Who is riding the A-Train this weekend...? (1 Viewer)

[TheDirtyWord]

I don't know if I would be even considering this normally, but a few factors are contributing to my thinking on this.

1) Indy's run defense. They looked better with Bob Sanders in their for sure. But they still gave up quite a bit of yards and the aftermath of the Indy/NE game seemed to contain alot of questions about why the Pats simply didn't ram it down the Colts throat.

2) This screams of letdown game for the Colts as well. After playing in a regular season game as ballyhooed as any this season (with the exception of perhaps the Manning Bowl)...I could see the Colts taking some time before putting the Bills away if they even do at all.

3) I think the only way the Bills could realistically win this game would be to slow it down. McGahee has struggled this year, but he's gotten the ball 20x/game. A-Train didn't look half bad against GB when McGahee went down. This smells like "blessing in disguise" a bit for Buffalo.

As for who I'm benching:

Rudi against SD...the Bengals just seem to be in a rut and for whatever reason, they don't appear willing to give the ball to Rudi 25 times to get them out of it. Plus, SD would be a tough opponent to do this on anyway.

Ahman against Minn...Vikings also seem to have their run D clicking on all cylinders. The Williams Boys have been monsters in the middle and are taking this part of the offense away from their opponents.

Anyone else playing this match-up?

 

[DolphinsPhan]

First, Alstott is the A-Train and I wouldn't start him this weekend.

Anthony Thomas will probably not have a huge game since the Colts will be up by 21 at half time. Bills will probably have to pass all 2nd half (go Lee Evans). The Bills will try and run to keep Manning off of the field, but he really only needs about 90 seconds to score anyway. No way the Colts lose at home.

 

[Iwannabeacowboybaby!]

Starting Anthony Thomas as my RB 2 over Reuben Droughns and Tatum Bell.

A couple of weeks ago, who would have thunk it.

 

[TheDirtyWord]

First, Alstott is the A-Train and I wouldn't start him this weekend.Anthony Thomas will probably not have a huge game since the Colts will be up by 21 at half time. Bills will probably have to pass all 2nd half (go Lee Evans). The Bills will try and run to keep Manning off of the field, but he really only needs about 90 seconds to score anyway. No way the Colts lose at home.

I'm not sure I get your logic. The Colts give up more rushing yards than any other team. Why would the assumption be made that any team would have to abandon the run in the second half because of the Colts offense? It really hasn't happened, teams are still running the ball 30x a game on Indy. And to me, I'd be surprised if they put this game in J.P. Losman's hands to manage.

 

[DolphinsPhan]

First, Alstott is the A-Train and I wouldn't start him this weekend.Anthony Thomas will probably not have a huge game since the Colts will be up by 21 at half time. Bills will probably have to pass all 2nd half (go Lee Evans). The Bills will try and run to keep Manning off of the field, but he really only needs about 90 seconds to score anyway. No way the Colts lose at home.

I'm not sure I get your logic. The Colts give up more rushing yards than any other team. Why would the assumption be made that any team would have to abandon the run in the second half because of the Colts offense? It really hasn't happened, teams are still running the ball 30x a game on Indy. And to me, I'd be surprised if they put this game in J.P. Losman's hands to manage.

You're not going to beat the Colts unless you score 30+ points. The Bills don't have the rushing attack to put up that many points and they certainly don't have it with a backup RB.

 

[Wilbur Wood]

I have him in 1 league.

I think that he will gain some yards. Would start him if he were at home. I do think that Indy gets up early and Buffalo will shy away somewhat from the run.

I am considering starting him over Larry Fitzgerald at my Flex slot. Then again I think that Arizona will play a stronger game coming off of the bye.

 

[Banger]

First, Alstott is the A-Train and I wouldn't start him this weekend.Anthony Thomas will probably not have a huge game since the Colts will be up by 21 at half time. Bills will probably have to pass all 2nd half (go Lee Evans). The Bills will try and run to keep Manning off of the field, but he really only needs about 90 seconds to score anyway. No way the Colts lose at home.

I'm not sure I get your logic. The Colts give up more rushing yards than any other team. Why would the assumption be made that any team would have to abandon the run in the second half because of the Colts offense? It really hasn't happened, teams are still running the ball 30x a game on Indy. And to me, I'd be surprised if they put this game in J.P. Losman's hands to manage.

