What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

Cleveland Browns (15 Viewers)

i kind of feel like that's what these three games are for.if he doesn't show anything they may move on.

or at least come up with a good backup plan, i hope.
The bar should not be set as low as 80 yards without any touchdowns 2 interceptions and only 13 yards on the ground where some idiot will say 'he threw for 100 yards and ran for 30 with a score and only threw 1 pick, he's improving give him MORE TIME.' BS

The kid not only sucked he didn't show anything in camp or preseason or during the season that lead the coaching staff to have any confidence in him so why the hell should we gift him the job? Because he's a damn celebrity? Because he works soo hard? Gimme a break, kid sucks and the only way he should get any break is if he earns it and he hasn't so he's got to do something extra-ordinary just to get a shot IMHO.

The team had better be looking past this kid because he isn't worth giving any time.

Two first round picks and we still need a QB.

When we had Jeff Garcia people said, we got our QB no need to look at a free agent like Drew Brees. When we had Charlie Frye people were afraid we'd draft someone like Aaron Rodgers.

Now we've got Johnny Manziel and if anyone says to stick with him till the wheels fall off their nutz. You do not stick with a kid like Manziel especially if you have two first round picks and the rest of the team has proven they can win with a guy like Brian Hoyer who doesn't suck and he has shown he will work and earn the trust of the vets. Anyone dares to say we should stick with Manziel because they dug their heels in and think everyone else should too is an idiot. I'm not dying on the Johnny Manziel hill just because I didn't rip him from the start. I didn't want us to draft him especially in the first round. Me and Mack both wanted Teddy, I didn't want him with the 4th pick but wanted him with the 26th pick. Johnny was 'ok' with the 26th pick but I was against trading up for him but was 'ok' moving up a few spots and getting Buffalo's 2015 1st and 4th picks plus Gilbert and Manziel because I thought if Johnny sucked we'd have 2 first round picks to get a legit QB in 2015 and well he sucks so don't hesitate go get the QB because we still need one.

If people have to dig their heels in and die on some asinine argument mountain then this is mine. Kid sucks so lets go get a real quarterback in 2015.
So you are ok drafting a QB with the 26th pick and then just giving up on him after three games (if all three are bad)??

Talk about butz.

I totally agree about Johnny sucking, but if you are personally "ok" with taking a QB at 26 then throwing him away after three games, YOU are nuts.

 
i kind of feel like that's what these three games are for.if he doesn't show anything they may move on.

or at least come up with a good backup plan, i hope.
The bar should not be set as low as 80 yards without any touchdowns 2 interceptions and only 13 yards on the ground where some idiot will say 'he threw for 100 yards and ran for 30 with a score and only threw 1 pick, he's improving give him MORE TIME.' BS

The kid not only sucked he didn't show anything in camp or preseason or during the season that lead the coaching staff to have any confidence in him so why the hell should we gift him the job? Because he's a damn celebrity? Because he works soo hard? Gimme a break, kid sucks and the only way he should get any break is if he earns it and he hasn't so he's got to do something extra-ordinary just to get a shot IMHO.

The team had better be looking past this kid because he isn't worth giving any time.

Two first round picks and we still need a QB.

When we had Jeff Garcia people said, we got our QB no need to look at a free agent like Drew Brees. When we had Charlie Frye people were afraid we'd draft someone like Aaron Rodgers.

Now we've got Johnny Manziel and if anyone says to stick with him till the wheels fall off their nutz. You do not stick with a kid like Manziel especially if you have two first round picks and the rest of the team has proven they can win with a guy like Brian Hoyer who doesn't suck and he has shown he will work and earn the trust of the vets. Anyone dares to say we should stick with Manziel because they dug their heels in and think everyone else should too is an idiot. I'm not dying on the Johnny Manziel hill just because I didn't rip him from the start. I didn't want us to draft him especially in the first round. Me and Mack both wanted Teddy, I didn't want him with the 4th pick but wanted him with the 26th pick. Johnny was 'ok' with the 26th pick but I was against trading up for him but was 'ok' moving up a few spots and getting Buffalo's 2015 1st and 4th picks plus Gilbert and Manziel because I thought if Johnny sucked we'd have 2 first round picks to get a legit QB in 2015 and well he sucks so don't hesitate go get the QB because we still need one.

