mitigate some of their offensive risk.

OR

* PIT D @CLE -- Mayfield, Chubb, and Landry in. Gotta think they run the hell out of the ball here after seeing what A. Collins did to this D a couple weeks ago. This feels like a 20-17 type game. Probably a solid floor, but not sure about ceiing. 

Which?

Thanks


Hard lean to SF.  Much higher ceiling which is what you want in a D.

 
D question. Think many are toiling with this selection (including myself):

* SF D @CHI -- No Nagy (although that may be an improvement). Fields doesn't look ready. O line vs. SF Dline could be a problem. Could see potential for ceiling here due to rookie mistakes and also can't imagine CHI is putting up a ton of points. That said, CHI could run on this D and mitigate some of their offensive risk.

OR

* PIT D @CLE -- Mayfield, Chubb, and Landry in. Gotta think they run the hell out of the ball here after seeing what A. Collins did to this D a couple weeks ago. This feels like a 20-17 type game. Probably a solid floor, but not sure about ceiing. 

Which?

Thanks
Defense are ultimately random number generators.

I like the thinking about Chicago, but put no merit in Nagy missing the game.

I don't think Cleveland is as healthy as they want people to think but they should still be better on offense pretty much across the board.

It really is a coin flip but I'm okay with

SF>Pit

 
Rolling with Toney at flex in PPR if he plays but it's a Monday night game so I'm looking for some input.

1) I could play it safe and start McKissic at flex (already starting Gibson at RB)

2) Start TY Hilton if he plays (already starting Pittman)

3) Drop Hilton and pickup Slayton as insurance for Toney for MNF*

I'm about a 15-20 point underdog this week so I'm looking for some upside which is why I was going to roll with Toney.

*I've got Gallup on IR and figure I will have to activate him next week and drop Hilton anyway.

ETA: Just reading some NFL trade rumors and it's possible that the Giants could look to trade Engram and Slayton. Makes the move for Slayton a little more enticing to see what happens.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
PPR

TY Hilton or Ricky Seals-Jones
Seals looks like the safer play and he has a bit of upside too. More targets and in on the injury report.

Love TY but can't see it after a one & done two weeks ago.

Seals>Hilton

 
D question. Think many are toiling with this selection (including myself):

* SF D @CHI -- No Nagy (although that may be an improvement). Fields doesn't look ready. O line vs. SF Dline could be a problem. Could see potential for ceiling here due to rookie mistakes and also can't imagine CHI is putting up a ton of points. That said, CHI could run on this D and mitigate some of their offensive risk.

OR

* PIT D @CLE -- Mayfield, Chubb, and Landry in. Gotta think they run the hell out of the ball here after seeing what A. Collins did to this D a couple weeks ago. This feels like a 20-17 type game. Probably a solid floor, but not sure about ceiing. 

Which?

Thanks
Note the injury report for the SF Defense

Azeez Al-Shaair LB Out
Samson Ebukam DE Questionable
Dee Ford DE Out
Maurice Hurst DT Out
Javon Kinlaw DT IR
Jaquiski Tartt S IR
 

vs Pittsburgh 

Melvin Ingram LB Out

Cleveland offense is much better than Chicago offense, so that might accrue in favor of SF.  But if the Bears are able to run on SF then not much opportunity for sacks and turnovers.

 
Rolling with Toney at flex in PPR if he plays but it's a Monday night game so I'm looking for some input.

1) I could play it safe and start McKissic at flex (already starting Gibson at RB)

2) Start TY Hilton if he plays (already starting Pittman)

3) Drop Hilton and pickup Slayton as insurance for Toney for MNF*

I'm about a 15-20 point underdog this week so I'm looking for some upside which is why I was going to roll with Toney.

*I've got Gallup on IR and figure I will have to activate him next week and drop Hilton anyway.
I don't like McKissic with your other options. Too much downside and you already have Gibson rolling.

Pittman>>Hilton too.

Slayton seems like the smart move here, imo.

 
Pick 1 WR / 3 Flex - .25 PPR

Pretty much made up my mind but could use second opinions in case my analysis is flawed. Going against as team devastated by byes / injuries and starting scrubs (Waller / McCaffrey, etc out). 

Toney vs KC (13) - Looks like he's going to play. Leaning towards this one for upside even though Monday Night questionable. Waddle and MIA offense got destroyed by BUF in week 2 so I have zero confidence in that matchup.

