What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Your mt rushmore of sitcoms (1 Viewer)

Good start. I Love Lucy and All in the Family are 2 first ballot no brainers. It get harder from there. I’d put Seinfeld up there. Fourth one is tough.  Debating 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've watched a lot of older sitcoms, but I'm far too ignorant do this based on long-term impact.

So, I've just got to go with my 4 favorite: Parks and Rec, The Office, Arrested Development, and the either Seinfeld or It's Always Sunny. 

As an aside, there's an alternate universe where The Cosby Show gets a lot of mentions here. 

 
pollardsvision said:
I've watched a lot of older sitcoms, but I'm far too ignorant do this based on long-term impact.

So, I've just got to go with my 4 favorite: Parks and Rec, The Office, Arrested Development, and the either Seinfeld or It's Always Sunny. 

As an aside, there's an alternate universe where The Cosby Show gets a lot of mentions here. 
Click to expand...
The office and park and rec are basically the same show.

 
Always Sunny

Seinfeld

Curb Your Enthusiasm

Not Rushmore yet but Derry Girls is rising for me, I've watched it 3 times.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
30 Rock 

Seinfeld

The Mary Tyler Moore Show

Blackadder

ETA: if Rushmore connotes "American", gimme The Simpsons

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Cheers/Frasier

Seinfeld when it's not too painful to watch

The Simpsons

Other than that, comedy is so time-bound that I feel bad listing older or later ones (neither of which are funny unless you're in the grips of the show's context)

 
(I don't think I can adequately rate any sitcoms pre 90s.)

Seinfeld

The Office

Parks and Rec

Big Bang Theory

Community (surprised it hasn't been mentioned yet)

Schitts Creek is nearing this list for me.

 
The young people on here will have no idea how good MASH and All in the Family were.   I don't consider animated.  Simpsons was great.  But it's easier to make animated stay relevant over years.

Seinfeld

MASH

All in the Family

The Office

Friends, Cheers, Modern Family ... those were good too.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Brunell4MVP said:
The young people on here will have no idea how good MASH and All in the Family were.   I don't consider animated.  Simpsons was great.  But it's easier to make animated stay relevant over years.
Click to expand...
The Gelbart years of M*A*S*H were as good as it gets. The Reynolds/Alda years are why it's not on my Rushmore.

I was in the comedy biz during All In The Family reign. We (the Emerson College crowd and the guys who were doing standup in stripjoints & Chinese restaurants before Boston had comedy clubs) discussed AitF a LOT because it wasn't the least bit funny and had America rolling. We never figured it out...

MTM beat em both by a mile.

 
MASH
Cheers
Seinfeld   (or Friends)
Modern Family  (or Big Bang Theory)

I think the above covers 4 decades

 
  • Andy Griffith
  • Parks and Rec
  • The Office
  • Seinfeld
Really thought about putting Community in that last spot, but it had a dramatic drop off after Season 3.  

 
Brunell4MVP said:
The young people on here will have no idea how good MASH and All in the Family were.   I don't consider animated.  Simpsons was great.  But it's easier to make animated stay relevant over years.

Seinfeld

MASH

All in the Family

The Office

Friends, Cheers, Modern Family ... those were good too.
Click to expand...
I've never understood the love for MASH.  The laugh track alone makes it un-watchable for me.  

Seinfeld

Gilligan's Island 

Sanford & Sons

Cheers  

 
wikkidpissah said:
The Gelbart years of M*A*S*H were as good as it gets. The Reynolds/Alda years are why it's not on my Rushmore.

I was in the comedy biz during All In The Family reign. We (the Emerson College crowd and the guys who were doing standup in stripjoints & Chinese restaurants before Boston had comedy clubs) discussed AitF a LOT because it wasn't the least bit funny and had America rolling. We never figured it out...

