Game Thread W10 - Dallas V Green Bay (1 Viewer)

[BobbyLayne]

He was also past the line of scrimmage on the throw but they missed it.

Believe the rule book is pinnedDoesn't matter if every part of his body is over the line if his throwing arm is behind itSEE Manning, Eli circa 2008

 

[snorlax]

He was also past the line of scrimmage on the throw but they missed it.

I don't think he was completely over the line, even though he was most of the way over. Kinda like McNabb last week.That doesn't look like much of a fumble.

Yeah, I don't know the rule. His front foot and the ball were both over the line, but his back foot was still behind it. I think the rule might be that both feet must be over. It sure doesn't make a whole lot of difference though.

 

[basher]

knee is down ... still that is hugely embarrassing

 

[sho nuff]

Our wonderful special teams....good run back...penalty...fumble created by the punter...challenge....and the way its been going this year...I doubt we win the challenge.

 

[BobbyLayne]

He was also past the line of scrimmage on the throw but they missed it.

I don't think he was completely over the line, even though he was most of the way over. Kinda like McNabb last week.That doesn't look like much of a fumble.

Yeah, I don't know the rule. His front foot and the ball were both over the line, but his back foot was still behind it. I think the rule might be that both feet must be over. It sure doesn't make a whole lot of difference though.

I think nobody knew the rule until that SNF game last year when Coughlin won a challenge

 

[sho nuff]

He was also past the line of scrimmage on the throw but they missed it.

I don't think he was completely over the line, even though he was most of the way over. Kinda like McNabb last week.That doesn't look like much of a fumble.

Yeah, I don't know the rule. His front foot and the ball were both over the line, but his back foot was still behind it. I think the rule might be that both feet must be over. It sure doesn't make a whole lot of difference though.

WHole body must be over the line.His big toe can be behind the line and its legal.

 

[Bankerguy]

Should be GB ball.

 

[Stinger Ray]

lI doubt we win the challenge.

you will be wrong again

 

[basher]

The pack really miss will blackmon

 

[snorlax]

He was also past the line of scrimmage on the throw but they missed it.

I don't think he was completely over the line, even though he was most of the way over. Kinda like McNabb last week.That doesn't look like much of a fumble.

Yeah, I don't know the rule. His front foot and the ball were both over the line, but his back foot was still behind it. I think the rule might be that both feet must be over. It sure doesn't make a whole lot of difference though.

I think nobody knew the rule until that SNF game last year when Coughlin won a challenge

Really, nobody? I have no idea which game you are even talking about.

 

[Mr Anonymous]

He was also past the line of scrimmage on the throw but they missed it.

Believe the rule book is pinnedDoesn't matter if every part of his body is over the line if his throwing arm is behind itSEE Manning, Eli circa 2008

Correct on the rule. And like I said, his throwing arm and the ball were past the LOS when he threw the ball.

 

[BobbyLayne]

He was also past the line of scrimmage on the throw but they missed it.

Believe the rule book is pinnedDoesn't matter if every part of his body is over the line if his throwing arm is behind itSEE Manning, Eli circa 2008

Correct on the rule. And like I said, his throwing arm and the ball were past the LOS when he threw the ball.

uncle

 

[Chaos Commish]

Why'd they mark it at the 23? That's where the block in the back happened.

 

[parasaurolophus]

He was also past the line of scrimmage on the throw but they missed it.

Believe the rule book is pinnedDoesn't matter if every part of his body is over the line if his throwing arm is behind itSEE Manning, Eli circa 2008

Correct on the rule. And like I said, his throwing arm and the ball were past the LOS when he threw the ball.

is throwing over the LOS a loss of down penalty?

 

[Bankerguy]

Hold missed on Spears. F me.

 

[basher]

nice to see no penalty on a run play for the packers (although I think there was a hold)

 

[Bankerguy]

He was also past the line of scrimmage on the throw but they missed it.

Believe the rule book is pinnedDoesn't matter if every part of his body is over the line if his throwing arm is behind itSEE Manning, Eli circa 2008

Correct on the rule. And like I said, his throwing arm and the ball were past the LOS when he threw the ball.

is throwing over the LOS a loss of down penalty?

Yes.

 

[Mr Anonymous]

is throwing over the LOS a loss of down penalty?

Yes

 

[Manster]

nice to see no penalty on a run play for the packers (although I think there was a hold)

that was a hold

 

[basher]

Peter King saying this line is as good as Indy's was an awful thing to put in writing. I have yet to see a clean blitz pickup by this line. They all seem to panic in pressure.

