Who has a More UPSIDE? (1 Viewer)

[jgb95]

A team owner is at high salary cap and he has both of these WR's on his PS and I need a WR.

Who has more upside????

Scoring system below.

Thanks

 

[jbalicki10]

A team owner is at high salary cap and he has both of these WR's on his PS and I need a WR.Who has more upside????Scoring system below.Thanks

Roddy White by a long shot.... Craytons game was a fluke

 

[zamboni]

A team owner is at high salary cap and he has both of these WR's on his PS and I need a WR.Who has more upside????Scoring system below.Thanks

Roddy White by a long shot.... Craytons game was a fluke

I agree with White, but not by much. Problem with Roddy is that you never know whether he, Jenkins or Crumpler will have the good game. Or none of the above if Harrington regresses to the QB we are accustomed to seeing.

 

[laughinboy_2000]

A team owner is at high salary cap and he has both of these WR's on his PS and I need a WR.Who has more upside????Scoring system below.Thanks

Roddy White by a long shot.... Craytons game was a fluke

I agree with White, but not by much. Problem with Roddy is that you never know whether he, Jenkins or Crumpler will have the good game. Or none of the above if Harrington regresses to the QB we are accustomed to seeing.

So you guys would take a WR that has Joey Harrington throwing him the ball OVER someone who had Tony Romo passing him the ball?

 

[Bermuda_Chub]

"Roddy White by a long shot.... Craytons game was a fluke"

Agreed. Plus there's the whole Terry Glenn thing.

 

[zamboni]

A team owner is at high salary cap and he has both of these WR's on his PS and I need a WR.Who has more upside????Scoring system below.Thanks

Roddy White by a long shot.... Craytons game was a fluke

I agree with White, but not by much. Problem with Roddy is that you never know whether he, Jenkins or Crumpler will have the good game. Or none of the above if Harrington regresses to the QB we are accustomed to seeing.

So you guys would take a WR that has Joey Harrington throwing him the ball OVER someone who had Tony Romo passing him the ball?

Crayton is a distant 3rd in the pecking order behind TO and Witten, and if Glenn returns, goes to 4th. At least White is becoming a primary target for Harrington, in an offense that will need to throw a lot.

 

[jgb95]

"Roddy White by a long shot.... Craytons game was a fluke"

Agreed. Plus there's the whole Terry Glenn thing.

That's my main concern.

Any new news on TG?

 

[Sid G]

For just the rest of this season? Crayton. Ask yourself how many more offensive touchdowns you expect the Cowboys to score than the Falcons, then figure out how much greater is the percentage of team TDs White is going to have to score to make up for it.

If you're a believer in Joey Harrington, the answer could be White. I'm not.

 

[Bears_Man2]

Upside perhaps White. I'd rather own Crayton. Much safer bet IMO.

 

[jgb95]

Dynasty

 

[Koya]

Roddy White, ESPECIALLY in a dynasty. The guy is finally showing flashes of being a first round talent and a true #1. That represents great upside considering his coaches propensity to throw the ball. If they get a good QB in their, who knows what may happen.

 

[jbalicki10]

Just remeber: #1 WR = Owens, #2 WR = Witten, #3 = GLENN????? Rest of the scraps: Hurd and "Dropsie" Crayton

I own Crayton and would take Roddy White in a trade.

Roddy White is the #2 WR and jenkins is the #3 guy from the games I saw.

 

[zamboni]

Roddy White, ESPECIALLY in a dynasty. The guy is finally showing flashes of being a first round talent and a true #1. That represents great upside considering his coaches propensity to throw the ball. If they get a good QB in their, who knows what may happen.

Of course, the same thing could be said for Jenkins, who's also shown some flashes.

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

Roddy White, ESPECIALLY in a dynasty. The guy is finally showing flashes of being a first round talent and a true #1. That represents great upside considering his coaches propensity to throw the ball. If they get a good QB in their, who knows what may happen.

Of course, the same thing could be said for Jenkins, who's also shown some flashes.

One big difference is that White is making plays downfield and turning short gains into long ones with his YAC ability. Jenkins is catching a lot of balls, but he's not the deep threat or athlete that White is. Laurent Robinson looks like he's going to poach one of the starter spots eventually, and with White's run blocking acumen and speed, I expect it to be Jenkins who moves to WR3. Big ups to Hue Jackson who has brought out the best in the young Falcon WRs.

 

[jgb95]

Thanks guy good info here

 

[zamboni]

Roddy White, ESPECIALLY in a dynasty. The guy is finally showing flashes of being a first round talent and a true #1. That represents great upside considering his coaches propensity to throw the ball. If they get a good QB in their, who knows what may happen.

Of course, the same thing could be said for Jenkins, who's also shown some flashes.

One big difference is that White is making plays downfield and turning short gains into long ones with his YAC ability. Jenkins is catching a lot of balls, but he's not the deep threat or athlete that White is. Laurent Robinson looks like he's going to poach one of the starter spots eventually, and with White's run blocking acumen and speed, I expect it to be Jenkins who moves to WR3. Big ups to Hue Jackson who has brought out the best in the young Falcon WRs.

I'm also waiting to see what Robinson can do. Seems like he's healthy now, and just waiting for one of the other guys to slip up (or get hurt). I think we can all agree that Horn is toast.One other think I like about White is if Leftwich takes over the job. His arm strength could dovetail nicely with White's down the field ability.