Waddle vs BUF (2nd) - Leaning towards sitting him. Don't know if I can trust Tua and MIA vs Bills considering TUA got knocked out that game and Jacoby Brisett was god awful. Don't know that they got any better since then.

Jamaal Williams vs PHI (29th) - I hate having to play this guy but the matchup is there and hopefully he gets volume.

Gordon vs Wsh (17) - Hate this split backfield.... But he scored TD last week which saved me so just hoping they do better against WSH. At least Jeudy is back so maybe they get revitalized and more scoring opportunities.

Alex Collins vs Jax (25th) - He got volume last week and goes against Jacksonville so I think it's a good volume play. His injury is concerning but same thing happened last week and he played.

Thanks!

 
Waffling between Javonte and Collins in 1/2 ppr


Collins. I have Gordon myself. I feel safer about Collins due to the better matchup and volume. Really hate Broncos 50/50 split as you're hoping for lucky TD with that low volume. They are both afternoon games so you're safe to choose Javonte if Collins doesn't play. But if he plays I think he has more volume based off prior weeks. Not like Geno Smith can win them a game. They have to run... Not sure Jags are capable of stopping them even if they know its coming.

 
Waffling between Javonte and Collins in 1/2 ppr
I love Javonte, he looks like a hammer when I see him run and he can catch.

But the bottom line is Collins is pretty decent too and he is in line for a full workload in a plus matchup and Javonte will absolutely be splitting time and WFT has been pretty solid against opposing RBs not named Kamara.

It's a boring play, one that would be tough for me to make in your situation but I it's the right decision.

Collins>Javonte

 
Pick 1 WR / 3 Flex - .25 PPR

Pretty much made up my mind but could use second opinions in case my analysis is flawed. Going against as team devastated by byes / injuries and starting scrubs (Waller / McCaffrey, etc out). 

Toney vs KC (13) - Looks like he's going to play. Leaning towards this one for upside even though Monday Night questionable. Waddle and MIA offense got destroyed by BUF in week 2 so I have zero confidence in that matchup.

Waddle vs BUF (2nd) - Leaning towards sitting him. Don't know if I can trust Tua and MIA vs Bills considering TUA got knocked out that game and Jacoby Brisett was god awful. Don't know that they got any better since then.

Jamaal Williams vs PHI (29th) - I hate having to play this guy but the matchup is there and hopefully he gets volume.

Gordon vs Wsh (17) - Hate this split backfield.... But he scored TD last week which saved me so just hoping they do better against WSH. At least Jeudy is back so maybe they get revitalized and more scoring opportunities.

Alex Collins vs Jax (25th) - He got volume last week and goes against Jacksonville so I think it's a good volume play. His injury is concerning but same thing happened last week and he played.

Thanks!
The easiest path here is to say I see Jamaal Williams as the odd man out. Zero impact since week 3, barely sees any action in the passing game. It may be a plus matchup but he doesn't appear to be a plus player.

I can see why you would be down on Waddle. I mean they got shellacked last time but Tua went down almost immediately and Waddle still got eight targets. They're going to get shellacked again but Waddle should see plenty of targets and he has enough speed and shiftiness to turn am okay game into a great one.

Collins is boring but gets volume and is home in a plus matchup.

If you were going to bench anyone other than Williams it would be Melvin. It's really just a volume situation but Williams is in the same situation and Gordon has been better with his volume.

Toney is a bit of a wild card but in your situation it seems like it's worth rolling him out. I have him and want to play my shiny new toy but I have an embarrassment of riches at the position and he's fifth on my depth chart. If there was a path I would absolutely play him.

 
heckmanm said:
0.5 PPR for WR, 1.0 PPR for TE: Robinson, K Raymond or Tyler Conklin?