If people have to dig their heels in and die on some asinine argument mountain then this is mine. Kid sucks so lets go get a real quarterback in 2015.
So you are ok drafting a QB with the 26th pick and then just giving up on him after three games (if all three are bad)??

Talk about butz.

I totally agree about Johnny sucking, but if you are personally "ok" with taking a QB at 26 then throwing him away after three games, YOU are nuts.
You could give him a year and call him Weeden.

 
You could give him a year and call him Weeden.
If that is the case, so be it.

Again, my personal opinion is to get rid of him right now cause I never cared for him at all.

But if a front office drafts a QB in the first round and moves on after three games, no matter how bad those three games are, they should be fired.

 
You could give him a year and call him Weeden.
If that is the case, so be it.

Again, my personal opinion is to get rid of him right now cause I never cared for him at all.

But if a front office drafts a QB in the first round and moves on after three games, no matter how bad those three games are, they should be fired.
I was making fun of the run of QB selections by Browns brass. Manziel done for the day. Injured running a QB sweep.

 
Any chance the Brown go QB in the first round again? The way the cap is, I've always thought it made sense if the player grades out as a top 30 pick.

 
Any chance the Brown go QB in the first round again? The way the cap is, I've always thought it made sense if the player grades out as a top 30 pick.
They'd have to trade up on order for the value to be there. So, I doubt it... Highly doubt it. Winston and Mariota are likely top 5 picks. The drop after them is huge. Maybe someone emerges between now and then but I'm not sure who that could be.

 
Saw the game up close and personal today. My observations:

1. Johnny is no where near NFL ready. The first pass he threw to the wrong spot set the tone for the day. He had some serious zip on a few passes but the offense just does not move with him running it. The lineman don't block well and he has rookie happy feet so even if they are on a block they have no idea where Johnny is.

2. The defensive backfield are all trying to get on ESPN with big hits. Not a ####### one of them can tackle to save their life, it was pitiful to watch. I know the whole NFL is that way but it doesn't make it any better. I'd run tackling drills until they break something.

3. Hoyer came in and the offense immediately changed. It was like a switch got flipped. He had time in the pocket and he stayed there. Not saying he was running up & down the field because he had plenty of suck too but you could tell who was in charge in that huddle and it was discernible. I asked a lot of folks about it today and they all agreed.

4. Special teams didn't cost us anything today, yeah!

5. Not sure what the future holds for this team but there is a definite lack of cohesion there. I think the rooks are tentative (including the coach) and the vets are either playing out the string or looking to move on. When the game was close I didn't see anybody getting jacked up about it, it was just blah.

6. Johnny wasn't as small as I thought he was and he isn't as fast as he thinks he is. He got run down a few times by big men again. When that is part of your game, that doesn't bode well for your future. He ain't gonna get any faster than he is today.

Arguably I'm not a fan but I'm willing to give MAC a shot if I thought we could win with him. I just don't get the feel from what I've seen that John Q. Football is the answer for Cleveland. Maybe a full off season taking all the snaps at #1 will make the difference but there isn't a lot to hang your hat on right now.

 
Mariota is a pipe dream for the Browns. Quit ####### around with QB's in the first round, draft some talent to put around a QB and I'll bet whoever you have slinging the rock will look markedly better.

 
i kind of feel like that's what these three games are for.if he doesn't show anything they may move on.

or at least come up with a good backup plan, i hope.
The bar should not be set as low as 80 yards without any touchdowns 2 interceptions and only 13 yards on the ground where some idiot will say 'he threw for 100 yards and ran for 30 with a score and only threw 1 pick, he's improving give him MORE TIME.' BS

The kid not only sucked he didn't show anything in camp or preseason or during the season that lead the coaching staff to have any confidence in him so why the hell should we gift him the job? Because he's a damn celebrity? Because he works soo hard? Gimme a break, kid sucks and the only way he should get any break is if he earns it and he hasn't so he's got to do something extra-ordinary just to get a shot IMHO.

The team had better be looking past this kid because he isn't worth giving any time.

Two first round picks and we still need a QB.

When we had Jeff Garcia people said, we got our QB no need to look at a free agent like Drew Brees. When we had Charlie Frye people were afraid we'd draft someone like Aaron Rodgers.