You're not going to beat the Colts unless you score 30+ points. The Bills don't have the rushing attack to put up that many points and they certainly don't have it with a backup RB.

Well I don't think the Bills have a chance if they decide to go toe to toe with Indy and try to air it out. Yes the Bills rushing attack isn't great but Indy's rush defense is beyond awful. The only chance they have IMO is if they keep the ball out of Indy's hands and try to run, run, run. These are the rush totals put up so far by Indy opponents:Giants 180-1Houston 98Jags 180-1Jets 117-2Tenn 214-1Wash 114Den 224-3 (M. Bell looked like OJ Simpson)NE 148-2Chances are A-Train won't have to share carries with anyone so he will probably get most if not all of the rushing yards. I'd say his chance for 100 yards is not only possible but probable.

 

[GroveDiesel]

I'm starting him over Thomas Jones

When your #2 RB options are Thomas Jones, Anthony Thomas and Michael Turner you can only be thankful that you have Larry Johnson as your #1.

 

[The Deathstar]

I don't know if I would be even considering this normally, but a few factors are contributing to my thinking on this.1) Indy's run defense. They looked better with Bob Sanders in their for sure. But they still gave up quite a bit of yards and the aftermath of the Indy/NE game seemed to contain alot of questions about why the Pats simply didn't ram it down the Colts throat.2) This screams of letdown game for the Colts as well. After playing in a regular season game as ballyhooed as any this season (with the exception of perhaps the Manning Bowl)...I could see the Colts taking some time before putting the Bills away if they even do at all.3) I think the only way the Bills could realistically win this game would be to slow it down. McGahee has struggled this year, but he's gotten the ball 20x/game. A-Train didn't look half bad against GB when McGahee went down. This smells like "blessing in disguise" a bit for Buffalo.As for who I'm benching:Rudi against SD...the Bengals just seem to be in a rut and for whatever reason, they don't appear willing to give the ball to Rudi 25 times to get them out of it. Plus, SD would be a tough opponent to do this on anyway.Ahman against Minn...Vikings also seem to have their run D clicking on all cylinders. The Williams Boys have been monsters in the middle and are taking this part of the offense away from their opponents.Anyone else playing this match-up?

Starting A-Train over Duece vs. Steelers

 

[menobrown]

I'm riding A-Train but I'm not benching anyone 'cause A-Train was my Mcgahee handcuff.

 

[G-Money]

In one league where I can start 3RB, I'm starting Thomas over Edge (vs DAL) and Mike Bell (vs OAK). I'd really like to play Bell, but the Denver RB situation isn still a bit too foggy at this point to chance. Edge will surely get touches, but a possible 2 YPC avg (or less) doesn't seem too appealing. We'll see.

(edit). I'm also starting Steven Jackson (vs SEA) and Corry Dillon (vs NYJ).

 

[pantagrapher]

Benching:

Laurence Maroney, Greg Jennings, Muhsin Muhammed, Reuben Droughns

 

[stbugs]

First, Alstott is the A-Train and I wouldn't start him this weekend.Anthony Thomas will probably not have a huge game since the Colts will be up by 21 at half time. Bills will probably have to pass all 2nd half (go Lee Evans). The Bills will try and run to keep Manning off of the field, but he really only needs about 90 seconds to score anyway. No way the Colts lose at home.

I'm not sure I get your logic. The Colts give up more rushing yards than any other team. Why would the assumption be made that any team would have to abandon the run in the second half because of the Colts offense? It really hasn't happened, teams are still running the ball 30x a game on Indy. And to me, I'd be surprised if they put this game in J.P. Losman's hands to manage.

You're not going to beat the Colts unless you score 30+ points. The Bills don't have the rushing attack to put up that many points and they certainly don't have it with a backup RB.

Well I don't think the Bills have a chance if they decide to go toe to toe with Indy and try to air it out. Yes the Bills rushing attack isn't great but Indy's rush defense is beyond awful. The only chance they have IMO is if they keep the ball out of Indy's hands and try to run, run, run. These are the rush totals put up so far by Indy opponents:Giants 180-1Houston 98Jags 180-1Jets 117-2Tenn 214-1Wash 114Den 224-3 (M. Bell looked like OJ Simpson)NE 148-2Chances are A-Train won't have to share carries with anyone so he will probably get most if not all of the rushing yards. I'd say his chance for 100 yards is not only possible but probable.