(How far has Robinson fallen that it's even a question? :sadbanana:)
Its very sad, especially since Robinson probably isn't the answer. I'd go Raymond, and hope Det/Phi gets high scoring.

rschroeder1 said:
My QB options this week are:

Teddy Bridgewater vs. WFT
Tua Tagovailoa at BUF

Currently have Bridgewater slotted in for now, but I'm wondering if I'm parsing too much here.  Obviously the BUF matchup isn't great for TUA.  The reason I'm asking is I am short one roster spot for a move I'd like to make.  I appreciate anyone's insights here.
I'd go Tua here. Teddy hasn't looked good for weeks, and I'm not sure getting Jeudy back is a cure all for that, or just muddles what little production there already is. Tua on the other hand, is coming off a 4 TD game, and will likely be chasing points. He also should get Parker back. 

ignatiusjreilly said:
Looking like Toney is going to play Monday night. If he does, would you play him vs KC in a non-PPR over ESanders (vs Miami) or DSmith (vs Detroit)?
This is probably a bold call, but I really like Smith against Detroit this week. He's been soooo close to some big weeks, and the Lions have a way of getting struggling players going.

Smack Tripper said:
PPR  Pick 2

Mike Williams

Emannauel Sanders

Waddle

Higgins

also PPR pick 2

Hubbard

Mitchell

Herbert
Williams/Higgins at WR. Just think they are better players in general, so the matchup doesn't sway me much for either. Nobody is more due for a nice game than Tee Higgins.

I'd go Hubbard/Mitchell at RB. Big Herbert fan, but I think Williams could be involved a lot this week, and the other 2, don't really have volume questions. 

Flex / Standard:

A Collins vs Jax

K Gainswell @ Det

AND

Cousins vs Dal

D Jones @KC
I'd roll with Gainwell here. Collins is pretty banged up, and I could see Penny getting some more run as he gets healthier. I think Gainwell gets a crack at running away with the job in Sanders absence, but will be in danger of someone getting the hot hand if he starts slow. Ultimately, I think Philly scores more points, so I'll use that as a tiebreaker.

I'd go Cousins over Jones. I just think Cousins is very consistent and has better weapons, at the moment anyway.

Non PPR-pick 2

Kamara v TB

Henderson v HOU

Mixon v NYJ

Never bench your studs and all that...Leaning Kamara & Henderson but have gone back & forth with Mixon/Henderson. 
Man, I hate the idea of sitting Mixon against the NYJ, but I can't really argue him over Henderson or Kamara. 

Pick 3 WR - Full PPR
Justin Jefferson vs Cowboys
Jaylen Waddle at Bills
Emmanuel Sanders vs Dolphins
Tyler Lockett vs Jaguars
Jerry Jeudy vs Footballs (assuming activated off IR)
Kadarius Toney at Chiefs

I do have Daniel Jones on my bench, so if Toney was inactive I could pick up either Darius Slayton, Evan Engram or Byron Pringle to go in that spot at game time
Thanks in advance
Jefferson is obviously a lock, and I think Waddle kind of is too. I'll go a little bold here, and say Lockett against a Jags defense that constantly gets beat deep. Jags got eaten alive their last game by a very similar WR in Waddle.

Half PPR for RB:

Start A.Gibson Vs Denver 

or 

Start D.Booker Vs KC

I really am at a crossroads here, both seem close in most rankings. I'm worried about Gibson's shin but with a Wed practice and no injury designation for the first time in a while, is he closer to full health? 

Booker is facing a defense that seems to struggle to stop most RB's, If Barkley was playing then this would be a no brainer, but Is ruled out and Booker produced last week. Can he strike lightning in a bottle 2 weeks on the bounce? 
I just don't trust Gibson right now. I think Booker is a better play, and its mostly due to matchup. 

PPR league. Need a one week TE rental with M. Andrews out.

* R. Seals-Jones @DEN -- Full time TE in on all the snaps. Universally ranked as the highest flyer of the week (top 12ish). However, the DEN matchup isn't good. Held decent TEs in check including Andrews. Not many receiving options for Heinecke to throw to though.

* P. Freiermuth @CLE -- Ebron out. Looks to be coming on. Getting JuJu touches.

Note: I'm favored to win by apprx. 20 points.

Which TE?

Thanks
Tough to argue against RSJ. He's too involved in the offense to sit for me. Freiermuth may have more upside, but its hard to see him higher than 4th in the pecking order behind Harris, Johnson, and Claypool. The latter of whom was in and out before the bye with a since healed hamstring injury.

.5ppr/.5 pp first down

Need a WR2 from this mix:

Lockett v JAX
Jakobi v Chargers
Shenault v SEA
Shepard v KC
I'd go Lockett and Shepard. I think NE tries to run it down the Chargers throat and shorten the game like the Ravens did, and Sheanult just seems so randomly used that he's tough to count on. I know Lockett hasn't really done anythijg with Geno, but the matchup couldn't be better.