MTM beat em both by a mile.
Click to expand...
you know what ...you got spunk

I love spunk

 
Yeah, I get pulled into watching episodes of MASH every once in a while when I'm over at my dad's. I've probably watched like 25 or so. Not sure I've laughed once. I'm not old enough to have seen it live, so maybe that's the issue. But I just find it painfully unfunny.

For me....Seinfeld and the Office are slam dunk choices.  I had never watched Curb (so weird, as I'm a HUGE Seinfeld fan) until quarantine back in March. But it makes my list now. Larry is my spirit animal.

The 4th spot is a tough one.  If we're including animated shows, I'd probably have to choose South Park. Obviously they have the occasional stinker, but I grew up on the show and it still makes me laugh like an idiot at times (even now, pushing into my late 30's).

If no animated shows.....I guess I'd choose Big Bang. I get that its not for everyone and some will mock it but I think the writing was incredibly clever and Parsons did an amazing job carrying it.

 
wikkidpissah said:
The Gelbart years of M*A*S*H were as good as it gets. The Reynolds/Alda years are why it's not on my Rushmore.

I was in the comedy biz during All In The Family reign. We (the Emerson College crowd and the guys who were doing standup in stripjoints & Chinese restaurants before Boston had comedy clubs) discussed AitF a LOT because it wasn't the least bit funny and had America rolling. We never figured it out...

MTM beat em both by a mile.
Click to expand...
AitF was too preachy for me upon rewatching it. I thought it was a blunt instrument where a skewer is usually better. My parents have described its popularity by saying that audiences, despite how obvious a send-up caricature of a man Bunker was, chose to ignore the preachy and laugh at the bigotry because they couldn't be as bad as Archie. But they also, in the dark recesses of their mind, thought Bunker might be right about certain things and found humor in their own closed-mindedness. 

But that's just what I hear. Like I was saying before I decided to respond, the sitcoms I listed were all of my time as a nascent adult or adult.

 
TLEF316 said:
Yeah, I get pulled into watching episodes of MASH every once in a while when I'm over at my dad's. I've probably watched like 25 or so. Not sure I've laughed once. I'm not old enough to have seen it live, so maybe that's the issue. But I just find it painfully unfunny.

For me....Seinfeld and the Office are slam dunk choices.  I had never watched Curb (so weird, as I'm a HUGE Seinfeld fan) until quarantine back in March. But it makes my list now. Larry is my spirit animal.

The 4th spot is a tough one.  If we're including animated shows, I'd probably have to choose South Park. Obviously they have the occasional stinker, but I grew up on the show and it still makes me laugh like an idiot at times (even now, pushing into my late 30's).

If no animated shows.....I guess I'd choose Big Bang. I get that its not for everyone and some will mock it but I think the writing was incredibly clever and Parsons did an amazing job carrying it.
Click to expand...
Yeah - I never got the disdain around here for BBT.  It wouldn't be in my top-4 but it would definitely be in my top-10.

 
Can you really call a show a "sitcom" if it's animated (Simpsons), or if it's filmed on location without a studio audience (The Office, Arrested Development)?

 
rockaction said:
AitF was too preachy for me upon rewatching it. I thought it was a blunt instrument where a skewer is usually better. My parents have described its popularity by saying that audiences, despite how obvious a send-up caricature of a man Bunker was, chose to ignore the preachy and laugh at the bigotry because they couldn't be as bad as Archie. But they also, in the dark recesses of their mind, thought Bunker might be right about certain things and found humor in their own closed-mindedness. 
Click to expand...
Same reason "The Colbert Report" was so popular, imo.

 
Sea Duck said:
Can you really call a show a "sitcom" if it's animated (Simpsons), or if it's filmed on location without a studio audience (The Office, Arrested Development)?
Click to expand...
The Simpsons is so meta about everything you could argue that they're more than conscious enough about the sitcom format that while they get to break rules, they generally adhere to them.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sea Duck said:
Can you really call a show a "sitcom" if it's animated (Simpsons), or if it's filmed on location without a studio audience (The Office, Arrested Development)?
Click to expand...
situational comedy (situation comedy in the U.S.), is a genre of comedy centered on a fixed set of characters who carry over from episode to episode.  I'd say all of those are sitcoms, although I would probably say Animated Sitcom should be seen as different but that's just my personal preference and not strictly going by the definition.

