Who would you stash away on Taxi Squad? A Miller or D Samuel (1 Viewer)

[jwsbowler]

Dynasty format contract style, 12 teams, no PPR.  We can stash a rookie for up to 2 years on our taxi squad... 4 spots.  The other 3 spots are already taken  Trying to figure out who would perform better right now between Anthony Miller or Deebo Samuel?  Can hold Miller for one more year on TS or Samuel for next 2 years, which probably will not do if I project it right.  Signing either to a multiple year contract is not an issue as I have the cap space to do it. 

So, who would you like to stash away on your TS and who goes on your active roster? 

 

[Gally]

I think Deebo is the most volatile.  He has the lowest floor and the highest ceiling.  He is perfect for a taxi squad.  Can you activate from the taxi squad mid year? 

I think Miller is what he is.  You say his situation last year.  I don't think it changes much.  He is a WR3/Flex for the most part and a guy you can plug in as a bye week replacement and he will do ok. 

Without really understanding the nuances of how your league works it's tough to say for sure which is the best way to go.  If you want a higher floor activate Miller.  If you want the higher ceiling go with Deebo.  For me I probably stash Deebo to get a better idea of what you got with him before having to make a real decision. 

 

[jwsbowler]

I think Deebo is the most volatile.  He has the lowest floor and the highest ceiling.  He is perfect for a taxi squad.  Can you activate from the taxi squad mid year? 

I think Miller is what he is.  You say his situation last year.  I don't think it changes much.  He is a WR3/Flex for the most part and a guy you can plug in as a bye week replacement and he will do ok. 

Without really understanding the nuances of how your league works it's tough to say for sure which is the best way to go.  If you want a higher floor activate Miller.  If you want the higher ceiling go with Deebo.  For me I probably stash Deebo to get a better idea of what you got with him before having to make a real decision. 

Thanks Gally, I always respect your opinion.  Yes, we can activate in mid season, so that is not a issue either.  It's just a way to save a player for next year without wasting a contract year as we do have a cap.  This WR would be #5 in the pecking order for the team.  

My initial thought was activate Deebo for that high end capability and that Miller is "dinged" with the ankle concern, which is not a major concern.  But, then I was 2nd guessing myself as I need to make the decision today.  To me, going either way would work.  

 

[Gally]

Thanks Gally, I always respect your opinion.  Yes, we can activate in mid season, so that is not a issue either.  It's just a way to save a player for next year without wasting a contract year as we do have a cap.  This WR would be #5 in the pecking order for the team.  

My initial thought was activate Deebo for that high end capability and that Miller is "dinged" with the ankle concern, which is not a major concern.  But, then I was 2nd guessing myself as I need to make the decision today.  To me, going either way would work.  

Since its for your WR5 I would activate Miller because I think Deebo has the higher long term upside and by using the TS for Deebo you gain a year of control to allow him to hit that potential.   If something changes mid season and Deebo is already hitting his potential and you need him you can shift then. 

 

[jwsbowler]

Since its for your WR5 I would activate Miller because I think Deebo has the higher long term upside and by using the TS for Deebo you gain a year of control to allow him to hit that potential.   If something changes mid season and Deebo is already hitting his potential and you need him you can shift then. 

That's the game plan now...  THANKS