PPR...

Dav. Johnson or K. Gainwell or Collins?

Arob or Slayton?

Gracias!
Gainwell

This is a spot where I'd actually roll with Robinson. Slayton could easily be the #4 target for NY this week.

Jones vs KC or Wentz vs TEN as a potential Dak replacement?

Dak is looking like a GTD so Jones is nice cause he plays Monday. Or I could just go with Wentz and forget about it 
I'd go Daniel Jones over Wentz. I his matchup more, and he also gives you the option of going Dak if he plays, which you should if does. 

 
Winston or Burrow?
I think we all see the blowout looming for Cincinnati but they had three pretty easy wins against Pit, Det & Bal and Burrow threw three TDs in each game.

Winston has had two monster games and four stinkers.

Burrow is also simply the better player.

This is a question about the importance of game script. Tampa should force New Orleans to throw a lot and the Bengals could be done by halftime.

I do absolutely consider game script when I think about these things but I do believe that, unless it is an epic blowout, usually teams don't appreciably change their game plans until the fourth quarter, if then. Mac Jones threw only 10 passes in the second half when they were up 31-7. But he threw for 300 & 2 up to that point (and the Pats had another passing TD before then).

My point is a lot of points need to be scored before teams change their game plan. I still think Burrow's upside is capped but he has the higher floor by far.

My head is telling to start Burrow without hesitation. My lizard brain is tempting me with the idea that Winston will have to throw 40+ passes of New Orleans wants to stay competitive, Burrow may not hit 25. And New Orleans, with Brees, played TB very tough for most of three games last season.

Burrow if you want to be safe.

Winston if you feel you need shoot for a big score.

Me?

Winston>Burrow for no good reason.

ETA: I immediately regret that decision.

But I'll stand by it...for now.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
D question. Think many are toiling with this selection (including myself):

* SF D @CHI -- No Nagy (although that may be an improvement). Fields doesn't look ready. O line vs. SF Dline could be a problem. Could see potential for ceiling here due to rookie mistakes and also can't imagine CHI is putting up a ton of points. That said, CHI could run on this D and mitigate some of their offensive risk.

OR

* PIT D @CLE -- Mayfield, Chubb, and Landry in. Gotta think they run the hell out of the ball here after seeing what A. Collins did to this D a couple weeks ago. This feels like a 20-17 type game. Probably a solid floor, but not sure about ceiing. 

Which?

Thanks
This is maybe the trickiest one yet. I think SF is the safe play, but I like the Steelers as an upside play. I think Mayfield 100% should not be playing, and will likely hurt the team by doing so. Steelers are coming off a bye week, and smell blood in the water. I could be crazy here, but I think this could be a real statement game for Pittsburgh.

PPR

TY Hilton or Ricky Seals-Jones
I'd go Hilton as long as he's active. He seemed to be a featured part of the offense his last time on the field.

Rolling with Toney at flex in PPR if he plays but it's a Monday night game so I'm looking for some input.

1) I could play it safe and start McKissic at flex (already starting Gibson at RB)

2) Start TY Hilton if he plays (already starting Pittman)

3) Drop Hilton and pickup Slayton as insurance for Toney for MNF*

I'm about a 15-20 point underdog this week so I'm looking for some upside which is why I was going to roll with Toney.

*I've got Gallup on IR and figure I will have to activate him next week and drop Hilton anyway.

ETA: Just reading some NFL trade rumors and it's possible that the Giants could look to trade Engram and Slayton. Makes the move for Slayton a little more enticing to see what happens.
I think Toney is playing, and he's your best option. If you are dropping Hilton anyway, no reason not to grab Slayton as insurance.

Waffling between Javonte and Collins in 1/2 ppr
I'd probably go Collins here. Similar timeshare issues, but a better matchup for Collins.

Pick 1 WR / 3 Flex - .25 PPR

Pretty much made up my mind but could use second opinions in case my analysis is flawed. Going against as team devastated by byes / injuries and starting scrubs (Waller / McCaffrey, etc out). 

Toney vs KC (13) - Looks like he's going to play. Leaning towards this one for upside even though Monday Night questionable. Waddle and MIA offense got destroyed by BUF in week 2 so I have zero confidence in that matchup.

