What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

What is S. Smith's value w/current QB situation? (1 Viewer)

mckid2000

Footballguy
What do you thinks about S. Smith's numbers going forward w/ Carr or Testaverde at QB. He's my #1 WR, but I'm very nervous about what he will do now and in his remaining games. Is he worth sitting in favor of guys like B. Berrian, D.Mason, S. Rice. This will be something that could kill me going forward in my season.

 
It's not good.. I'm in the same position and feel your pain..

However, you have to go with your studs - I had him on the bench but just switched placing Smith in the starting role.. May come back to to bite me but I'd hate to sit my best wr and have him go off.

 
I'm playing Smith all the time. Who ever the QB is only has to throw it a few yards then Smith can do what he does best..RUN !

If worry about going forward there was a thread on Smiths trade value yesterday, had a lot of replies to it, check it out some where in this forum.

 
SS can score on a screen pass. A high school QB can throw this pass.

SS is the best WR in the NFL IMHO. At the very least he's the best YAC guy in the NFL.

When he goes off on your bench you'll be sorry!

 
SS can score on a screen pass. A high school QB can throw this pass.SS is the best WR in the NFL IMHO. At the very least he's the best YAC guy in the NFL.When he goes off on your bench you'll be sorry!
And when he keeps putting up a 3 or 4 catch, 40 yard days and scores every other week we'll be just as sorry. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. tMAYBE the light bulb will come on for Vinny and he'll grap the throw the damned ball to your stud WR concept.One can always hope I guess.
 
The QB situation is certainly not good for Smith, but he is still a top 5 FF WR. Other than Randy Moss, i cant think of another WR i would rather have from here on out.

 
Im so nervous I'm thinking about putting Roddy White in over Smith. :rolleyes:
I went ahead and did this very thing.
Im gonna keep smith in, atleast one of us will be happy. :)
I have the luxury of being the highest scoring team in an IDP league with 21 starters, so I just need a few points out of this WR position. White is more likely to give me 10-12 points. Smith is more likely to give me 4 or 28.
 
Let's hope Vinny did enough today to let Fox let him keep the job. What I like about Testaverde is that he is going to feed Smith one way or the other unlike Carr who just sees "coverage" and abandons ship.

 
Will vinny start after the bye. I hope so
Fox would have to be a gigantic idiot to go back to Carr after the bye. Carr is an inept NFL quarterback. Vinny isn't Tom Brady but he managed the game pretty well and most importantly he got Smith back involved. His ability to get the ball downfield to Smith is HUGE for this offense and that had been missing with Carr because Carr doesn't have a strong downfield arm. It's real simple - the Panthers need Smith productive if they're going to win consistently. A two-year-old could see there was a significant difference in that regard today compared to the previous two games with Carr at QB.
 
Vinny did NOTHING to deserve to get benched after playing that well and only being on the team for what, 5 days? As a Smith owner, I'm SOOOO happy Vinny is in Carolina. :confused:

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top