Responses So far (Trying to wait till everyone is ready for the bottles to be revealed):
Bucket List Survey: https://forms.gle/oo8swXQcDxX6ymhP8
Thanks to Bluesbomber, BrutalPenguin, Man with no name, and Gamma for completing so far!
@mr roboto pending
Spectrum List Survey: https://forms.gle/QYQ9VM8n6UmqNoYbA
|Thanks to George? and Redwes so far! Pending
@Instinctive @Nathan R. Jessep @Freak Show
Now, Since Top Shelf Samples were shipped labeled I can reveal them and the results, even though we only have 5 of 6 responses
at the survey.
EH Taylor : Four Grain (Special Release from 2018 IIRC) - Won Whiskey of the year.
2 folks rated Exceptional (5/5), 1 rated Very Good (4/5).
Notes:
"EH 4 grain, delicious but last and was hammered by then."
"EH Taylor Four Grain - Exceptional sample. Smooth with a little heat. EH Taylor never lets me down."
EH Taylor 4 grain - wonderful flavor. This felt like the perfect whiskey
--
"Pappy" Van Winkle Lot B 12 Year
3 Rated Very Good
Notes:
Pappy Lot B - super smooth - but almost too smooth. I like a little kick. For sure this was the smoothest of all samples.
Pappy, so smooth there was no bite or real flavor. Kind of lost a star for the no bite, that said it was so smooth I’d probably drink the entire bottle in one sitting if it was in front of me.
Van WInkle 12 Yr - This was very good but not exceptional. Shared sample with brother in law. I think this sample is "hurt" by the expectations being "Pappy". You expect it to be amazing, and while it is very good... I think because your expectations are unreasonable, it mentally lets you down.
--
Willett Family Estate 12yr
2 folks rated Exceptional
Notes:
Willett 12 - damn - good stuff! Loved the bite.
Willett family estate 12 year - This was an exceptional sample. Smooth with some heat. Sweet finish. REALLY need to find a bottle of this for my own now!
--
Willett Family Estate 11yr
1 person rated it Very Good
Notes:
Willett 11 year, bam hits you with bite from the first sip.
--
BTAC - Thomas H Handy Rye
2 Exceptional / 1 Very Good
Notes:
Thomas Handy rye - one of my favorite whiskeys. This is the only one I've had before, but I just wanted to have it again. Ryes are my favorite, and this one is top of the list
Thomas H Handy Rye - This was spicy and unique. Being a rye it of course has more bite. Very good rating.
Btac handy rye, I wish I had a cigar to have paired with this. Bold and lip numbing.
--
BTAC - William Larue Weller
1 Average (3/5)
Notes:
BTAC WLW - Of all, this was my least favorite. I am now five whiskeys in so this is the extent of my review
--
BTAC - George T Stagg
None of the 3 had this
--
Old Forrester Birthday Bourbon 2016
1 Exceptional
Birthday bourbon, my purpose in life is to find a bottle every September when it’s released. Fan ####### tastic
--
Old Commonwealth - Van Winkle 1992
1 Exceptional
1992 Old commonwealth - Amazing sample. Smooth, cinnamon finish. Blew my socks off.
--
??? Mystery Sample - TBD... will be revealed once other groups test it.
I will say it's the most polarizing sample across all groups with scores ranging from 1 to 5 and comments going from
"far and away favorite" to "This was absolutely terrible!"
--
Overall Notes / Comments:
This is a blast! I really appreciate you doing it. It would be interesting to know the price points of these whiskeys. They were really really good.
Icon is the man. Very awesome setting this up for everyone. Most of us never have a chance at finding most of these samples.
There was no second through five, just 1b, 1c...