Waddle vs BUF (2nd) - Leaning towards sitting him. Don't know if I can trust Tua and MIA vs Bills considering TUA got knocked out that game and Jacoby Brisett was god awful. Don't know that they got any better since then.

Jamaal Williams vs PHI (29th) - I hate having to play this guy but the matchup is there and hopefully he gets volume.

Gordon vs Wsh (17) - Hate this split backfield.... But he scored TD last week which saved me so just hoping they do better against WSH. At least Jeudy is back so maybe they get revitalized and more scoring opportunities.

Alex Collins vs Jax (25th) - He got volume last week and goes against Jacksonville so I think it's a good volume play. His injury is concerning but same thing happened last week and he played.

Thanks!
Miami with Brissett, and Miami with Tua are very different. I think Waddle is a must start among this group. 

Collins feels like the best play of the flex options, followed by Toney, and Gordon in my opinion. The Lions are slowly putting more and more on Swift's plate, at the expense of Williams, and even against the Eagles, I'd rather look elsewhere.

Winston or Burrow?
This is probably the easiest call of all these for me. Burrow, and its not close. Burrow is a legit QB1, and is has top-5 potential any given week. Winston is a low-end QB2, with no real weapons other than Kamara. Even if Burrow gets pulled early due to a blowout(no sure thing by the way) its likely he gets 2-3 TD's before that point. 

 
Teddy 2 Gloves vs Danny Double Dimes

every game I’ve lost this year I’ve been run down on a Monday Night 

Triple D give me a chance to expel the demon 

 
Which 2 from this group?

0.5 PPR 

Cooks vs LA

Beasley vs MIA

Shepard vs KC

Leaning Beasley and Shepard (and keeping fingers crossed he plays) but sitting Cooks is hard to do. 

 
Defense are ultimately random number generators.

I like the thinking about Chicago, but put no merit in Nagy missing the game.

I don't think Cleveland is as healthy as they want people to think but they should still be better on offense pretty much across the board.

It really is a coin flip but I'm okay with

SF>Pit
I'm in the same situation with streaming defenses this week. For better or worse I'm going with Seattle. The injuries on that SF defense scared me off, as did road dog Steelers facing Chubb in the slop. Nagy missing the game is likely the best thing to happen to the Bears. 

 
Stuck between a hard place and a rock.

Decimal scoring,td's 6pts,ppr

                                                          Need TWO of the following:

                                                                                                          M.Gordon vs Wash

                                                                                                          S.Perine @ NYJ(sneaky sleeper?)

                                                                                                          K.Toney @ KC(healthy?)

                                                                                                           V.Jefferson @ Hou

                                                                                                            M.Hardman vs NYG

                                                                                                            T.Smith vs TB

                                                       And here's a quandry.

                                                       Need a TE:

                                                                                                         D.Goedert @ Det

                                                                                                         N.Fant vs Wash

                                                                              Then need ONE from whoever the TE isn't and:

                                                                                                        M.Gordon vs Wash

                                                                                                        S.Shepard @ KC

 
.5 PPR

Jamal Agnew vs SEA

Mooney vs SF

Edit: Lol nevermind, with ridley out I have to start both

start Tannehill now or wait for DAK and have to start Daniel Jones if he doesn’t go? Sitting at 3-4 and need a big game from QB

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Superflex ppr need two of Davis mills, javonte and Darrell Williams. Mills hasn’t been good but a QB’s marginal game is usually as good as a 100yd, 1 TD day for a back. 

 
PPR 12 team. Need a flex

Have RB's Gaskin, Collins, Carter or WR's Landry, Boyd

Leaning Gaskin for no particular reason. Boyd has been terrible for me so he is my last choice probably

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think we all see the blowout looming for Cincinnati but they had three pretty easy wins against Pit, Det & Bal and Burrow threw three TDs in each game.

Winston has had two monster games and four stinkers.

Burrow is also simply the better player.

This is a question about the importance of game script. Tampa should force New Orleans to throw a lot and the Bengals could be done by halftime.

I do absolutely consider game script when I think about these things but I do believe that, unless it is an epic blowout, usually teams don't appreciably change their game plans until the fourth quarter, if then. Mac Jones threw only 10 passes in the second half when they were up 31-7. But he threw for 300 & 2 up to that point (and the Pats had another passing TD before then).