I didn't realize how well the Pats did actually run the ball. Without Brady's 4 picks, their rushing totals would have been even better.Thomas looked pretty good and I can't imagine the Bills not running a lot. I am in a PPR league, so this is a tough start for me, but I think I like Thomas' chances of getting 10-15 points without a lot of risk, so I am probably starting him at the Flex over Branch, Galloway, B. Edwards and Cotchery. I know that at least 1 of those receivers will go off, but the problem is which one and guessing wrong. I guess I might also look at Thomas over Chester Taylor if he hasn't gotten over the "soreness." Taylor's main problem so far is the lack of TDs and Thomas seems to have a very good chance at a TD based on the stats above.

 

[BigTex]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

 

[Iwannabeacowboybaby!]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

He's the guy who had 20 carries, 90 plus yards and a TD last week and now faces one of the worst run defenses in the league.The only way he doesn't have a solid game is if the Bills fall behind 21 points early and just can't run the ball because they're so far behind so early.

 

[TheDirtyWord]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

 

[BigTex]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

 

[Banger]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

Who cares about A-Train's long term potential, talent, etc.? This is a week to week evaluation. This week he's the unquestioned starter (with no one that will cut into his carries), he's playing for the coach he's had the most success in his career with, in limited action this year he's actually looked pretty decent and he's playing the worst rush defense in the NFL. What happened in Dallas or two years ago, etc. is totally irrelevant. Situations change and you have to re-evaluate and react accordingly. A few years ago if you told me that Thomas Jones would be in the league let alone starting for the top team in the league and putting up good/great numbers I would have laughed in your face.I'm on record stating how much of a slug I thought A-Train was but for this week (and possibly next week) his opportunity is better than a lot of RB's with a lot more talent. Chances are he was on the waiver wire in most leagues prior to this week so it's not as if people will be crushed if he doesn't work out.

 

[BigTex]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).

When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

Who cares about A-Train's long term potential, talent, etc.? This is a week to week evaluation. This week he's the unquestioned starter (with no one that will cut into his carries), he's playing for the coach he's had the most success in his career with, in limited action this year he's actually looked pretty decent and he's playing the worst rush defense in the NFL. What happened in Dallas or two years ago, etc. is totally irrelevant. Situations change and you have to re-evaluate and react accordingly. A few years ago if you told me that Thomas Jones would be in the league let alone starting for the top team in the league and putting up good/great numbers I would have laughed in your face.I'm on record stating how much of a slug I thought A-Train was but for this week (and possibly next week) his opportunity is better than a lot of RB's with a lot more talent. Chances are he was on the waiver wire in most leagues prior to this week so it's not as if people will be crushed if he doesn't work out.

This is were we'll disagree, so no need to go into the neck of the woods. Hey, who knows this may be his "Take off the diaper" motivation to get him were everyone was hoping he'd be. But I wouldn't bet on it.

 

[pantagrapher]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

 

[EdwardCat]

Thomas will finish with 8 carries for 21 yards and 2 catches for 24 yards. He will see very little action.

 

[sdsjr3]

I'm still debating, but I may actually start A-train over Chester this week

The matchup is just too tempting and the higher risk/higher reward factor is definitely appealing considering Chester may be a bit limited.

As for the rest of the garbage going on in this thread, It's obvious that too many people have the long term notion regarding what's going on here. We are talking THIS WEEK and maybe next here fellas. No need to speak about how A-train has been a failure in the past. It's worthless with regard to this topic.

 

[pantagrapher]

I think (and hope) they lean on Thomas. Minimum of 20 touches this weekend.

 

[Banger]

Thomas will finish with 8 carries for 21 yards and 2 catches for 24 yards. He will see very little action.

how's that Tomlinson is done prediction working out for ya?

 

[dornado]

A deep league and an injury to McGahee has me in the unenviable position of rotating A-Train and Wali Lundy as my RB2... so, I guess I'm starting him over Lundy at Jax (Lundy played well against the Jags last time, but its a little different on the road)....

I'm hoping A-Train can put up some points... I don't think he's going to light the world on fire but I think he's a half-way decent goalline back and should get pleny of opportunities.