 

[Bankerguy]

nice to see no penalty on a run play for the packers (although I think there was a hold)

Um yeah. See post 115.

 

[Manster]

He was also past the line of scrimmage on the throw but they missed it.

Believe the rule book is pinnedDoesn't matter if every part of his body is over the line if his throwing arm is behind itSEE Manning, Eli circa 2008

Correct on the rule. And like I said, his throwing arm and the ball were past the LOS when he threw the ball.

is throwing over the LOS a loss of down penalty?

entire body has to be over the line. Romo wasnt completely over the line

 

[Young 8]

so much for the "high scoring game"

 

[BobbyLayne]

...and appropriately, a commercial for Left for 4 Dead 2

 

[Bankerguy]

Ok how about a slant, a quick out or a bubble screen?

Need to get some rythem and tempo going.

 

[The Moz]

GB's line is not great but Rodgers does alot of it himself as well. The man holds onto the ball waaaaaaaay to long. If you are looking at at a blitz you have to throw in 2-3 seconds not hold it. Rodgers is just as much to blame as his oline is.

 

[Hitchcock Presents]

I thought I'd kill my opponent this week after he started Cutler. However, Romo only has three points. This is a familiar Sunday.

 

[Bankerguy]

Some one wake Romo up.

 

[Andy Herron]

They need to leave Choice in there for at least this series.

 

[Bankerguy]

ROY you F'ing suck

 

[basher]

GB's line is not great but Rodgers does alot of it himself as well. The man holds onto the ball waaaaaaaay to long. If you are looking at at a blitz you have to throw in 2-3 seconds not hold it. Rodgers is just as much to blame as his oline is.

Granted you can't make a quick throw when you have a 3 step drop and the center gets knocked back into you. He does hold onto the football too long but he also doesn't have room to step up and throw.

 

[Chaos Commish]

Oy

 

[Native]

ROY!!?!?!?!?!

 

[Young 8]

LMAO Roy Will

 

[Hitchcock Presents]

Roy Williams and Braylan should go out for a beer.

 

[BobbyLayne]

RoY

 

[snorlax]

I don't know about that facemask penalty on Harris. It looked like Choice was spinning and Harris's hand just glanced over the helmet.

 

[basher]

Roy being Roy ... again

 

[lyon812]

Memo to Dallas: Stop trying to make Roy Williams happy, he won't reward you.

 

[Bankerguy]

I'm losing my mind here.

 

[Hitchcock Presents]

I can't watch this anymore. Dallas does less with more talent than any other team.

 

[bentley]

Quote:

To get Williams the Cowboys gave up their first-round pick, third-round pick, and a sixth-round pick

Quote:

Williams has caught only 14 of 37 passes thrown his way this season. Only four receivers in the league who have been targeted at least 25 times have caught a lower percentage of passes aimed at them.

Quote:

In 16 games with the Cowboys, Williams has produced 33 catches for 447 yards and three touchdowns.

Quote:

Roy's catch % by year (and QB):

2004: 45.8% (Harrington, who completed 56% of his passes)

2005: 47.9% (Harrington & Garcia, 58%)

2006: 54.3% (Kitna, 62%) <-- Mike Furrey caught 67.1% of his passes by the way

2007: 60.6% (Kitna, 63%) <-- Furrey at 67.8%, Shaun McDonald at 62.2%

2008: 43.9% (mostly Orlovsky at 56%, then Romo at 61%)

2009: 37.8% (Romo, 60%)

 

[Chaos Commish]

Roy Williams and Braylan should go out for a beer.

Waste of beer.

 

[Bogart]

This game feels like Dallas is down by 21.

 

[Andy Herron]

I am so disgusted with Roy Williams it's not even funny.

If he catches that ball we're still driving.

 

[basher]

This game feels like Dallas is down by 21.

Thank the packers for inopportune penalties and poor offensive play.

 

[bentley]

Roy Williams and Braylan should go out for a beer.

Waste of beer.

Plus the bottles would just keep breaking as they slid off the bar when the bartender pushed them at Roy.

 

[snorlax]

Roy Williams and Braylan should go out for a beer.

Waste of beer.

Yeah, I assume a lot of it would get dropped on the bar floor.

 

[Bankerguy]

Columbo broken Fibula.

Brooking great play!

 

[Chaos Commish]

Eagles 9

Chargers 28