My point is a lot of points need to be scored before teams change their game plan. I still think Burrow's upside is capped but he has the higher floor by far.

My head is telling to start Burrow without hesitation. My lizard brain is tempting me with the idea that Winston will have to throw 40+ passes of New Orleans wants to stay competitive, Burrow may not hit 25. And New Orleans, with Brees, played TB very tough for most of three games last season.

Burrow if you want to be safe.

Winston if you feel you need shoot for a big score.

Me?

Winston>Burrow for no good reason.

ETA: I immediately regret that decision.

But I'll stand by it...for now.
Thank you.  Yeah, I think I'll go Burrow.  He's the safer play.  I could honestly see the NOS-TB game playing out a number of different ways, at least a couple of which involve Winston not having a great game.  On the flipside, I think it's hard to imagine, even if it's a complete blowout, Burrow not throwing for at least 200 yards and a score or two.  If that's his floor, I'll take it.

This is probably the easiest call of all these for me. Burrow, and its not close. Burrow is a legit QB1, and is has top-5 potential any given week. Winston is a low-end QB2, with no real weapons other than Kamara. Even if Burrow gets pulled early due to a blowout(no sure thing by the way) its likely he gets 2-3 TD's before that point. 
Thank you for basically reaffirming what my gut was telling me (while my head kept screaming "shootout between TB/NO").  Burrow has been solid, and there's no reason to think differently now.  

 
Teddy 2 Gloves vs Danny Double Dimes

every game I’ve lost this year I’ve been run down on a Monday Night 

Triple D give me a chance to expel the demon 
We have a thing about nicknames in this thread, not a big deal as these are clear but still...you're doing it wrong.

Being said I love Jones over Bridgewater generally 9 out of 10 the only hesitation I have is the WFT has made virtually every single QB they have faced very fantasy relevant except, surprisingly Justin Hebert in week one. I chalk that up to week 1 outlier.

Herbert 8, Jones 21, Allen 30, Ryan 24, Winston 25, Mahomes 16, Rodgers 19. They average 21 points yielded to QBs per week.

That is the only reasonable argument in Favor and the counter argument is Jones is more talented can, hurt you with his feet has much higher upside and KC Defense hasn't really been any better giving up 18 points on average to QBs per week.

Jones>Bridgewater

 
Which 2 from this group?

0.5 PPR 

Cooks vs LA

Beasley vs MIA

Shepard vs KC

Leaning Beasley and Shepard (and keeping fingers crossed he plays) but sitting Cooks is hard to do. 
Cooks and Shepard seem like obvious choices to me.  They are both target sponges on their teams while Beasley is third fiddle at best in a game that will probably feature plenty of running by Buffalo. 

Cooks/Shepard>Beasley

 
Claypool vs Cle or Gaskin vs Buf for my PPR Flex?
Gaskin can catch a little, and he will probably need to if he is going to be relevant this week. Claypool is simply the better talent.

I am not sure any deep dive into these players and their matchups is going to reveal much. Claypool should see 7-9 targets and he can do damage with that. Gaskin actually thrived the last time Mia was blown out @ Tampa Bay but I wouldn't rely on another two TDs, but it's the 10 targets that's more interesting. He averages about 5 targets/game even without that 10 target game against TB. He also averages just under 9 carries per game and I would bet the under here.

Yeah, this is really a coin toss and I keep going back and forth.

They have similar floor although I give Claypool the edge on ceiling because he can hurt you big on one play while Gaskin needs a lot more to go right for that to happen.

Claypool...? Maybe?

 
Teddy 2 Gloves vs Danny Double Dimes

every game I’ve lost this year I’ve been run down on a Monday Night 

Triple D give me a chance to expel the demon 
Jones. Teddy has been struggling of late, and Jeudy isn't going to fix everything. Jones should have Shepard and Toney back, and has a a better matchup in my opinion.

Which 2 from this group?

0.5 PPR 

Cooks vs LA

Beasley vs MIA

Shepard vs KC

Leaning Beasley and Shepard (and keeping fingers crossed he plays) but sitting Cooks is hard to do. 
I'd actually sit Beasley. I think Knox being out could lead to Buffalo running more, and see Cooks getting 10 targets. Beasley may see 7+ targets, but unless he scores, he likely tops out at about 75-80 yards. 

