Jeff Pasquino
Footballguy
Team Legacy
QB
Carson Palmer, QB, CIN 5
Charlie Frye, QB, CLE 6
I like Palmer (obviously a good QB from last year) should he be 100% come September. I also like the Cleveland offense, and it is really interesting if you look at Frye's numbers in 05 vs. Eli's in 04. His supporting cast got a lot better as well.
Edwards would help if he's 100% as well, but I like JJ and Winslow coming back.
GRADE: B+ (A-/A if Palmer is a go Week 1).
RB
Deuce McAllister, RB, NO 7
Michael Bennett, RB, NO 7
Ron Dayne, RB, DEN 4
Tatum Bell, RB, DEN 4
TJ Duckett, RB, ATL 5
I need to see Deuce and how "back" he is. If he is the Deuce of 03/04, this is a nice RB1 pick. Bell would be a good RB2 and this would be a strong group with Dayne/Bennett as good handcuffs. Duckett can also punch in some TDs which always helps.
GRADE: C+ but B/B- if Deuce is 100%.
WR
Steve Smith, WR, CAR 9
Eddie Kennison, WR, KC 3
Drew Bennett, WR, TEN 7
Brandon Stokley, WR, IND 6
Robert Ferguson, WR, GB 6
Todd Pinkston, WR, PHI 9
Smith will get far more attention this year, but he's still a Top 10 WR. Kennison consistently puts up good numbers in the KC offense. WR3 is likely Bennett, who could also post nice numbers with either McNair or Volek. TEs in TEN may diminish his targets, but still a solid option.
Pinkston is likely the 2/3 option in Philly in a pass/pass/run offense. He could contribute on occasion, as could Fergie. Stokley also sees plenty of playing time, so overall a very good group.
GRADE: A.
TE
Randy McMichael, TE, MIA 8
Kevin Everett, TE, BUF 8
McMichael will likely be the 2nd most targeted Dolphin after Chambers despite the WR2 in Miami (whomever that will be - Booker or Welker).
I don't like the Buffalo TE pick, even if Everett wins the job.
Grade: B- due to really having one TE (I see no value from Everett).
PK
Shayne Graham, PK CIN 5
Matt Bryant, PK, TB 4
Joe Nedney, PK, SF 7
Three kickes - I'd love to know why, especially with Graham as one of them. Bryant is a nice PK2, so Nedney seemed like a very odd pickup.
GRADE: B+
DEF
Baltimore Ravens, DEF 7
Philadelphia Eagles, DEF 9
I love Philly's D this year to bounce back. The schedule is also favorable for the D to post some lower scoring games. Ball hawking / sacks will be the question. Baltimore is usually a solid choice, but they are aging. Ed Reed / Ray Ray will usually get you some points.
GRADE: B.
OVERALL
The strength is at WR, with 6 good choices. I would have liked to see a 7th WR over a third kicker, but so be it. Good lineup at QB, K and D. TE is one guy really at McMichael, but he should produce. RB is the weak link, and two players (Palmer, Deuce) coming off of injuries will make or break this team. If both are healthy and perform as before, watch out. Big if, though. Overall - very solid team with a shot at winning. Very solid job drafting especially from the last spot.
OVERALL GRADE: A-.
QB
Carson Palmer, QB, CIN 5
Charlie Frye, QB, CLE 6
I like Palmer (obviously a good QB from last year) should he be 100% come September. I also like the Cleveland offense, and it is really interesting if you look at Frye's numbers in 05 vs. Eli's in 04. His supporting cast got a lot better as well.
Edwards would help if he's 100% as well, but I like JJ and Winslow coming back.
GRADE: B+ (A-/A if Palmer is a go Week 1).
RB
Deuce McAllister, RB, NO 7
Michael Bennett, RB, NO 7
Ron Dayne, RB, DEN 4
Tatum Bell, RB, DEN 4
TJ Duckett, RB, ATL 5
I need to see Deuce and how "back" he is. If he is the Deuce of 03/04, this is a nice RB1 pick. Bell would be a good RB2 and this would be a strong group with Dayne/Bennett as good handcuffs. Duckett can also punch in some TDs which always helps.
GRADE: C+ but B/B- if Deuce is 100%.
WR
Steve Smith, WR, CAR 9
Eddie Kennison, WR, KC 3
Drew Bennett, WR, TEN 7
Brandon Stokley, WR, IND 6
Robert Ferguson, WR, GB 6
Todd Pinkston, WR, PHI 9
Smith will get far more attention this year, but he's still a Top 10 WR. Kennison consistently puts up good numbers in the KC offense. WR3 is likely Bennett, who could also post nice numbers with either McNair or Volek. TEs in TEN may diminish his targets, but still a solid option.
Pinkston is likely the 2/3 option in Philly in a pass/pass/run offense. He could contribute on occasion, as could Fergie. Stokley also sees plenty of playing time, so overall a very good group.
GRADE: A.
TE
Randy McMichael, TE, MIA 8
Kevin Everett, TE, BUF 8
McMichael will likely be the 2nd most targeted Dolphin after Chambers despite the WR2 in Miami (whomever that will be - Booker or Welker).
I don't like the Buffalo TE pick, even if Everett wins the job.
Grade: B- due to really having one TE (I see no value from Everett).
PK
Shayne Graham, PK CIN 5
Matt Bryant, PK, TB 4
Joe Nedney, PK, SF 7
Three kickes - I'd love to know why, especially with Graham as one of them. Bryant is a nice PK2, so Nedney seemed like a very odd pickup.
GRADE: B+
DEF
Baltimore Ravens, DEF 7
Philadelphia Eagles, DEF 9
I love Philly's D this year to bounce back. The schedule is also favorable for the D to post some lower scoring games. Ball hawking / sacks will be the question. Baltimore is usually a solid choice, but they are aging. Ed Reed / Ray Ray will usually get you some points.
GRADE: B.
OVERALL
The strength is at WR, with 6 good choices. I would have liked to see a 7th WR over a third kicker, but so be it. Good lineup at QB, K and D. TE is one guy really at McMichael, but he should produce. RB is the weak link, and two players (Palmer, Deuce) coming off of injuries will make or break this team. If both are healthy and perform as before, watch out. Big if, though. Overall - very solid team with a shot at winning. Very solid job drafting especially from the last spot.
OVERALL GRADE: A-.