Now we've got Johnny Manziel and if anyone says to stick with him till the wheels fall off their nutz. You do not stick with a kid like Manziel especially if you have two first round picks and the rest of the team has proven they can win with a guy like Brian Hoyer who doesn't suck and he has shown he will work and earn the trust of the vets. Anyone dares to say we should stick with Manziel because they dug their heels in and think everyone else should too is an idiot. I'm not dying on the Johnny Manziel hill just because I didn't rip him from the start. I didn't want us to draft him especially in the first round. Me and Mack both wanted Teddy, I didn't want him with the 4th pick but wanted him with the 26th pick. Johnny was 'ok' with the 26th pick but I was against trading up for him but was 'ok' moving up a few spots and getting Buffalo's 2015 1st and 4th picks plus Gilbert and Manziel because I thought if Johnny sucked we'd have 2 first round picks to get a legit QB in 2015 and well he sucks so don't hesitate go get the QB because we still need one.

If people have to dig their heels in and die on some asinine argument mountain then this is mine. Kid sucks so lets go get a real quarterback in 2015.
So you are ok drafting a QB with the 26th pick and then just giving up on him after three games (if all three are bad)??

Talk about butz.

I totally agree about Johnny sucking, but if you are personally "ok" with taking a QB at 26 then throwing him away after three games, YOU are nuts.
I am because many were pimping taking a QB with the 4th pick and none were worthy of the 4th pick, I wanted Sammy but am still fine with the trade and getting the extra 1st and 4th round picks next year.

The reason I was fine with taking a QB at 26 is due to the trade because we have two first round picks next year so if the guy bombed at 26 then we have the ammo to get a QB next year, Johnny sucks so I don't hesitate and get the QB because Johnny ain't the guy and Hoyer is a stop gap till the guy arrives.

Sticking with a Johnny Manziel is insane unless you truly feel he's thee guy and I don't and the longer we wait the worse it will get because we won't have two first round picks in the future.

 
How about Cardale Jones in the 3rd-4th round if he does well against Bama and declares. If he wants playing time he will have to transfer out of OSU. If he's going to sit on the bench, why not do it in the NFL and get paid?

 
I can't imagine what you guys would have to give up to get Mariota away from the Bucs or Titans - Both of this year's ones pkus next year's as well? More?

Barring a big fall from grace ala Manziel ahead of the draft the price for him in a QB-starved league seems like it'd off the charts.

-QG

 
MAC_32 said:
How about Cardale Jones in the 3rd-4th round if he does well against Bama and declares. If he wants playing time he will have to transfer out of OSU. If he's going to sit on the bench, why not do it in the NFL and get paid?
unless it's Mariota, no qbs inside the top 200.
What?
not interested in winston, so, who else?
So because you're not interested he's suddenly not a top 200 player? That's absurd.
 
MAC_32 said:
How about Cardale Jones in the 3rd-4th round if he does well against Bama and declares. If he wants playing time he will have to transfer out of OSU. If he's going to sit on the bench, why not do it in the NFL and get paid?
unless it's Mariota, no qbs inside the top 200.
What?
not interested in winston, so, who else?
So because you're not interested he's suddenly not a top 200 player? That's absurd.
I'm sure there will be several teams that do not have him on their board.
 
MAC_32 said:
How about Cardale Jones in the 3rd-4th round if he does well against Bama and declares. If he wants playing time he will have to transfer out of OSU. If he's going to sit on the bench, why not do it in the NFL and get paid?
unless it's Mariota, no qbs inside the top 200.
What?
not interested in winston, so, who else?
So because you're not interested he's suddenly not a top 200 player? That's absurd.
I'm sure there will be several teams that do not have him on their board.
There is no way you can be sure of this.
 
Gordon, then Manziel & Justin Gilbert. Couple of swings and misses in the 1st round if Gilbert doesn't get his head out of his ###. Should be a fantastic offseason.

 
What the #### is wrong with this kid!?

How do we draft such a whining moron...

:thumbdown:

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/12081609/cleveland-browns-rookie-justin-gilbert-says-brought-criticism-himself

Justin Gilbert: 'I will be great'
Updated: December 26, 2014, 4:15 PM ET
By Pat McManamon | ESPN.comBEREA, Ohio -- Cleveland Browns cornerback Justin Gilbert said Friday he brought much of his teammates' sharp criticism on himself, but also vowed: "I will be great."

[+] EnlargeAP Photo/David RichardBrowns rookie cornerback Justin Gilbert said Friday he brought much of his teammates' sharp criticism on himself.

"I'm not mad at anyone about it," Gilbert said Friday. "I brought it upon myself. I can take that and roll with it. I messed up. But I can promise my teammates I'm going to make it right."

Gilbert would not get into specifics about what happened behind the scenes to prompt the criticism, saying what happened should stay "in the family." A source close to the team, though, said Gilbert had serious attitude issues and was frequently late to meetings.

The Browns had high hopes for Gilbert when they took him eighth overall in May's draft. But as the season progressed, he fell behind undrafted rookie K'Waun Williams, and in the most recent game in Carolina he did not play in the first quarter and watched as fourth-round Pierre Desir came off the inactive list to start and play the entire game.

He admitted he is shy and reserved, and said that might have sparked some of the feeling that his attitude is lacking. He appeared at times uncomfortable as he spoke to a group of media.

GIlbert at first said he had "no idea' where the criticism came from, but later said he "most definitely" knew.

"It has been corrected," he said. "It's not really a problem, not going to be an issue anymore."

Safety Donte Whitner said earlier in the week that Gilbert had to "stop acting like a kid," and linebacker Karlos Dansby said any growth from Gilbert had to come from him but that he was there to help.

Gilbert declined to comment on Whitner's remark.

Of general criticism, Gilbert said: "I'm not a person to judge my teammates and put it out in the media like that. If I have a problem with somebody I would address them face to face. That's just all I can say about that."

Gilbert said he expected criticism from Whitner because "he's the guy who's always just talking."

"I just sit back and listen to people," Gilbert said. "I'm not going to put out there what he was really saying."

As for reaching out to Dansby, Gilbert said: "It's something I might look into, yeah. I think I can handle that and talk to him about some things and we can see where things end going from there."

Does Gilbert know what it takes to be a professional?

"That's a question I really can't answer right now," Gilbert said.

Gilbert vowed he would work harder in the offseason and next season, and said the criticism "sparked a flame" inside him.

But he also said that some of the remarks "crossed the line a little bit."

"We're all here to do the same thing and that's win and provide for our family," Gilbert said. "Some of the things were right and some of the things could have been kept to themselves."
 
More from Gilbert... This kid doesn't get it at all!

Why Whitner?

"Because (Whitner's) the guy that's always just talking,'' said Gilbert. "I just sit back and listen to people. I'm not going to really put out there what he was saying.''

Dansby stressed that he's an open book and that Gilbert would need to come to him for the kind of wisdom that only an 11-year veteran can provide. Will he take the veteran up on it?

"It's something I might look into, yeah,'' said Gilbert. "I think I can handle that and talk to him about some things and we can see where things end up going from there.''

He disagrees with the two leaders that his rookie year was a waste.

"Not at all,'' he said. "I learned a lot this season, so I don't see how it could be a waste at all.''

Was Whitner's command to grow up fair?

"I have no comment about that,'' he said.

Asked if he struggled with maturity issues, he said, "Not at all'' and doesn't know when it hit him that he needs to work harder.

He said several players have pulled him aside and tried to help him.

"I'd say Buster Skrine and Joe Haden,'' he said. "Those are about the only two.''Does he finally know what it takes to be a pro?

"That's a question I really can't answer right now,'' he said.

 
Was it a wasted year for JG? Well, the defense played over a thousand snaps. On how many did he make an impact?

Mr. Gilbert, did you help the Browns win in 2014? If not, it was a wasted year.

 
So are the debates from earlier in the year re: drafting Gilbert & Manziel over other options now settled?

Any positives from the rest of the draft? I still think Desir could be a good CB but of course he sat almost the whole year.

 
SaintsInDome2006 said:
So are the debates from earlier in the year re: drafting Gilbert & Manziel over other options now settled?

Any positives from the rest of the draft? I still think Desir could be a good CB but of course he sat almost the whole year.
Bitonio, Crow, West, Kirksey...
 