 

[BigTex]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.The Colts have played against some damn good rbsortisTikkiDillonTaylor/DrewThey've faced the great Denver OLSo, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

 

[EdwardCat]

Thomas will finish with 8 carries for 21 yards and 2 catches for 24 yards. He will see very little action.

how's that Tomlinson is done prediction working out for ya?

Irrelevant to the current discussion. Please troll somewhere else.

 

[Limp Ditka]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.The Colts have played against some damn good rbsortisTikkiDillonTaylor/DrewThey've faced the great Denver OLSo, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

 

[Biabreakable]

First, Alstott is the A-Train and I wouldn't start him this weekend.Anthony Thomas will probably not have a huge game since the Colts will be up by 21 at half time. Bills will probably have to pass all 2nd half (go Lee Evans). The Bills will try and run to keep Manning off of the field, but he really only needs about 90 seconds to score anyway. No way the Colts lose at home.

I'm not sure I get your logic. The Colts give up more rushing yards than any other team. Why would the assumption be made that any team would have to abandon the run in the second half because of the Colts offense? It really hasn't happened, teams are still running the ball 30x a game on Indy. And to me, I'd be surprised if they put this game in J.P. Losman's hands to manage.

You're not going to beat the Colts unless you score 30+ points. The Bills don't have the rushing attack to put up that many points and they certainly don't have it with a backup RB.

Well I don't think the Bills have a chance if they decide to go toe to toe with Indy and try to air it out. Yes the Bills rushing attack isn't great but Indy's rush defense is beyond awful. The only chance they have IMO is if they keep the ball out of Indy's hands and try to run, run, run. These are the rush totals put up so far by Indy opponents:Giants 180-1Houston 98Jags 180-1Jets 117-2Tenn 214-1Wash 114Den 224-3 (M. Bell looked like OJ Simpson)NE 148-2Chances are A-Train won't have to share carries with anyone so he will probably get most if not all of the rushing yards. I'd say his chance for 100 yards is not only possible but probable.

The Colts are giving up an average of 139 yards rushing/game and 1.25 rushing TD/game.Unless you have some VERY good Rb options this week Thomas looks like a very good bet to get you 100+TDI am considering Thomas over Ahman Green and Chester Taylor. Still undecided yet.

 

[EdwardCat]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.The Colts have played against some damn good rbsortisTikkiDillonTaylor/DrewThey've faced the great Denver OLSo, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

 

[Banger]

Thomas will finish with 8 carries for 21 yards and 2 catches for 24 yards. He will see very little action.

how's that Tomlinson is done prediction working out for ya?

Irrelevant to the current discussion. Please troll somewhere else.

not trolling at all just putting your predictive abilities in context....

 

[pantagrapher]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.The Colts have played against some damn good rbsortisTikkiDillonTaylor/DrewThey've faced the great Denver OLSo, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

That's possible. But I think the Bills know their best chance is to slow the game down and keep Manning off the field. If they try to play catchup with the passing game, they'll quickly find themselves in a hole they can't crawl out of. The Colts feast on teams that lack the discipline to run against them. We'll see if the Bills can stick to their guns.

 

[EdwardCat]

Thomas will finish with 8 carries for 21 yards and 2 catches for 24 yards. He will see very little action.

how's that Tomlinson is done prediction working out for ya?

Irrelevant to the current discussion. Please troll somewhere else.

not trolling at all just putting your predictive abilities in context....

You are trolling and now find yourself on ignore. Please play your childish games elsewhere.

 

[EdwardCat]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.The Colts have played against some damn good rbsortisTikkiDillonTaylor/DrewThey've faced the great Denver OLSo, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

That's possible. But I think the Bills know their best chance is to slow the game down and keep Manning off the field. If they try to play catchup with the passing game, they'll quickly find themselves in a hole they can't crawl out of. The Colts feast on teams that lack the discipline to run against them. We'll see if the Bills can stick to their guns.

Let's hope they win the coin flip, then. I just don't see Anthony Thomas doing much against them. It is rare a RB steps in for the main back on a bad team and blows up. If he's able to break off a big run, he may have a chance of being good fantasy-wise. However, I think the Colts keep them him in check.

 

[[scooter]]

Starting A-Train over Foster and Leon Washington.