 
Sea Duck said:
Same reason "The Colbert Report" was so popular, imo.
Click to expand...
I don't mean to argue, but I'm really not sure. I think the Colbert Report is distinctly aimed, and the people in on the joke are in on it for what the comedian would call the "right" reasons. Colbert manages to take all the patriotic gin in the world's punch bowl and make it palatable for the teetotalers.

eta* But your broader point is taken. Irony has that tendency to become real in a heartbeat. Ask a million Pabst drinkers circa 2000 what that was all about.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
rockaction said:
AitF was too preachy for me upon rewatching it. I thought it was a blunt instrument where a skewer is usually better. My parents have described its popularity by saying that audiences, despite how obvious a send-up caricature of a man Bunker was, chose to ignore the preachy and laugh at the bigotry because they couldn't be as bad as Archie. But they also, in the dark recesses of their mind, thought Bunker might be right about certain things and found humor in their own closed-mindedness. 

But that's just what I hear. Like I was saying before I decided to respond, the sitcoms I listed were all of my time as a nascent adult or adult.
Click to expand...
There were "Archie Bunker For President" posters hung unironically in the basements and garages of a lot of blue collar workers in the early '70s. 

 
rockaction said:
AitF was too preachy for me upon rewatching it. I thought it was a blunt instrument where a skewer is usually better. My parents have described its popularity by saying that audiences, despite how obvious a send-up caricature of a man Bunker was, chose to ignore the preachy and laugh at the bigotry because they couldn't be as bad as Archie. But they also, in the dark recesses of their mind, thought Bunker might be right about certain things and found humor in their own closed-mindedness. 

But that's just what I hear. Like I was saying before I decided to respond, the sitcoms I listed were all of my time as a nascent adult or adult.
Click to expand...
Hmmm.  Interesting take.  I thought it was a very important show that touched on subjects not being talked about on TV at the time. It was also a relatable show.  I still know people like Archie.

 
rockaction said:
AitF was too preachy for me upon rewatching it. I thought it was a blunt instrument where a skewer is usually better. My parents have described its popularity by saying that audiences, despite how obvious a send-up caricature of a man Bunker was, chose to ignore the preachy and laugh at the bigotry because they couldn't be as bad as Archie. But they also, in the dark recesses of their mind, thought Bunker might be right about certain things and found humor in their own closed-mindedness. 

But that's just what I hear. Like I was saying before I decided to respond, the sitcoms I listed were all of my time as a nascent adult or adult.
Click to expand...
i knew quite a few comics who became comedy writers. their biggest obstacle - besides being ugly & lazy in a town that doesnt abide either - was how hacky the sitcom format (basically, writing to a laugh track) actually was. i think that was the problem we wiseguys had with the Norman Lear tip. It was "new" source material done Lucy style. Instead of Lucy saying WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA when Ricky wouldnt let her in the show, it was Editt exclaiming "Oh Aaawchie" when he'd rail on sumn polite folk didnt talk about. Same with Maude, Jeffersons and blossomed beyond Lear to Sanford & Son and Chico & the Man, Kotter and such. Twas impossible for anyone who respected beats, callbacks, even punchlines when the setup and "Oh my!" riffing was enough

ETA: and the catchphrases......cant forget the catchphrases..

 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

TheBaylorKid
Mount Rushmore 4th of July 2026
Replies
10
Views
223
Terminalxylem
Terminalxylem
Jayrod
  • Poll Poll
How old are you?
2 3 4
Replies
179
Views
3K
FarFromHome
FarFromHome
Yogibear
Question before I take "Bucket List" trip
Replies
9
Views
379
3C's
3C's

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top