SaintsInDome2006 said:
So are the debates from earlier in the year re: drafting Gilbert & Manziel over other options now settled?

Any positives from the rest of the draft? I still think Desir could be a good CB but of course he sat almost the whole year.
Bitonio, Crow, West, Kirksey...
yeah, the focus is on the ones but they did very well afterwards. K'Waun Williams too.
 
In all seriousness, what specifically is going on with Gilbert? I just don't understand. Is it basically that he thinks he can steal that $12 mil guaranteed and just not play football after that? Does he feel like he should be starting and is pouting? Is it that he doesn't like how many meetings there are in the NFL?

There are so many lines being printed about this kid yet nothing is actually saying what the damn problem is.

 
In all seriousness, what specifically is going on with Gilbert? I just don't understand. Is it basically that he thinks he can steal that $12 mil guaranteed and just not play football after that? Does he feel like he should be starting and is pouting? Is it that he doesn't like how many meetings there are in the NFL?

There are so many lines being printed about this kid yet nothing is actually saying what the damn problem is.
He's an athletic freak, but wasn't ever taught how to play corner back. I think he's probably instinctively resisting putting in the work to be great since he never has needed to before. That is why I didn't want him, but I'd be lying if I said I expected it to be this bad.

 
In all seriousness, what specifically is going on with Gilbert? I just don't understand. Is it basically that he thinks he can steal that $12 mil guaranteed and just not play football after that? Does he feel like he should be starting and is pouting? Is it that he doesn't like how many meetings there are in the NFL?

There are so many lines being printed about this kid yet nothing is actually saying what the damn problem is.
He's an athletic freak, but wasn't ever taught how to play corner back. I think he's probably instinctively resisting putting in the work to be great since he never has needed to before. That is why I didn't want him, but I'd be lying if I said I expected it to be this bad.
He has the raw skills, speed, athleticism, and length, to turn into an exceptional NFL CB. He flashed some this year but the book is he's consistently late for practice and workouts and it seems he's resistant to criticism and the position takes some adjusting to the NFL game.

He was a top ten draft pick and was considered the best at his position by many scouts and NFL front offices' and he heard that and knows how good he can be but it seems he lost track at some point after he inked his contract.

Look at Joe Haden this year, he look terrible for the first half but he put it together and was playing at a high level at the end.

The kid has better raw skills than Joe so I'm not writing him off yet. I think Pettine and O'Brien can work with him but its up to him to transform himself into an exceptional player and I don't know how far he'll push himself. Right now he's not making the effort so I'm fine with the criticism but he has the skill and I think he's got the coaching in place and he can make the effort but its up to him.

Manziel on the other hand, I don't think he's got the raw skill and his position requires more than just raw skill and effort, maturity plays a big role if he expects to be a leader.

The good thing heading into this offseason is Haslett has announced he will keep Pettine and Farmer and he's backing them over Josh Gordon.

 
So I know a lot of you listen to the same CLE radio I do. Jim Donovan was just on and said Justin Gilbert reported for the Houston game at 11:45am. That was a 1pm home game. And he is probably the one they keep out of the three stooges (Manziel/Gordon/Gilbert). It was an interesting 1/2 hour, with the season being over the gloves are off.

 
I'm in Cincy and don't get much of Browns coverage here except for a game or two out of Dayton. Link to the station where I can listen, or perhaps a podcast? These three fools have me shaking my head. Did they say anything specific out of JFF or Gordon being traded, or is this more of a gut feeling you have after listening? Gordon being suspended gives the Browns one more year with him under contract, correct? Was that move partially to salvage part of his contract, or make him more desireable for a trade (two years at a low rate vs one)?

 
I'm in Cincy and don't get much of Browns coverage here except for a game or two out of Dayton. Link to the station where I can listen, or perhaps a podcast? These three fools have me shaking my head. Did they say anything specific out of JFF or Gordon being traded, or is this more of a gut feeling you have after listening? Gordon being suspended gives the Browns one more year with him under contract, correct? Was that move partially to salvage part of his contract, or make him more desireable for a trade (two years at a low rate vs one)?
http://espn.go.com/espnradio/affPopup?s=wknr-am

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top