 

[Limp Ditka]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.The Colts have played against some damn good rbsortisTikkiDillonTaylor/DrewThey've faced the great Denver OLSo, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

That's possible. But I think the Bills know their best chance is to slow the game down and keep Manning off the field. If they try to play catchup with the passing game, they'll quickly find themselves in a hole they can't crawl out of. The Colts feast on teams that lack the discipline to run against them. We'll see if the Bills can stick to their guns.

Let's hope they win the coin flip, then. I just don't see Anthony Thomas doing much against them. It is rare a RB steps in for the main back on a bad team and blows up. If he's able to break off a big run, he may have a chance of being good fantasy-wise. However, I think the Colts keep them him in check.

Now you're just spewing garbage since that's pretty much exactly what he did last week.

 

[Crusaderfan]

I'm starting Thomas over Caddy although right now I would start my Yellow Lab over Caddy. Caddy and the TB offense stink!

Willie

 

[BigTex]

FWIS, I'm an owner of any player on either of these teams, I was lucky enough to trade WilMac before his injury. But WilMac struggled with this OL and now we want to believe that A-Train (eventhough it's a good matchup) is going to produce 100yds/TD.

I just don't think it's a slam dunk this week like many of you are thinking. When Manning a company play this week, before they ever hit the field, Buff will be behind by 14pts.

Considering who Indi has played, their D is not as bad as some are making it out to be. I'm not into making predictions, I NEVER have. But buyer beware.

Some in this thread are actually contenplating starting him over guys that have produced in starting rolls. LOL.

If you're thinking of playing him I'd like to know your record and other options.

 

[EdwardCat]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.The Colts have played against some damn good rbsortisTikkiDillonTaylor/DrewThey've faced the great Denver OLSo, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

That's possible. But I think the Bills know their best chance is to slow the game down and keep Manning off the field. If they try to play catchup with the passing game, they'll quickly find themselves in a hole they can't crawl out of. The Colts feast on teams that lack the discipline to run against them. We'll see if the Bills can stick to their guns.

Let's hope they win the coin flip, then. I just don't see Anthony Thomas doing much against them. It is rare a RB steps in for the main back on a bad team and blows up. If he's able to break off a big run, he may have a chance of being good fantasy-wise. However, I think the Colts keep them him in check.

Now you're just spewing garbage since that's pretty much exactly what he did last week.

hahaha...what a loser.

 

[Limp Ditka]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor...

Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).

When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. Bryant

Both can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.

The Colts have played against some damn good rbs:

Portis

Tikki

Dillon

Taylor/Drew

They've faced the great Denver OL

So, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

That's possible. But I think the Bills know their best chance is to slow the game down and keep Manning off the field. If they try to play catchup with the passing game, they'll quickly find themselves in a hole they can't crawl out of. The Colts feast on teams that lack the discipline to run against them. We'll see if the Bills can stick to their guns.

Let's hope they win the coin flip, then. I just don't see Anthony Thomas doing much against them. It is rare a RB steps in for the main back on a bad team and blows up. If he's able to break off a big run, he may have a chance of being good fantasy-wise. However, I think the Colts keep them him in check.

Now you're just spewing garbage since that's pretty much exactly what he did last week.

hahaha...what a loser.

You're kidding me, right?

Thomas played 3 and 1/2 quarters and went for just shy of a note and got a touch.

For him, or any other backup RB, that's blowing up.

 

[Banger]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.The Colts have played against some damn good rbsortisTikkiDillonTaylor/DrewThey've faced the great Denver OLSo, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

That's possible. But I think the Bills know their best chance is to slow the game down and keep Manning off the field. If they try to play catchup with the passing game, they'll quickly find themselves in a hole they can't crawl out of. The Colts feast on teams that lack the discipline to run against them. We'll see if the Bills can stick to their guns.

Let's hope they win the coin flip, then. I just don't see Anthony Thomas doing much against them. It is rare a RB steps in for the main back on a bad team and blows up. If he's able to break off a big run, he may have a chance of being good fantasy-wise. However, I think the Colts keep them him in check.

With the power backfield of Dayne/Gado/Lundy the Texans put up 98 yards (the lowest of any team all year vs. Indy) and a 4.9 ypc at Indy despite losing 43-24. The Texans have the 28th best running game in the NFL. I view this as a probable stat line for A-train except that he won't share the ball between 3 backs. I'll take 98 yards and a TD for a week 10 WW pickup. I don't know why people are so concerned with a blowout. Indy has blown out two teams all year, the Texans/Skins. Their scores have been....Giants 26-21Texans 43-24Jax 21-14Jets 21-14Titans 14-13Skins 36-22Den 34-31NE 27-20

 

[BigTex]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).

