Would u trade S.Barkley + B.Roethlisberger for N.Chubb + B.Mayfield? (1 Viewer)

[Saboo]

1/2 point ppl league with td’s counting for ten points (qb’s much more important than standard leagues) would you trade Barkley + Big Ben for Nick Chubb and B.Mayfield?

 

[beerbuff]

It's not bad but unless it was dynasty I'd probably pass.

 

[Saboo]

Thanks for the help. It’s a redraft league where qb’s count for a lot. I’m stuck with J.Winston and Ben Roethlisberger. I think Winston could have a great season but I don’t totally trust him.

 

[lostxn]

I would leave this trade. Mayfield could be awesome or a bust in year 2. Big Ben should stay consistent and you already have one of the best RBs in the game. All eggs in the Cleveland basket scares me...

 

[travdogg]

I'd pass. I like the Browns guys, but Barkley is on another level, and Big Ben is still very solid, and possibly just as good as Mayfield, for 1 more year.

 

[bhsutton]

Don't take that trade.  I don't think you want both cleveland browns.  Likely when when scores the other is not.  Big Ben was a top 5 QB last year in most set ups.  He will be again this year.  Barkley will outscore Chubb most likely and Hunt comes back around week 8.

 

[Gally]

Just because all QB's are worth 10 does not increase QB value.   All QB scoring goes up so their relative value within the position remains the same. 

That being said I think I would rather keep Barkley and since it is redraft the youth of Baker doesn't really get you anything so it diminishes the value on that side a bit. 

 

[Saboo]

Thanks for all the help. This I agree with most of the opinions my only issue is I don’t think I can win with J.Winston and Roethlisberger.

 

[az_prof]

No. Barkeley>Chubb

Roth=Mayfield

 

[49erFthFll]

Definite no.  I think Mayfield and Big Ben end up around the same this year, top 10-15.  I like Winston's upside.  Barkley is a no brainer every week.  Chubb in week 10 gets Hunt to contend with, and will make you question playing time heading into the playoffs.