Todd from Utah
Footballguy
Yeah, I dont think anyone really would have cared if players didn't look the same as their real life counterparts. And its not like the faces were even remotely detailed anyway.Thats the thing I didnt get. Way back when they release the game without names and it was numbers only. Do the same thing but make the likenesses off - then wait for the roster dudes to clean it up. I dont really care if the computer guy looks like some college kid
But it was still obvious to anyone who every player was supposed to be. Florida QB-15 was a white, 99 rated, left handed throwing, well built QB who could run. Combine with that the fact that the rosters were so easily editable, and pretty much any court would agree that they were circumventing the spirit of the law and stealing their likenesses. Of course, the schools themselves were doing the exact same thing by selling Florida # 15 jerseys in the book store, but here we are.
For me, the appeal of a college football (or basketball game) was dynasty mode. In NCAA football, I usually plowed through about a season a week, so 3 weeks after getting the game, the rosters were all randomly generated recruits anyway. So they can just use 100% randomized names and stats for the starting rosters for all I care. I imagine they'd tailor the starting rosters so that the historically great teams were great (and the bad teams bad, plus everything in between.
I dont know why EA would even bother negotiating for the rights of the current college kids. Seems like a big waste of money to me. As I believe someone else suggested a while back in this thread, I'd concentrate on scooping as many "legends" as possible for ultimate team.
Last edited by a moderator: