I'm sorry I've read this whole thread, hoping for something usefull.The bottom line is that Bush has been dissapointing in his first couple of seasons by almost any measuring stick, BUT has shown enough that NO isn't ready to write him off, and many FF owners aren't ready to either.To me, he's a very safe pick in redraft as it's likely he'll have enough opportunities to at least justify his ADP, plus has enough upside to have a chance to do better. He's especially attractive in PPR.He's a lot tougher in dynasty, because if he doesn't improve his YPA/C, his opportunities will surely decrease. The reason the debate is so hot is because he's so unconventional in how he gets his yards/fantasy points that the traditional measuring sticks don't seem very adequate, particularly given how he's used and the injury he played through last year.I can't fault anyone steering clear, nor can I fault anyone who's targetting him. This is one of those guys we are not likely to ever get a clear consesus on. Personally, I like him as an RB2 in PPR dynasty, and will buy at that price, or sell at low RB1.