Who's overvalued? Who's undervalued? (1 Viewer)

[Doug Drinen]

If you're a subscriber, click here to cast your votes for which players you think are over- and under-valued at their current ADP.

This is sort of experimental for now, but if all goes well, your aggregated votes will end up on various pages of the site, like the player pages, the ADP page, and maybe the rankings and projections pages. In the bigger picture, one of our long term goals here at FBG is to create more features that allow users to interact with the site and with each other, to make the site a little more participatory. This is a small step along that road.

 

[DaddyFatSacks]

If you're a subscriber, click here to cast your votes for which players you think are over- and under-valued at their current ADP.

This is sort of experimental for now, but if all goes well, your aggregated votes will end up on various pages of the site, like the player pages, the ADP page, and maybe the rankings and projections pages. In the bigger picture, one of our long term goals here at FBG is to create more features that allow users to interact with the site and with each other, to make the site a little more participatory. This is a small step along that road.

Haven't even clicked the link yet but seems like a great idea!

 

[MCguidance]

This is going to take more time than I thought - so I have definitely decided to devote more to it later. Really like this idea

 

[Captain Hook]

GREAT idea and format Doug

 

[by_the_sea_wannabe]

so for example if say Tom Brady is #99 overall and the #1 qb, if we think his qb rank is right but is vastly underrated at #99 overall should we vote underrated?

 

[Verbal Kint]

Favre

 

[FUBAR]

Why is it that I feel compelled to list one overvalued for every undervalued, but it's harder to?

 

[FantasyTrader]

Why is it that I feel compelled to list one overvalued for every undervalued, but it's harder to?

1) Because when you look back on any given year, the circumstances which made a player overvalued tend to unfold inseason and the circumstances which made a player undervalued tend to unfold the previous offseason. Think about it.2) There's a smaller pool of players that CAN be overvalued to players who could be undervalued.

 

[pizzatyme]

If you're a subscriber, click here to cast your votes for which players you think are over- and under-valued at their current ADP.

This is sort of experimental for now, but if all goes well, your aggregated votes will end up on various pages of the site, like the player pages, the ADP page, and maybe the rankings and projections pages. In the bigger picture, one of our long term goals here at FBG is to create more features that allow users to interact with the site and with each other, to make the site a little more participatory. This is a small step along that road.

Haven't even clicked the link yet but seems like a great idea!

Thanks, I suggested this the last 3 years...lolAlong with several others.

 

[pizzatyme]

so for example if say Tom Brady is #99 overall and the #1 qb, if we think his qb rank is right but is vastly underrated at #99 overall should we vote underrated?

Over/Under valued in comparison to all others, not just within his position, I believe.

 

[pizzatyme]

Doug,

A couple of suggestions...

I'd offer 5 buttons to get a better variance. Very, slightly, appropriate, slightly over, very over, etc.

It would be nice to see the composite and to be able to select some users to include/exclude their selections.

Good work thus far.

 

[Doug Drinen]

Bump.

This data is now on the player pages. Guess who this guy is:

http://subscribers.footballguys.com/players/AndeDe00-1.php

FBG suscriber opinions:

He is good value at his current ADP: 4.3%

His ADP is appropriate: 34.8%

He is not worth drafting at his current ADP: 60.9%

 

[Banger]

Bump.

This data is now on the player pages. Guess who this guy is:

http://subscribers.footballguys.com/players/AndeDe00-1.php

FBG suscriber opinions:

He is good value at his current ADP: 4.3%

His ADP is appropriate: 34.8%

He is not worth drafting at his current ADP: 60.9%

it's funny that's the first guy that jumped out to me.