Will the real Donovan McNabb please step forward... (1 Viewer)

[dawgtrails]

McNabb. Fantasy points (in my scoring league) the past 5 years.

2006-1st??

2005-19th

2004-3rd

2003-12th

2002-14th

2001-5th

Can we expect this going forward this year? He has played Houston and New York...not known as defensive savants.

What can we expect? A top 5 fantasy season? Is Stallworth for real? Will Westbrook get hurt? Are there too many unknowns to get a good grasp on his future?

Is he a sell high candidate, not unlike others mentioned (Gore, Coles, etc...)

 

[Tick]

He's in his prime, he's shown he can do it without TO, he's healthy... I see no reason to sell high - hold high instead.

 

[Ilov80s]

McNabb. Fantasy points (in my scoring league) the past 5 years.2006-1st??2005-19th2004-3rd2003-12th2002-14th2001-5thCan we expect this going forward this year? He has played Houston and New York...not known as defensive savants.What can we expect? A top 5 fantasy season? Is Stallworth for real? Will Westbrook get hurt? Are there too many unknowns to get a good grasp on his future?Is he a sell high candidate, not unlike others mentioned (Gore, Coles, etc...)

2002: injured in 11th game, missed rest of season.2005: Injured for most of the season, only started 9 games It is also worth noting that had McNabb not been hurt in 02, he was on pace to be the #1 QB. He was averaging 2.5 more points per game then the next best QB. Clearly McNabb was underrated in 06 and is a stud.

 

[[scooter]]

McNabb. Fantasy points (in my scoring league) the past 5 years.

2006-1st??

2005-19th - - was injured, only played 9 games

2004-3rd

2003-12th

2002-14th - was injured, only played 10 games

2001-5th

McNabb has always been a monster when healthy. He was a stud before TO, and he'll continue to be a stud after TO.

 

[dawgtrails]

' date='Sep 21 2006, 09:33 PM' post='5571592']

McNabb. Fantasy points (in my scoring league) the past 5 years.

2006-1st??

2005-19th - - was injured, only played 9 games

2004-3rd

2003-12th

2002-14th - was injured, only played 10 games

2001-5th

McNabb has always been a monster when healthy. He was a stud before TO, and he'll continue to be a stud after TO.

Excellent points.Does his previous injuries make him more likely to get injured again?

Or, because he has seemed to become less of a runner, and more of a passer, he will continue to be qa dominant fantasy QB?

I think the latter, but am worried about the former.

 

[Jason Wood]

McNabb. Fantasy points (in my scoring league) the past 5 years.2006-1st??2005-19th2004-3rd2003-12th2002-14th2001-5thCan we expect this going forward this year? He has played Houston and New York...not known as defensive savants.What can we expect? A top 5 fantasy season? Is Stallworth for real? Will Westbrook get hurt? Are there too many unknowns to get a good grasp on his future?Is he a sell high candidate, not unlike others mentioned (Gore, Coles, etc...)

Hey dawgtrails,McNabb's numbers there are misleading because of injury. If you compared his finishes in your league on a points per game basis, you would see he's typically an excellent fantasy option and it would make your decision a much easier one.J

 

[gman8343]

McNabb is awesome, and I'm a Giant fan so that's hard to admit.

 

[cstu]

McNabb is awesome, and I'm a Giant fan so that's hard to admit.

I love McNabb, but I find it incredibly frustrating to watch a guy as good as he is randomly throw passes to the ground 5 yards in front of receivers. It's crazy to watch him do that one play and then throw an absolutely perfect pass the next. All I can say is that at least it's better than overthrowing receivers and getting ball picked off.

 

[Homer]

I don't have McNabb in any league (wouldn't touch him with a Stretch Pulawski -- NOT my line), but I DID jump all over the Philly D based on their cupcake schedule. In the NFL there are severely tangible benefits from mailing it in the season before...

 

[Football Jones]

This is the real McNabb. Forget last year. When he's healthy, he's right up there with Peyton & Palmer (if not better, FF-wise).

 

[thayman]

McNabb. Fantasy points (in my scoring league) the past 5 years.2006-1st??2005-19th2004-3rd2003-12th2002-14th2001-5thCan we expect this going forward this year? He has played Houston and New York...not known as defensive savants.What can we expect? A top 5 fantasy season? Is Stallworth for real? Will Westbrook get hurt? Are there too many unknowns to get a good grasp on his future?Is he a sell high candidate, not unlike others mentioned (Gore, Coles, etc...)

2002: injured in 11th game, missed rest of season.2005: Injured for most of the season, only started 9 games It is also worth noting that had McNabb not been hurt in 02, he was on pace to be the #1 QB. He was averaging 2.5 more points per game then the next best QB. Clearly McNabb was underrated in 06 and is a stud.