When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.The Colts have played against some damn good rbs:

Portis

Tikki

Dillon

Taylor/Drew

They've faced the great Denver OL

So, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

That's possible. But I think the Bills know their best chance is to slow the game down and keep Manning off the field. If they try to play catchup with the passing game, they'll quickly find themselves in a hole they can't crawl out of. The Colts feast on teams that lack the discipline to run against them. We'll see if the Bills can stick to their guns.

Let's hope they win the coin flip, then. I just don't see Anthony Thomas doing much against them. It is rare a RB steps in for the main back on a bad team and blows up. If he's able to break off a big run, he may have a chance of being good fantasy-wise. However, I think the Colts keep them him in check.

With the power backfield of Dayne/Gado/Lundy the Texans put up 98 yards (the lowest of any team all year vs. Indy) and a 4.9 ypc at Indy despite losing 43-24. The Texans have the 28th best running game in the NFL. I view this as a probable stat line for A-train except that he won't share the ball between 3 backs. I'll take 98 yards and a TD for a week 10 WW pickup. I don't know why people are so concerned with a blowout. Indy has blown out two teams all year, the Texans/Skins. Their scores have been....

Giants 26-21

Texans 43-24

Jax 21-14

Jets 21-14

Titans 14-13

Skins 36-22

Den 34-31

NE 27-20

Banger, we can make analysis for or against playing A-Train and still have a valid point. If I had absolutely no choice, it would be strongly considered (maybe). But that's just my opinion, I'm not saying you should not start him, hell that's your decision. Right or wrong, I'm making an argument of why I'm not benching another player for A-Train which is the title of this thread. And it's not a slam dunk 100yds/TD for A-Train like many are leading to think.P.S.

After watching what Miami did to Chicago, anything's possible.

 

[Grigs Allmoon]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor... Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. BryantBoth can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.The Colts have played against some damn good rbsortisTikkiDillonTaylor/DrewThey've faced the great Denver OLSo, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

That's possible. But I think the Bills know their best chance is to slow the game down and keep Manning off the field. If they try to play catchup with the passing game, they'll quickly find themselves in a hole they can't crawl out of. The Colts feast on teams that lack the discipline to run against them. We'll see if the Bills can stick to their guns.

Let's hope they win the coin flip, then. I just don't see Anthony Thomas doing much against them. It is rare a RB steps in for the main back on a bad team and blows up. If he's able to break off a big run, he may have a chance of being good fantasy-wise. However, I think the Colts keep them him in check.

Now you're just spewing garbage since that's pretty much exactly what he did last week.

It's actually quite common for backup RBs to step in and have very productive games.FWIW, I am also considering starting A-Train over Rudi.

 

[pantagrapher]

FWIS, I'm an owner of any player on either of these teams, I was lucky enough to trade WilMac before his injury. But WilMac struggled with this OL and now we want to believe that A-Train (eventhough it's a good matchup) is going to produce 100yds/TD.

I just don't think it's a slam dunk this week like many of you are thinking. When Manning a company play this week, before they ever hit the field, Buff will be behind by 14pts.

Considering who Indi has played, their D is not as bad as some are making it out to be. I'm not into making predictions, I NEVER have. But buyer beware.

Some in this thread are actually contenplating starting him over guys that have produced in starting rolls. LOL.

If you're thinking of playing him I'd like to know your record and other options.

So you don't make predictions, but you mock predictions nobody else is making. Nobody called A-Train a slam dunk. But it's a good thing you're here to tell us he isn't one.

 

[BigTex]

FWIS, I'm an owner of any player on either of these teams, I was lucky enough to trade WilMac before his injury. But WilMac struggled with this OL and now we want to believe that A-Train (eventhough it's a good matchup) is going to produce 100yds/TD.

I just don't think it's a slam dunk this week like many of you are thinking. When Manning a company play this week, before they ever hit the field, Buff will be behind by 14pts.

Considering who Indi has played, their D is not as bad as some are making it out to be. I'm not into making predictions, I NEVER have. But buyer beware.

