Which side? Julio/AR15/gurley (1 Viewer)

[Pwingles]

12 team ppr

start 2-4 rb, 3-5 wr

julio and kamara

ar15 and gurley

current roster without the above players

ingram, hill, mixon, perkins, crowell, lynch

evans, dez, coleman, davis, mike williams, tyrell

 

[travdogg]

I'd take the Robinson/Gurley side. I'm very high on Gurley, and believe his troubles were entirely about a team that had quit on a coaching staff. I think Gurley could very much be the best player in this deal. I think Kamara is pretty clearly the weakest link of this deal, and is probably only better than Hill among your current RBs. 

Julio is still a stud, no question, but there is more than enough bounce back potential for Gurley and Robinson to make this a deal in your favor.

 

[Gally]

In a vacuum I probably lean towards the Julio side but I think it's even.  I just don't trust Arob or Gurley.  To me that side has a lot more upside but a lot more risk too.

However based on your roster I think I might pull the trigger for Gurley/ARob.  The upside would give you a really strong roster if it hits and the risk side can be made up for is they perform as RB2/wr3 levels.  

 

[yourlogicisridiculous]

Julio side is safer. You can pretty heavily rely on Julio getting you points. On the other hand ARob and Gurley have both shown elite level play on pretty garbage teams. Their upside is humongous. It's really up to you whether or not you want to take the gamble. Myself, I take the ARob and Gurley side.