Claypool vs Cle or Gaskin vs Buf for my PPR Flex?
Even with Brown out, I still can't fully get on board with Gaskin over a guy like Claypool. I would bet the Steelers spent much of the bye week getting Ben and Claypool on the same page. 

Stuck between a hard place and a rock.

Decimal scoring,td's 6pts,ppr

                                                          Need TWO of the following:

                                                                                                          M.Gordon vs Wash

                                                                                                          S.Perine @ NYJ(sneaky sleeper?)

                                                                                                          K.Toney @ KC(healthy?)

                                                                                                           V.Jefferson @ Hou

                                                                                                            M.Hardman vs NYG

                                                                                                            T.Smith vs TB

                                                       And here's a quandry.

                                                       Need a TE:

                                                                                                         D.Goedert @ Det

                                                                                                         N.Fant vs Wash

                                                                              Then need ONE from whoever the TE isn't and:

                                                                                                        M.Gordon vs Wash

                                                                                                        S.Shepard @ KC
Toney and Jefferson would be my picks in the top one. Jefferson has soundly beaten D-Jax for the #3 job, and is heavily involved. I think he's got a good floor against Houston, with a good chance he gets a few deep shots. 

I'd go Goedert over Fant. Better matchup, and likely more targets as Denver likely gets both Jeudy and Albert O back. 

I'd go Shepard over Gordon. Just so much volume for Shepard. 

1/2 pt PPR flex

Emanuel Sanders or Khalil Herbert

I’m really back and forth on this decision. 
I'd lean Sanders here. His role as the #2 has been solidified in Knox's absence, especially in the redzone.

I have a bunch of different options for 2 flex spots 1.5 ppr for TE

M. Carter

Beasley

ARob

Cooks

H Henry

Higbee
Cooks and Carter would be my picks here. Carter was much more involved after the bye week, and should see plenty of garbage time work. Cooks targets keep him a decent start regardless of matchup. 

.5 PPR

Jamal Agnew vs SEA

Mooney vs SF

start Tannehill now or wait for DAK and have to start Daniel Jones if he doesn’t go? Sitting at 3-4 and need a big game from QB
Mooney for sure. Until I see something to suggest otherwise, beyond some glowing praise from Meyer, I don't see Agnew as any higher than 5th in the Jags pecking order. Mooney has become the Bears #1 WR, and while that isn't an even decent passing game, he's the much safer play.

I'd wait for Dak, as I prefer Jones to Tannehill anyway. 

Superflex ppr need two of Davis mills, javonte and Darrell Williams. Mills hasn’t been good but a QB’s marginal game is usually as good as a 100yd, 1 TD day for a back. 
Yeah, I'd start any QB over a committee RB. Go Mills and Darrell. 

PPR 12 team. Need a flex

Have RB's Gaskin, Collins, Carter or WR's Landry, Boyd

Leaning Gaskin for no particular reason. Boyd has been terrible for me so he is my last choice probably
Yeah, I can support Gaskin here. He has a high ceiling if Buffalo gets an early lead. I like Carter as well, but Gaskin probably has a higher ceiling.

 
Ten team full ppr need to start two between Javonte, Alex Collins, and DJ. I’m thinking Collins and DJ since they have more control of their backfield? I have no clue. Ridley ####ed me.

 
Ten team full ppr need to start two between Javonte, Alex Collins, and DJ. I’m thinking Collins and DJ since they have more control of their backfield? I have no clue. Ridley ####ed me.


So tough on that one.  Collins is getting the carries so he is probably the safest floor.  I might go williams over DJ though...

 
Stuck between a hard place and a rock.

Decimal scoring,td's 6pts,ppr

                                                          Need TWO of the following:

                                                                                                          M.Gordon vs Wash

                                                                                                          S.Perine @ NYJ(sneaky sleeper?)

                                                                                                          K.Toney @ KC(healthy?)

                                                                                                           V.Jefferson @ Hou

                                                                                                            M.Hardman vs NYG

                                                                                                            T.Smith vs TB

                                                       And here's a quandry.

                                                       Need a TE:

                                                                                                         D.Goedert @ Det

                                                                                                         N.Fant vs Wash

                                                                              Then need ONE from whoever the TE isn't and:

                                                                                                        M.Gordon vs Wash

                                                                                                        S.Shepard @ KC
#1

Hard no on Hardman and T.Smith.