Some in this thread are actually contenplating starting him over guys that have produced in starting rolls. LOL.

If you're thinking of playing him I'd like to know your record and other options.

So you don't make predictions, but you mock predictions nobody else is making. Nobody called A-Train a slam dunk. But it's a good thing you're here to tell us he isn't one.

Really? Were do you see any predictions being "mocked?" You're welcome, that's what I'm here for, to correct you in your errors.And it's sooooo typical.

 

[pantagrapher]

Banger, we can make analysis for or against playing A-Train and still have a valid point. If I had absolutely no choice, it would be strongly considered (maybe). But that's just my opinion, I'm not saying you should not start him, hell that's your decision. Right or wrong, I'm making an argument of why I'm not benching another player for A-Train which is the title of this thread. And it's not a slam dunk 100yds/TD for A-Train like many are leading to think.

P.S.

After watching what Miami did to Chicago, anything's possible.

There you go again.

 

[BigTex]

Banger, we can make analysis for or against playing A-Train and still have a valid point. If I had absolutely no choice, it would be strongly considered (maybe). But that's just my opinion, I'm not saying you should not start him, hell that's your decision. Right or wrong, I'm making an argument of why I'm not benching another player for A-Train which is the title of this thread. And it's not a slam dunk 100yds/TD for A-Train like many are leading to think.

P.S.

After watching what Miami did to Chicago, anything's possible.

There you go again.

 

[Banger]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor...

Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).

When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. Bryant

Both can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.

The Colts have played against some damn good rbs:

Portis

Tikki

Dillon

Taylor/Drew

They've faced the great Denver OL

So, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

That's possible. But I think the Bills know their best chance is to slow the game down and keep Manning off the field. If they try to play catchup with the passing game, they'll quickly find themselves in a hole they can't crawl out of. The Colts feast on teams that lack the discipline to run against them. We'll see if the Bills can stick to their guns.

Let's hope they win the coin flip, then. I just don't see Anthony Thomas doing much against them. It is rare a RB steps in for the main back on a bad team and blows up. If he's able to break off a big run, he may have a chance of being good fantasy-wise. However, I think the Colts keep them him in check.

With the power backfield of Dayne/Gado/Lundy the Texans put up 98 yards (the lowest of any team all year vs. Indy) and a 4.9 ypc at Indy despite losing 43-24. The Texans have the 28th best running game in the NFL. I view this as a probable stat line for A-train except that he won't share the ball between 3 backs. I'll take 98 yards and a TD for a week 10 WW pickup.

I don't know why people are so concerned with a blowout. Indy has blown out two teams all year, the Texans/Skins. Their scores have been....

Giants 26-21

Texans 43-24

Jax 21-14

Jets 21-14

Titans 14-13

Skins 36-22

Den 34-31

NE 27-20

Banger, we can make analysis for or against playing A-Train and still have a valid point. If I had absolutely no choice, it would be strongly considered (maybe). But that's just my opinion, I'm not saying you should not start him, hell that's your decision. Right or wrong, I'm making an argument of why I'm not benching another player for A-Train which is the title of this thread. And it's not a slam dunk 100yds/TD for A-Train like many are leading to think.

Agreed. Everything has to be taken in context with respect to your lineup, scoring system, etc. I'm just trying to point out that to date Indy has stopped no one from running the ball, whether it be a blowout, tight game, good running team, bad running team, home, road, it hasn't mattered. Nothing is absolute and there are no guarantees but based on Indy's track record to date I think it's more likely that A-Train has a good game than it is that he has a bad game (since no team has so far). Is it possible that he goes out and get snuffed? Absolutely.

Indy averages 31.5 carries/game against and the lowest by any team was the Texans with 20. I think it's very likely that he gets at least 20 carries. Last week after Willis got hurt midway through the 1st qtr he ran for 20-95 and a TD vs. GB who has the 10th ranked rush defense in the league.

 

[BigTex]

Is this the same guy that got beat out by Tyson Thompson?

Yes, fortunately there is no Fantasy position for Special Teams contributor...

Fact is, Indianapolis gives up 33% more rushing yards than what their opponent typcially averages and that is counting their averages with their inflated stats against Indy. Combine that with Buffalo's 100.8 YPG average, this trend indicates that Buffalo could go for 130-135 rushing yard (which would be a comparatively good game for the Indy rushing defense).

When you also consider that there is no other RB on the roster with a carry this season (who'll be active), I think A-Train really looks attractive.

A-Train = A. Bryant

Both can't keep their job, both have some talent, both will give you hope by displaying a good game or two. But one day you'll wake up to only be disapointed by another wet dream.

What's your beef? We're talking about starting him this week, not propping him up as a fantasy savior. Do you think he's a bad start this week, or are you just trolling?

IMHO eventhough the matchup seems to look good for him, I'm not buying it. His stop here in Dallas was pathetic to say the least. If he was playing St. Mary's school girls of the blind, cripple and crazy, I'd still believe the same.

The Colts have played against some damn good rbs:

Portis

Tikki

Dillon

Taylor/Drew

They've faced the great Denver OL

So, what would you expect their stats to look like after they've faced murderers row?

Your muderers row is missing Ruth and Gehrig

I think that kind of proves his point. The fact that they haven't faced LT or LJ and they are still the worst run defense in the history of the NFL says something. However, with the Bills being down so quickly, Anthony Thomas will see very little action. Losman will probably finish with 45 passes.

That's possible. But I think the Bills know their best chance is to slow the game down and keep Manning off the field. If they try to play catchup with the passing game, they'll quickly find themselves in a hole they can't crawl out of. The Colts feast on teams that lack the discipline to run against them. We'll see if the Bills can stick to their guns.

Let's hope they win the coin flip, then. I just don't see Anthony Thomas doing much against them. It is rare a RB steps in for the main back on a bad team and blows up. If he's able to break off a big run, he may have a chance of being good fantasy-wise. However, I think the Colts keep them him in check.

With the power backfield of Dayne/Gado/Lundy the Texans put up 98 yards (the lowest of any team all year vs. Indy) and a 4.9 ypc at Indy despite losing 43-24. The Texans have the 28th best running game in the NFL. I view this as a probable stat line for A-train except that he won't share the ball between 3 backs. I'll take 98 yards and a TD for a week 10 WW pickup.

I don't know why people are so concerned with a blowout. Indy has blown out two teams all year, the Texans/Skins. Their scores have been....

Giants 26-21

Texans 43-24

Jax 21-14

Jets 21-14

Titans 14-13

Skins 36-22

Den 34-31

NE 27-20

Banger, we can make analysis for or against playing A-Train and still have a valid point. If I had absolutely no choice, it would be strongly considered (maybe). But that's just my opinion, I'm not saying you should not start him, hell that's your decision. Right or wrong, I'm making an argument of why I'm not benching another player for A-Train which is the title of this thread. And it's not a slam dunk 100yds/TD for A-Train like many are leading to think.

Agreed. Everything has to be taken in context with respect to your lineup, scoring system, etc. I'm just trying to point out that to date Indy has stopped no one from running the ball, whether it be a blowout, tight game, good running team, bad running team, home, road, it hasn't mattered. Nothing is absolute and there are no guarantees but based on Indy's track record to date I think it's more likely that A-Train has a good game than it is that he has a bad game (since no team has so far). Is it possible that he goes out and get snuffed? Absolutely.

Indy averages 31.5 carries/game against and the lowest by any team was the Texans with 20. I think it's very likely that he gets at least 20 carries. Last week after Willis got hurt midway through the 1st qtr he ran for 20-95 and a TD vs. GB who has the 10th ranked rush defense in the league.

We are in an agreement.

 

[Wilbur Wood]

FWIS, I'm an owner of any player on either of these teams, I was lucky enough to trade WilMac before his injury. But WilMac struggled with this OL and now we want to believe that A-Train (eventhough it's a good matchup) is going to produce 100yds/TD.

I just don't think it's a slam dunk this week like many of you are thinking. When Manning a company play this week, before they ever hit the field, Buff will be behind by 14pts.

Considering who Indi has played, their D is not as bad as some are making it out to be. I'm not into making predictions, I NEVER have. But buyer beware.

Some in this thread are actually contenplating starting him over guys that have produced in starting rolls. LOL.

If you're thinking of playing him I'd like to know your record and other options.

How about in a PPR format instead of Larry Fitz at Flex??? Rationale being that Fitz will take a little time to work back into the flow of real games and he has not played at all with Leinert (think that this week that Boldin will outpoint Fitz)