Despite the questions around him Toney feels like a must start from this group. He has flashed too much, in very limited snaps to be ignored in such a plus matchup. If he's a late scratch pivot to Hardman and pray to whichever God(s) you believe would really concern themselves with your magic football team.

Jefferson is interesting as in the two games Desean Jackson really didn't play he saw over 90% of offensive snaps. The Rams will roll but Stafford may not even hit 30 passes so he will have to be efficient.

Gordon is absolutely the safe floor option. He gets you 65 yards, catches two passes a game and has scored in 3 of 7.

I can see Perine being relevant. I can also see him be irrelevant. Nothing but a gut call on him.  If you like him, start him.  I wouldn't.

Toney and Jefferson for boom

Toney and Gordon for balance

 
1/2 pt PPR flex

Emanuel Sanders or Khalil Herbert

I’m really back and forth on this decision. 
This one is easy to go back and forth on.

I say Herbert because he I think he has seized the Montgomery role*, will see volume and is more likely to be relevant for four quarters and is probably a little less TD dependent. Mind you, if Sanders is irrelevant by the fourth quarter it is because Buffalo has scored a lot of points in the first 2.5-3 quarters.

Still Herbert>Sanders

*ETA: I could be wrong. It is possible Williams saw so little action last week because he didn't practice all week. But I still like Herbert.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have a bunch of different options for 2 flex spots 1.5 ppr for TE

M. Carter

Beasley

ARob

Cooks

H Henry

Higbee
Cooks for sure, without hesitation.

Then it's a coin toss.  I lean Hunter Henry then maybe Michael Carter because he can be relevant in the receiving game

Cooks>>>Henry>Carter

 
.5 PPR

Jamal Agnew vs SEA

Mooney vs SF

start Tannehill now or wait for DAK and have to start Daniel Jones if he doesn’t go? Sitting at 3-4 and need a big game from QB
Mooney based on volume.

Nothing wrong with Jones>Tannehill IMO your call and it may not work out but it's not a terrible decision.

 
Ridley out has made this a dumpster fire, start 3 PPR:

  • Cooper @ Vikings
  • Crowder v Bungles
  • Jefferson @ Texans
  • Boyd @ Jets
  • OBJ vs Stealer's
  • Johnson @ Saints
Leaning the top three, OBJ basically only still on the roster due to having even worse junk to drop, Johnson probably drops to equally worthless with Gronk likely back (although if Evans is shut down by Lattimore, maybe it's a what the heck play), but I could certainly see an argument that Boyd in the lineup. Pascal is on the wire as a hail mary - thoughts?

 
Superflex ppr need two of Davis mills, javonte and Darrell Williams. Mills hasn’t been good but a QB’s marginal game is usually as good as a 100yd, 1 TD day for a back. 
Unfortunately 100 yards and a TD are hardly a lock for Davis Mills. But in a super-flex I can see it.

Javonte has the safer floor and has been close to breaking one off, but Williams has proven a higher ceiling.  Really unpredictable this one. In this situation I may go with Williams solely on the principle that if I am down he gives me hope going into Monday night.  Not a great reason but an entertaining one.

 
PPR 12 team. Need a flex

Have RB's Gaskin, Collins, Carter or WR's Landry, Boyd

Leaning Gaskin for no particular reason. Boyd has been terrible for me so he is my last choice probably
I lean Collins then Gaskin.

Collins is boring but he has the easiest path to touches, he's at home and it's a plus matchup.

Gaskin catches more than Collins but his touches are all over the place.

Collins>Gaskin

 
Ridley out has made this a dumpster fire, start 3 PPR:

  • Cooper @ Vikings
  • Crowder v Bungles
  • Jefferson @ Texans
  • Boyd @ Jets
  • OBJ vs Stealer's
  • Johnson @ Saints
Leaning the top three, OBJ basically only still on the roster due to having even worse junk to drop, Johnson probably drops to equally worthless with Gronk likely back (although if Evans is shut down by Lattimore, maybe it's a what the heck play), but I could certainly see an argument that Boyd in the lineup. Pascal is on the wire as a hail mary - thoughts?
I like your choices. Jefferson is obviously a wild card but Boyd has done very little so far to justify being in your lineup.

Cooper, Crowder & Jefferson

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top